Midterm Defeat, the Result of Trump's Populism [Economic Insight] View original image

Before the Brexit vote in June 2016, the BBC reported that “if Brexit becomes a reality, it could signal a victory for Donald Trump in the U.S. presidential election in November.” Brexit and the Trump surge shared a common thread: anger among lower- and middle-income groups in developed countries whose economic circumstances had worsened because of free trade and immigration. The same was true of resentment toward established politicians and elites. The outcome matched the BBC’s prediction.


Ten years later, the United Kingdom is reassessing Brexit. At the Labour Party conference on September 29, Prime Minister Andy Burnham said the damage caused by Brexit had outweighed its benefits and announced that he would present several options for the United Kingdom’s long-term relationship with the European Union (EU). In effect, he proposed a national debate on rejoining the EU. Last month, Burnham also appeared on the political podcast The Rest Is Politics, where he publicly said that Russia had interfered in the Brexit referendum.


Just as Brexit is being rejected in the United Kingdom, Trump recently suffered a crushing defeat in the midterm elections. The prolonged U.S.-Iran war and the resulting surge in oil prices and inflation have been cited as major causes. But the failure of manufacturing to rebound and economic polarization to improve, contrary to Trump’s promises, as well as the serious side effects of tariffs and anti-immigration policies, also played a major role.


It is almost common sense that Brexit and Trump-style tariffs do not help the economy. Even before the Brexit vote, although Brexit could curb immigration, economic costs were expected, including weaker export competitiveness due to trade barriers with the EU, the departure of multinational companies, and a decline in foreign direct investment. Even before Trump was elected, many predicted that rising tariffs would be passed through to import prices and push up consumer prices, while anti-immigration policies would sharply reduce the supply of low-wage workers and drive up service prices.


Brexit and Trump may have given voice to the anger of white men with a high school education or less who felt economically deprived as they were left behind by globalization, the rise of the innovation economy, and the resulting shift toward more advanced industrial structures. They may have offered an outlet for those feelings, but they could not solve the fundamental problem of economic polarization. That is why Brexit and Trump are described as populist.


If Brexit and Trump fail to solve fundamental problems and cause various side effects, policies are likely to revert to what they were before. That process is already underway. Even after the midterm defeat, Trump-style high tariffs may remain in place for some time with the support of Democrats, who have traditionally favored protectionism. But if the adverse effects become more pronounced, the tariffs will inevitably be scaled back.


Majority rule is an excellent system for resolving conflict by securing the acceptance of opposing forces and bringing them together. But repeatedly straying from a desirable course and then returning to it increases inefficiency. That is why we must remain vigilant against populism.


Turning to South Korea, public opinion has soured amid a sharp drop in stock prices. Setting target levels for prices determined by the market, such as stock prices and exchange rates, is itself a problem. Market prices are shaped by the combined effects of various economic conditions. If the government steps in as though it must achieve a particular target, the adverse consequences are all too predictable. It is also almost common sense that the government should not intervene excessively in prices in the financial markets.



In particular, the deferral of the National Pension Service’s rebalancing from January through June this year and the introduction of leveraged exchange-traded funds (ETFs) can only be suspected of being attempts to boost the stock market ahead of the June local elections. These policies of the Lee Jae-myung administration are populist, too. The government must not make the mistake of intervening again in an attempt to reverse the recent sharp drop in stock prices.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing