Appellate court convicted over "excess payments when construction stopped"; Supreme Court overturns ruling

The Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News

The Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News

View original image

The Supreme Court has ruled that whether construction costs were set excessively, causing a loss through breach of trust, must be assessed based on the time the contract was signed, not when construction was halted.


According to legal sources on November 5, the Supreme Court’s Second Division, with Justice Park Youngjae presiding, recently overturned the lower court’s ruling sentencing the chairman of a clan association, identified as A, to two years in prison and its secretary-general, identified as B, to one year in prison on charges including breach of trust under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes. The court sent the case back to the Gwangju High Court.


Starting in 2020, the clan association, chaired by A, discussed building an addition on an open parking area on clan-owned land, but failed to reach a concrete agreement.


The two later obtained a building permit using meeting minutes bearing only relatives’ signatures, without a resolution at a general meeting. The building was designed to house a gallery cafe run by B on the first and second floors and multi-family housing on the third floor. In October 2022, they signed a contract for 1.7331 billion won, comprising the actual construction cost of 1.5331 billion won plus 200 million won the defendants intended to use.


The clan association paid 1.07 billion won by April 2023. The contractor halted construction in July of that year. The exterior was complete, but no interior work had been done.


The first trial found A guilty only of occupational embezzlement and forgery of private documents, among other charges, and sentenced him to one year in prison. It acquitted him of breach of trust and also acquitted B, ruling that the loss had not been proven because there was no evidence to objectively determine the reasonable construction cost.


The central issue was when the loss should be assessed. The appellate court also acquitted the defendants of the original breach-of-trust charge under the Act on the Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Economic Crimes. However, it found them guilty of occupational breach of trust, a charge the prosecution added during the appeal. It reasoned that when construction stopped, the contractor could have claimed no more than about 886.58 million won for the work completed up to that point, and that paying more than this amount caused a loss equal to the difference. The appellate court sentenced A to two years in prison and B to one year.


The Supreme Court rejected that conclusion. It said whether construction costs were excessive must be judged based on the time the contract was signed, and the fact that payments made around the time construction stopped exceeded the value of the work completed by then did not, on its own, establish that the defendants had caused an excessive contract to be made. It also said that even if an advance payment had been made before construction stopped, this did not establish that the two had been aware of, or intended to cause, a loss to the clan association.



The court ruled, "The mere possibility that construction costs could have been set at a lower level if there had been no breach of duty should not, by itself, lead to an easy conclusion that property loss occurred."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing