[Reporter's Notebook] The Authority of the Law Is Realized Not in Court Rulings, but in Enforcement on the Ground
Redevelopment Eviction Disputes and Unlawful Occupation of Public Facilities
Recurring Enforcement Delays Add to Social Costs
Protecting Legitimate Rights While Firmly Addressing Unlawful Acts
Fair and Consistent Law Enforcement Is Key
Even after a court issues a final ruling, further difficulties arise in putting that decision into effect on the ground.
Even a lawful administrative disposition can fail to achieve its original purpose if subsequent procedures are delayed. The gap between legal judgments and their real-world enforcement raises questions about how effectively the rule of law works in our society.
The rule of law is not fulfilled merely by enacting laws and issuing rulings. The authority of law is established only when decisions made in accordance with legally prescribed procedures are carried out fairly and the same standards are applied to everyone.
In reality, however, enforcement is sometimes delayed even after legal disputes have been resolved, owing to physical resistance and conflicts of interest. This can increase social costs and prolong disputes.
Disputes over the enforcement of eviction orders at redevelopment and reconstruction sites are a prime example.
Even when legal disputes over the handover of land and buildings have ended, physical clashes during compulsory enforcement can disrupt project schedules. Financing and management costs may rise, and the resulting burden may be passed on to association members and other stakeholders.
The unlawful occupation of public facilities is another example.
Unauthorized occupation of public facilities such as rivers, valleys, and roads, or the installation of illegal structures, restricts the public’s rightful use of them. If lawful corrective orders and measures to restore the sites to their original condition are repeatedly ignored, the effectiveness of public administration will inevitably decline.
Consistent law enforcement is also a major challenge in crimes that harm people’s livelihoods, including illegal acts in real estate transactions, various forms of collusion and corruption, online fraud, and illegal private lending.
If the perception spreads that profits from unlawful acts outweigh the costs of legal liability, law-abiding citizens may end up at a disadvantage. This goes beyond simple violations of the law and can undermine trust among members of society.
That does not mean, however, that every delay in enforcement can be characterized as unlawful resistance.
Redevelopment and public-facility improvement projects involve a range of rights, including property rights, housing rights, the right to livelihood, and business rights. Parties’ legitimate objections and the remedies provided by law must be fully respected.
However, the exercise of legitimate rights must be distinguished from unlawful obstruction of enforcement. Just as the protection of legitimate rights cannot serve as grounds for immunity from unlawful acts, strict law enforcement must not depart from procedural legitimacy or the principle of proportionality.
The crux of the issue is fairness and consistency, not the speed of enforcement.
If responses to the same unlawful acts vary according to the parties’ status or financial means, or the size and influence of a group, the principle of equality before the law loses credibility.
Law enforcement agencies must protect citizens’ fundamental rights while ensuring that legal judgments finalized through due process are not unjustly rendered ineffective. They also need to assess repeated obstruction of enforcement and unlawful occupation, coordinate among relevant agencies, and monitor conditions after enforcement.
Administrative agencies, too, must continuously check whether their orders are being carried out, rather than limiting their response to unlawful acts to one-time crackdowns. The effectiveness of law enforcement should be measured not by the number of orders issued but by how much the unlawful conditions have actually been remedied.
Oversight of the exercise of public authority must not be neglected either. Excessive force or procedural violations cannot be justified on the grounds that the law is being enforced. Establishing the rule of law and protecting fundamental rights are not competing goals, one of which must be sacrificed for the other.
The foundations of the rule of law are the equal application of the law without exception and fair procedures.
If the pattern continues in which people who obey the law suffer losses while those who break it benefit by holding out, public trust in the legal order will inevitably erode.
The administrative powers of the national and local governments must be devoted to protecting the rights and interests of law-abiding citizens. At the same time, legality and fairness must be ensured throughout every stage of law enforcement.
The authority of the law does not come from harsh punishment, but from the belief that the same standards apply to everyone.
Those who break the law must be held appropriately accountable, while legitimate rights must be protected to the end. The state authorities that enforce the law must also be subject to it.
The principles the rule of law must uphold are clear.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The law must not yield to power, but public authority must not stand above the law either. Trust in the rule of law depends on how consistently that balance is upheld on the ground.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.