Debate over expanding rotational transfers heats up after the "Jang Yun-gi case"
Can transferring officers to another region be expected to stamp out collusion-related misconduct?
Opinion: "Expansion would be difficult without securing a budget"

As controversy has mounted over a series of cases in which police investigations were deemed inadequate, including the “Jang Yun-gi case,” expanding the rotational transfer system has been raised as a possible solution. However, it has emerged that the Police Investigation Reform Committee said the causal link between collusion-related misconduct and the system was unclear. The position is that an unconditional expansion of the system would be difficult without securing a budget, given the practical challenges it could pose for frontline officers, including housing, childcare and long commutes.


Members of the National Police Workplace Council (Jikhyeop) chant slogans including “Oppose Forced Rotational Transfers” in front of the National Police Agency in Seodaemun-gu, Seoul, on the afternoon of July 29, ahead of a joint meeting of police workplace councils from across the country. Yonhap News Agency

Members of the National Police Workplace Council (Jikhyeop) chant slogans including “Oppose Forced Rotational Transfers” in front of the National Police Agency in Seodaemun-gu, Seoul, on the afternoon of July 29, ahead of a joint meeting of police workplace councils from across the country. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

In written responses to reporters at a press briefing on November 9, Acting Korean National Police Agency Commissioner General Kim Jongcheol said, “The committee’s view was that the causal link between collusion-related misconduct and rotational transfers was unclear. It also said that the improvements being considered by the National Police Agency should be clearly highlighted so the public can easily understand them.” He said the views raised at the committee meeting on November 2 included that the causal link between collusion-related misconduct and rotational transfers was unclear, that it would be difficult to implement the proposed improvements (expansion) without securing a budget, and that the changes resulting from improvements to the rotational transfer system needed to be highlighted.


“To develop reasonable and feasible measures, we gathered a broad range of opinions from frontline employees and outside experts over about three months and reported the findings to the committee,” Acting Commissioner General Kim said. He dismissed the claim, saying, “It is entirely untrue that there was an opinion at the committee that the measures should be stronger than those under review.”


At last month’s National Assembly audit of the National Police Agency by the Public Administration and Security Committee, Acting Commissioner General Kim was asked by Joo Hoyoung of the People Power Party whether a more sophisticated system should be devised to ease opposition to expanding rotational transfers. He replied, “It is true that implementing rotational transfers for frontline employees as well would place a considerable burden on them,” adding that “it would be difficult in practice unless housing or transportation subsidies were provided as a prerequisite.”


The National Police Workplace Council, which functions like a labor union for police, strongly opposes a uniform expansion of the rotational transfer system. It says exchanges between metropolitan and provincial police agencies should be expanded, focusing on senior officers at the rank of superintendent and above who have substantive influence over investigations, personnel, inspections and command, rather than general staff. The National Police Agency is gathering feedback from frontline officers through online surveys, internal bulletin boards and an on-site advisory group.



Meanwhile, in an internal survey conducted by the National Police Agency in August, 85.4% of 9,611 police officers opposed expanding rotational transfers, citing long commutes, childcare responsibilities and a decline in professional expertise.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing