[Contribution] The Weight of the Throne
Professor Park Seongsu, Department of Leisure Sports Instruction, Mokpo National University
View original imageA month has already passed since the 20th Aichi-Nagoya Asian Games came to a close. Leaving that brilliant glory behind, national team athletes are likely working up a sweat in their respective places as they strive to take another step forward. Glory and wounds, joy and frustration: these are experiences every athlete goes through, but the effort required to win the glory of a gold medal does not come easily to everyone.
The moment athletes put on the national team uniform, they represent not just themselves but the country. The Taegeuk mark carries honor, and athletes who reach the top at international competitions receive applause, awards and various institutional benefits. Among these, the issue that tends to be most sensitive in our society is the military service benefit available to male athletes.
This benefit is often called an "exemption from military service," but the system does not eliminate military service itself. Under the current system, Olympic medalists who finish third or higher and Asian Games gold medalists may be assigned to serve as arts and sports personnel. After completing three weeks of basic military training, they serve for a set period in their respective fields and fulfill obligations that include military education and volunteer activities using their specialized skills. The Military Manpower Administration also describes the system as one in which people serve as arts and sports personnel instead of performing regular military service.
Even so, the reality as experienced by athletes and the public is different. For male athletes whose careers may be interrupted by active-duty service, an Olympic medal or an Asian Games gold medal can be significant enough to change the course of their athletic careers. As a result, whenever a major international competition begins, the same strange situation recurs: "Who will receive the military service benefit?" draws more attention than athletic performance or the responsibilities of representing the country.
Recently, the controversy has resurfaced. Following the 2026 Asian Games, debate arose over comments and actions by some athletes related to military service, and the Ministry of National Defense announced its intention to ultimately pursue a phased reduction and abolition of the alternative service system, including the arts and sports personnel program. The Military Manpower Administration is also conducting policy research to review the eligibility requirements for assignment as arts and sports personnel as a whole.
The heart of the issue is not simply that athletes receive military service benefits. There is no reason to criticize them for receiving benefits that the state has legitimately granted through laws and regulations. What we should ask instead is, "What is the purpose of winning a gold medal?"
An Asian Games gold medal should be the fruit of the sweat shed by an athlete representing the country. The goals of becoming Asia's best in one's sport, a sense of responsibility toward the Taegeuk mark and devotion to teammates who trained together should come first. The military service benefit should be an institutional reward for that achievement, not the reason the gold medal exists.
Moreover, when considering this issue, we must also look at female national team athletes. Female athletes wear the Taegeuk mark just like male athletes, endure the same training and represent the country on the same playing fields. Olympic and Asian Games medals do not distinguish between men and women. The compensation system in sports, including the pension for research on improving athletic performance, which is awarded based on results at international competitions, is also fundamentally based on athletic achievement.
But the situation is different when it comes to military service, because the obligation to serve does not apply in the same way. As a result, even when male and female athletes win the same Asian Games gold medal, male athletes receive the additional benefit of resolving a military service issue that can have a major impact on their careers, while female athletes have no separate benefit equivalent to it.
Are male and female athletes equally rewarded for the same gold medal won on behalf of the country?
This issue should not end with a proposal to give female athletes greater financial compensation equivalent to the military service benefit. Rather, it is an opportunity to reconsider the principles on which rewards for national team athletes should be designed. We need a public discussion about how to evaluate the contributions national team athletes make to the country, taking into account military service, pensions, prize money, career support and post-retirement pathways.
One scene comes to mind when considering this issue: the men's individual recurve archery final at the 2018 Jakarta-Palembang Asian Games. Kim Woo-jin faced Lee Woo-seok, who was then a member of the Korea Armed Forces Athletic Corps. If Lee had won the gold medal, his military service situation could have changed significantly. But neither athlete brought the military service issue into the competition.
In a match that went down to the final set, Lee Woo-seok put his last arrow in the 9-point ring, while Kim Woo-jin shot a 10 and won 6-4. Kim did not give up the match out of consideration for his junior's circumstances. That was sport. Lee, for his part, did not blame his military service situation after losing. Accepting the result as a match he lost because he was not good enough, he said, "Every Korean man has to serve in the military." He also drew a clear distinction from the controversy over "helping certain athletes get military service benefits" that had arisen in other sports at the time, saying that archery's team selection process was transparent and athletes had earned their places through their skill.
The winner, Kim Woo-jin, also made a strong impression. Even after winning the gold medal, he avoided excessive celebrations out of consideration for his junior, who had missed the chance to receive the military service benefit. Yet during the match, he gave his all through the final arrow and did not hold back. After it ended, he showed consideration for his teammate. I believe this is the dignity a national team athlete can display.
Fairness in sports must not be compromised to accommodate someone's personal circumstances. If athletes hold back because military service is at stake, or if team selection or competition management changes because a particular athlete should receive a benefit, the trust that national team sports must earn from the public will also collapse.
A gold medal is heavy.
Its weight includes years of training, injuries and setbacks, as well as the sacrifices of families and coaches. It also carries the support funded by taxpayers and the social responsibility that comes with the title of national team athlete. That is why the public expects more from athletes who ascend the gold medal podium than world-class performance alone.
The podium demands dignity worthy of its height.
Pointing fingers at individual athletes for making military service benefits a goal will not solve the problem. It is also true that military service can have a major impact on an athlete's career, given how short an athletic career can be. Therefore, alongside considering individual athletes' attitudes, we must take a clear-eyed look at whether a system maintained for decades remains appropriate in today's social environment. The government is, in fact, also considering reforms to the arts and sports personnel program.
What rewards are appropriate for national team athletes? How should the country's achievements by male and female athletes be evaluated fairly? How can we correct a situation in which a particular benefit tied to military service takes precedence over the essence of sports and the value of representing the country? And above all, what responsibility and dignity should athletes wearing the Taegeuk mark show the public?
The two archers who stood at the shooting line in Jakarta in 2018 answered those questions this way: "There were no special favors in the contest, no excuses in defeat, and consideration for an opponent in victory."
A gold medal shines brightest the moment it is placed around an athlete's neck, but its true value endures according to how the athlete receives it and how they conduct themselves.
The podium of national team representation stands high.
And the weight of the gold medal podium is far greater than the weight of the medal itself.
Professor Park Seongsu of the Department of Leisure Sports Coaching at Mokpo National University
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
<This contribution presents the freely expressed views of an outside contributor to foster healthy discourse and may not reflect the editorial position of this publication.>
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.