National University of Singapore Professor Shin Jangseop: “Corporations are independent legal entities, not shareholders’ property... Corporate governance should be viewed from a long-term prosperity perspective”

Professor Shin Jang-seop of the Department of Economics at the National University of Singapore speaks at the Future Economy Research Center's third monthly forum (Photo courtesy of Seoul National University's Future Economy Research Center)

Professor Shin Jang-seop of the Department of Economics at the National University of Singapore speaks at the Future Economy Research Center's third monthly forum (Photo courtesy of Seoul National University's Future Economy Research Center)

View original image

The Future Economic Research Center at Seoul National University’s Institute of Economic Research, led by Professor Lee Jihong, held its third monthly forum on November 6 at Wooseok Economic Hall at Seoul National University. The forum was organized to explore desirable directions for corporate governance and featured an in-depth discussion under the theme “Why Do Corporations Exist? Beyond Shareholder Value Theory and Stakeholder Theory.”


Shin Jang-seop, a professor in the Department of Economics at the National University of Singapore, delivered the presentation, while Kim Byungyeon, a distinguished professor at Seoul National University, chaired the forum. Scholars and experts from Korea and abroad also attended to discuss the purpose of corporations and desirable directions for corporate governance.


Professor Shin graduated from Seoul National University’s Department of Economics and earned a Ph.D. in economics from the University of Cambridge in the United Kingdom. He has taught economics at the National University of Singapore since 1999. He has continued to conduct research and publish extensively on topics including the growth of the Korean economy, industrial policy, and corporate governance, and has also shared his views on current economic issues through media articles and interviews.


In particular, in his 2020 book What Is a Corporation?, he set out the “Eight Propositions on Corporations,” explaining the nature of corporations with a focus on their status as independent legal entities and on market competition. This year, he published the English-language book Why Do Corporations Exist? with Cambridge University Press, proposing a new framework for understanding corporations that goes beyond shareholder value theory and stakeholder theory.


In his presentation, Professor Shin said, “As debate over the purpose of corporations has become polarized between shareholder value theory and stakeholder theory, understanding of the very nature of corporations and the principles by which they operate has in fact become inadequate.”


Shareholder value theory identifies maximizing shareholder value as a corporation’s purpose, while stakeholder theory points to realizing social value. However, both theories are limited in that they view corporations not as independent legal entities but as tools for achieving specific objectives. A corporation’s identity, as illustrated by The New York Times’ pursuit of journalistic integrity or Samsung Group’s philosophy of “serving the nation through business,” is difficult to explain fully through shareholder or stakeholder theory alone.


“Only by properly understanding the ontology of corporations can we properly understand their purpose,” Professor Shin explained. “We first need to examine the legal and economic entities corporations exist as and how they operate.” To do so, he presented the “Eight Propositions on Corporations,” starting from two fundamental principles—“the corporation as a joint-stock company established through incorporation” and “market competition”—and explaining such features as the corporation’s independent ownership of assets, the separation of ownership and control, and corporate continuity.


“Shareholders own shares, but they do not own the corporation; the corporation itself is owned by the legal entity,” he said. “Shareholders oversee and check management by appointing and dismissing directors, among other means, but the board and management bear responsibility for business decisions and management.”


Professor Shin emphasized the discretion of boards and management. In this connection, he discussed the Delaware Supreme Court’s decision in the Time case, explaining how Time’s board responded to Paramount’s hostile tender offer while pursuing a merger with Warner. The case shows that even when shareholders are offered a higher short-term sale price, management can make decisions based on the company’s long-term strategy and identity, and have those decisions respected.


“We should view corporations not simply as vehicles for generating returns for shareholders, but as ‘long-term prosperity communities’ that seek long-term survival and growth,” Professor Shin said.


He added, “For corporations to endure amid market competition, they must continue to innovate and invest for the long term, and the discretion of management and decision-making systems that support these efforts are important. To this end, companies should establish board-centered leadership and a vision unique to each company, and build compensation systems linked to long-term performance.”


He noted in particular that “differences in interests can arise between management, which is responsible for a company’s long-term survival, and financial investors with diverse investment objectives.”


Professor Shin observed that “fund managers are also merely agents of investors,” adding that “there is no guarantee that the objectives of those entrusted with managing funds will always align with a company’s objectives.” He emphasized that “the common ground is medium- to long-term performance.” He added, “Management and investors should communicate with a focus on a company’s sustained growth and the enhancement of its value over the medium to long term, rather than on short-term efforts to boost its share price.”


He also said that “shareholder return policies, such as share buybacks, do not necessarily lead to higher share prices over the medium to long term.” Citing overseas companies including Intel, General Electric (GE), and TSMC, Professor Shin argued that “what fundamentally determines a share price over the medium to long term is not share buybacks, but a company’s operating performance and vision over that period.”


As global competition for technological supremacy intensifies, it will be important to seek long-term governance models suited to the characteristics of each industry and encourage companies to strengthen their fundamentals, rather than blindly pursuing short-term shareholder value.


The discussion that followed focused on the assessment of long-term corporate value, the role of corporate bylaws, the role of government, and recent trends in the Korean stock market.


Kim Byungyeon, the forum’s chair and a distinguished professor at Seoul National University, said, “It was a fresh perspective to emphasize that corporations should secure a degree of independence from shareholder influence and that management should have the discretion to make decisions from a long-term perspective.” He added, “Viewing corporations as independent legal entities rather than as the property of shareholders offers new insights for debates on corporate governance.”



Lee Jihong, director of the Future Economic Research Center, said, “Given Korea’s manufacturing-centered industrial structure, concerns have grown that capital market reform could tilt excessively toward shareholder capitalism.” He added, “With the harm caused by the short-termism of private equity funds becoming apparent, it is time for the financial and fair-trade authorities to promptly review the regulatory framework in line with the principles of long-term investment and market competition.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing