Eight years after the "Lim Se-won Act," medical staff remain exposed to violence
Medical community: "The effectiveness of security and emergency response systems must be assessed"

Another incident in which a medical professional was stabbed with a weapon in a large general hospital’s consultation room has fueled calls to review the effectiveness of existing measures. In psychiatric wards in particular, where both patients’ human rights and healthcare workers’ safety must be considered, critics say the institutional framework for protecting medical staff needs to be strengthened alongside physical security measures.


"Do We Have to Risk Our Lives to Treat Patients?" Healthcare Workers' Safety Remains Overlooked Amid Fear of Patient Attacks with Weapons View original image

According to police and the medical community on November 6, a woman in her 50s, identified only as A, attacked a professor with a weapon in a psychiatry consultation room at Severance Hospital in Seodaemun-gu, Seoul, on November 4, injuring him. The professor suffered a stab wound about 5 cm long to his hand while defending himself and received treatment at the hospital. Police have arrested A and are investigating her motive and the circumstances of the attack.


The incident recalls the 2018 killing of the late Professor Im Sewon of Kangbuk Samsung Hospital, who was murdered with a weapon wielded by one of his patients. The public shock that followed led to the creation of the so-called “Im Sewon Act,” which strengthened penalties for violence in medical institutions and sought to create a safe environment for providing care. Amendments to the Medical Service Act increased penalties for assault and threats in medical institutions, while requiring facilities with 100 or more beds to take safety measures, including deploying security personnel and installing emergency alarm systems.


Yet, as this latest incident shows, healthcare workers in psychiatric wards continue to face repeated violence. This is partly because of the challenge of protecting patients’ human rights while also ensuring the safety of medical staff and other patients. “It has already been eight years since Professor Im Sewon passed away, but residents are still frequently assaulted by patients in wards,” said Baek Myeongjae, a professor of psychiatry at Kyung Hee University Medical Center. “Even when there is a violent patient in a ward, it is difficult to take measures such as physical restraints because of concerns about protecting the patient’s human rights or the risk of death.”


According to the Korean National Police Agency, violent crimes at medical institutions have remained at similar levels each year: 1,914 cases in 2021, 1,821 in 2022, 1,793 in 2023, 1,773 in 2024 and 1,760 last year. In 2025, assault accounted for 68.2% of all such crimes, with 1,200 cases, followed by bodily injury at 13.1% (231 cases), threats at 7.7% (136 cases) and property damage at 6.1% (107 cases).


"Do We Have to Risk Our Lives to Treat Patients?" Healthcare Workers' Safety Remains Overlooked Amid Fear of Patient Attacks with Weapons View original image

A 2025 survey of 44,903 healthcare workers by the Korean Health and Medical Workers’ Union also found that 11.5% had experienced physical assault in the past year, while 55.1% had been subjected to verbal abuse. Patients or their guardians accounted for 94.0% of those responsible for physical assaults, and 69.2% of those responsible for verbal abuse.


“If consultation rooms, where patients’ lives are saved, are left as dangerous places exposed to the risk of weapon attacks and violence at any moment, healthcare workers who have persevered on a sense of duty alone will have no choice but to leave the field amid extreme anxiety and fear,” said Kim Seonggeun, spokesperson for the Korean Medical Association. “Protecting healthcare workers from violence in consultation rooms is an essential social safety net for safeguarding the lives of the public and patients.”


Another concern is that violence against healthcare workers does not end with harm to individual employees of medical institutions. “The health and lives of medical staff are put at risk, and many patients who need treatment suffer enormous harm because they are unable to receive care,” said Jeong Chanseung, special director for social contribution at the Korean Neuropsychiatric Association and head of the Maum Dream Clinic. “Violence in medical institutions must be recognized as an act that threatens the lives and health of the public.”


There are also calls for harsher penalties for violence. “In several U.S. states, violence in medical institutions is treated as an act that threatens not only individual healthcare workers but also the lives and health of the public, and is subject to enhanced penalties. The United Kingdom also applies a zero-tolerance approach,” Jeong said. “Violence must be met with stringent punishment.”


However, protecting healthcare workers must not lead to stigmatizing patients with mental health conditions or limiting their access to care. “The conduct subject to punishment must be violence, and nothing else,” said Lee Uiju, president of the Korean Intern Resident Association. “Protecting healthcare workers and creating a safe treatment environment for patients are not separate tasks.”



"Do We Have to Risk Our Lives to Treat Patients?" Healthcare Workers' Safety Remains Overlooked Amid Fear of Patient Attacks with Weapons View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing