Shift Work, Hazardous Conditions, and Strenuous Labor
Work-Relatedness Recognized Despite Average Weekly Hours Below 52

A 41-year-old worker who was working in the basement mechanical room of a Seoul hotel collapsed during a night shift and died of a brain hemorrhage. The first- and second-instance courts did not recognize the death as work-related, ruling that his working hours fell short of the threshold for overwork. The Supreme Court, however, reached a different conclusion. It said the case should be reconsidered, taking into account both his 12 years of shift work and his working conditions.


[Shift Work in a Basement Mechanical Room]


Mr. A had worked in facility management at the Sheraton Seoul Palace Gangnam Hotel, which has since closed, since 2012. He worked day and night shifts in the basement mechanical room, cleaning air conditioners and air-handling units, draining water from sauna baths, and maintaining boilers and other facilities.


His work schedule also varied considerably. Although a set schedule was supposed to be followed, it was not properly observed in the months before his death.


Noise of around 78.5 dB, comparable to the sound of a vacuum cleaner, was constantly produced in the mechanical room. He was also exposed to hazardous substances, including mineral dust, welding fumes, chromium, and manganese. He was frequently injured while repairing facilities in the cramped spaces of the aging hotel, and had to respond to complaints from staff and customers each time repairs were made.


Mr. A collapsed during a night shift in April 2019 and died. The cause of death was a brain hemorrhage. His spouse filed a claim for survivors' benefits and funeral expenses, arguing that the death was work-related, but sued after the Korea Workers' Compensation and Welfare Service rejected the claim.


[Lower Courts Reject Work-Relatedness]


The first- and second-instance courts did not recognize the death as work-related, ruling that Mr. A had worked an average of about 40 hours per week in the 12 weeks before his death, below the threshold for overwork. They also found that personal health issues may have contributed to the brain hemorrhage.


[Supreme Court Ruling (Summary)]


On October 27, 2026, the Supreme Court's Special Division 1, with Justice Ma Yong-ju presiding, overturned the lower court's ruling and remanded the case to the Seoul High Court (2024Du40400). Mr. A was represented by attorney Seo Bo-yeol, a graduate of the 35th class of the Judicial Research and Training Institute.


- Including his previous job, Mr. A had worked shifts for about 12 years. Long-term night work can cause fatigue and stress to build up and increase the risk of vascular disease.


- Mr. A was 41 and had no history of cerebrovascular disease, but his blood pressure rose to the hypertensive range while he was working shifts.


- If shift work, hazardous working conditions, and strenuous physical labor overlapped, a connection between the work and the brain hemorrhage could be recognized even if his average weekly working hours were below 52. The lower court erred by failing to examine these factors.



Ahn Jaemyeong, The Law Times reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing