"You should invest for the long term in indexes that track the entire market."

"You should never average down recklessly. Adding water to cement leads to shoddy construction."

"Retail investors tend to be overconfident when investing in individual stocks."


That was the warning to retail investors from Park Geunbae, a managing director at Shinhan Securities who leads its Shinhan Premier Pathfinder Division. Like Warren Buffett, the "Oracle of Omaha," Park emphasized an investment principle of "minimizing losses and reducing volatility." Rather than blindly buying more shares every time a losing stock falls in price, he explained, investing in an index that tracks the broader market, which tends to rise over the long term, is a safer choice.

"Adding More Water to Cement Leads to Shoddy Construction... Don't Average Down on Stocks": Investing Expert's Blunt Warning to Retail Investors [Weekend Money] View original image

Park Geunbae, a managing director at Shinhan Securities' Shinhan Premier Pathfinder Division, made the remarks at an investment strategy seminar held at the company's headquarters in Yeouido on the afternoon of Nov. 5. "In investing, risk is the extent to which actual returns deviate from expected returns. This is called volatility," Park said. "Even with the same expected rate of return, repeatedly investing in assets with high volatility does not help long-term returns."


He particularly stressed the "weight of losses" in the relationship between risk and return. Park began by citing Warren Buffett's investment principles: "Rule No. 1: Never lose money. Rule No. 2: Never forget Rule No. 1." He went on to emphasize, "If you lose 1%, a 1% gain will restore your principal. But if you lose 50%, you need a 100% gain to recover your principal. To make up for an 80% loss, you need a 400% return."


Because the greater the loss, the higher the gain needed to make up for it, investors should be cautious about leveraged investing or aggressively buying more individual stocks during a downturn. "When stock prices fall, everyone averages down. Don't average down. You should never do it recklessly," Park warned. "Adding water to cement makes for shoddy construction." He added, "Indexes are the safe option because the market trends upward over time. You should be careful about investing in individual stocks."


He also cautioned against retail investors' overconfidence in their ability to pick individual stocks. "The KOSPI rose 38.78% over the past year, but only 8.4% of stocks recorded gains greater than the index," Park said, adding that "retail investors tend to be overconfident when investing in individual stocks." He said, "If you aren't confident you can pick a stock that will make it into that 8.4%, you should invest in an index."


At the start of the seminar, Park first posed the question, "Why are the ants heading west?" He was examining why Korean investors become "Seohak ants" by investing in U.S. stock markets. The answer was "volatility." Park said a comparison of daily closing prices for the S&P 500 and the KOSPI over the past 15 years showed little difference between the United States and South Korea in the proportions of days when the indexes rose and fell. However, the average declines were greater for the KOSPI.


"Volatility and time determine investment performance," Park noted. Long-term investing, he said, is just as important as keeping volatility low. According to Park, if investors had invested in the S&P 500 at the end of each month over the past 15 years and held their investments for one year, they would have made a profit in 164 of 182 cases, or 90.1%. In short, investments with manageable levels of risk make long-term investing possible, which in turn maximizes the benefits of compounding. "If you invest consistently and patiently, you can share fully in the stock market's long-term upward trend," he said. "To make time work in your favor, you need to stay in the market for a long time."


Park also emphasized that long-term investing is especially important for retirement pensions. "Retirement pensions are all about the power of time," he said, describing it as "time turning a speck of dust into a mountain." According to the 2025 Retirement Pension Investment White Paper released by the Financial Supervisory Service, close to 60% of DC and IRP account holders earn annual returns of less than 4%. "Small differences in returns grow significantly over time," Park said. "If you invest 100 in principal at an annual return of 3% for 25 years, it grows to 209.4. But if you increase the annual return by 3 percentage points, the result will be more than double that."



He also introduced the "Toegaeehwang" strategy as a way to increase after-tax returns, recommending the use of "retirement pensions, personal pensions, and the golden rule involving ISAs (Individual Savings Accounts)." Transferring ISA maturity proceeds into a pension savings account makes it possible to receive an additional tax deduction of up to 10% of the amount transferred, capped at 3 million won. Park concluded, "Successful wealth management is not about accurately predicting market movements, but about setting principles that align with your investment goals and following them consistently," he said. "It is important to manage volatility at a level you can handle and use tax-advantaged accounts to manage your assets with a long-term perspective."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing