"A 210,000-Follower Influencer Is a Recluse? It's All an Act"... Depression-Based Military Service Classifications Surge 11-Fold in 10 Years
Surge in Grade IV and V classifications for depressive disorders
From 223 in 2013 to 2,493 last year
210,000-follower influencer used false medical certificates
On the ground: "Limited criteria, staff shortages"
Influencer A, 28, who has 210,000 social media followers, played two roles ahead of his conscription physical examination. While remaining active online, he acted at hospitals as if he led a reclusive life, saying, "I'm afraid of people, so I stay shut in at home even during the day." After being classified as eligible for alternative service based on false medical certificates, he stopped both psychiatric treatment and medication.
A confidently told people around him, "I have a story, so I won't get caught," but was exposed after an acquaintance reported him and the Military Manpower Administration's special judicial police investigated. In May, the Seoul Northern District Court sentenced A, who had been indicted on charges of violating the Military Service Act, to one year and six months in prison, suspended for three years. [Related article='Avoiding military service by "pretending to be a reclusive loner"... 210,000-follower influencer gets suspended sentence']
A conscript descends the stairs at the Seoul Regional Military Manpower Administration's conscription examination center in Yeongdeungpo-gu, Seoul. A sign above reads, "Proud to fulfill my military service! I am proud of myself." Photo by Park Hosu.
View original imageRecently, cases of young people in their 20s being classified as Grade IV (supplementary service) or Grade V (wartime labor service) due to depression have surged. The number of people exempted from military service or assigned to alternative service, such as social service personnel, has risen sharply. Attempts to evade military service by exaggerating or fabricating symptoms have also increased.
Those caught faking mental illness: 7 → 44
According to data submitted by the Military Manpower Administration to The Asia Business Daily on November 10, the number of people classified as Grade IV or V due to depressive disorders rose from 223 in 2013 to 2,493 last year, an 11.2-fold increase in just over a decade. As of the end of September this year, 2,024 people had already received such classifications, nearing last year's level.
The increase is even more striking given the decline in the total number of people undergoing examinations. The number of examinees fell from 364,148 in 2013 to 222,425 last year, while the share of people with mental illnesses among all those classified as Grade IV or V rose from the high teens in 2023 to around 35% last year.
As mental illness classifications rise, so do crimes involving evasion of military service. The number of people referred for prosecution by the Military Manpower Administration's special judicial police after they were caught faking mental illness rose from around 7 in 2013 to 27 in 2024 and 44 last year. Another 23 people were caught through September this year. Those on the front lines say they struggle to determine whether claims are genuine, as limitations in the classification criteria coincide with staff shortages.
Park Jinwoo, a psychiatrist who until recently worked as a dedicated conscription examiner at the Seoul Regional Military Manpower Administration, said, "The basic principle of psychiatric care is to believe a patient's suffering." He added, "But at conscription examinations, we have to constantly suspect malingering, which creates a professional dilemma."
Confusing revisions to examination rules drive surge in Grade IV and V classifications
The confusion has deepened since the Ministry of National Defense revised its physical examination rules in 2024. The revised rules narrowed the criteria for a Grade III classification, which qualifies a person for active military service, to cases in which there is "no impairment in social or occupational functioning." Park said, "It's difficult to be certain that an examinee receiving treatment and taking medication has no functional impairment at all." He explained, "Even when someone appears capable of adjusting to military life, examiners often assign Grade IV or V because they worry that problems could arise later." Indeed, immediately after the rules were revised, the number of people classified as Grade IV or V by psychiatric departments surged 20.4% (1,207 people) in a single year, from 5,914 in 2023 to 7,121 in 2024.
There are measures to identify examinees who raise suspicions. When signs of irregularity appear, the Military Manpower Administration conducts a so-called "malingering test" or refers the person for a detailed assessment at the Daegu Central Conscription Examination Center. The Daegu center even checks examinees' bank deposits and withdrawals and call records to verify whether they are genuinely unable to manage daily life.
However, some say that examiners on the front lines lack both the authority and the infrastructure to identify suspicious cases. Park said, "At the Seoul Regional Military Manpower Administration, there are around four psychiatrists per examination team, but at regional offices there are only one or two per examination department." He added, "If an examinee submits hundreds of pages of medical records, the interview and review alone take nearly an hour."
There is also a shortage of clinical psychologists who can determine whether symptoms have been exaggerated. Even when psychological testing is requested, it takes considerable time to receive the results. As a result, it is difficult to identify every false claim on site, and cases are repeatedly uncovered only later through reports from acquaintances or subsequent investigations.
The Ministry of National Defense plans to revise the physical examination rules starting January 1, 2027. It will extend the observation period for assessing the persistence, severity, and recurrence of mental illnesses from the current minimum of six months to at least one year, and tighten the classification criteria for conditions that are particularly vulnerable to abuse, such as addiction disorders.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Experts, however, say that simply extending the assessment period has its limits, since people could build up a long treatment history in advance to evade military service. They say a system is needed to precisely assess the extent of functional impairment in daily life. Kwon Junsu, a professor of psychiatry at Seoul National University Hospital, said, "We need to precisely assess the actual level of functional impairment in each patient." He stressed, "It is urgent to expand the mental health workforce so that thorough examinations and verification can be carried out."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.