[Workarounds at Non-Membership Golf Courses] Quasi-Membership Rights That Skirt the Law

Culture Ministry to Review Membership Recruitment; Tax Authorities to Check Tax Benefits
Board of Audit and Inspection Review of Oversight Also Needed

As sales of quasi-membership rights at non-membership golf courses have spread through lodging facility sales and monetary loan agreements, the government urgently needs to strengthen oversight and supervision. Critics say the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism and local governments should conduct joint fact-finding inspections, while tax authorities should verify tax benefits, to identify membership-style operations concealed by the formal structure of contracts.

Quasi-Membership Rights Face Oversight Gaps... Supervision Standards Need Overhaul View original image

According to the golf industry on November 13, the current Sports Facilities Act generally prohibits non-membership golf courses from recruiting members. Limited exceptions may be allowed for products linked to lodging facilities, making it difficult to determine whether a practice is illegal based on the form of a contract alone. When the product seller and golf course operator are different entities, the contractual relationships become complex, and reservation priority or other benefits offered to specific customers are not readily apparent.


Joint fact-finding inspections by the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism and local governments are considered a priority. Such inspections would examine contract periods, the number of permitted visits, and whether reservation priority is granted, and compare those terms with actual reservation and check-in records. Key areas for review would also include whether use opportunities are concentrated among certain contract holders and whether reservations by ordinary golfers have been restricted.


Verification by tax authorities is also necessary. The National Tax Service should examine whether the individual consumption tax levied on golf course admissions is appropriate, while local tax authorities should separately review whether public-type golf courses meet the requirements for property tax treatment. Selling quasi-membership rights does not in itself mean tax evasion. If violations are confirmed after examining the actual business practices and applicable tax requirements, the authorities can take appropriate action.


Calls have also been made for the Board of Audit and Inspection to review how oversight has been carried out. An audit of Milyang S-Park CC revealed a method of raising funds that differed from the original business plan, making it necessary to determine whether the supervisory authorities properly monitored compliance with the plan. It is also worth examining whether other golf courses have raised funds in similar ways.

Quasi-Membership Rights Face Oversight Gaps... Supervision Standards Need Overhaul View original image

Institutional reforms should focus on determining the rights actually granted to users rather than the names given to contracts. Review criteria should be made more specific so authorities can determine whether products sold by separate entities, rather than by golf course operators, effectively grant membership privileges such as reservation priority or guaranteed long-term access. Relevant standards should also be clarified to ensure that oversight covers attempts to circumvent regulations by separating the contracting parties.



Strengthening consumer protections is another task. When a product is sold by an entity separate from the operator, existing benefits may be discontinued if the golf course is sold or its business deteriorates. Critics say contracts should specify who is responsible for providing the service and the conditions for transferring rights, and that buyers should be able to check in advance information about deposit refund obligations and the seller's ability to pay.

Quasi-Membership Rights Face Oversight Gaps... Supervision Standards Need Overhaul View original image

Seo Cheonbeom, head of the Korea Golf Consumer Agency, said, "The administration should conduct inspections of non-membership golf courses engaging in improper practices, together with local governments that have authority over golf course management and supervision, and issue corrective orders." He added, "Effective follow-up measures are needed, including business suspensions and tax assessments for failure to comply with corrective orders."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing