[Op-Ed] The Election Is Over; Now Let Sinan Go
The County’s Residents Have Already Answered
On June 3, the residents of Sinan County gave a clear answer. Kim Taeseong of the Rebuilding Korea Party won 51.95% (15,546 votes), defeating Park Wooryang of the Democratic Party of Korea, who received 48.04% (14,376 votes), by 1,170 votes. The bid to become the first person in the nation to win a fifth, nonconsecutive term came to an end.
Once the election determining the future of Sinan under its ninth popularly elected administration is over, the proper course is to humbly accept the will of the people and support the new county administration. But just over a month after the election, what former County Governor Park’s side filed was a criminal complaint. It accused Governor Kim Taeseong of making false statements during the election campaign.
Was the only place to look for the reason a four-term county governor nominated by the ruling party lost to a candidate from a new party the opponent’s remarks? In multiple opinion polls conducted before the election, residents ranked “integrity and honesty” as either their first or second criterion for choosing a county governor. Throughout the campaign, public sentiment clearly placed great weight on character as well as ability.
Blaming the election result on an opponent’s words is tantamount to viewing the county’s residents not as sovereign citizens capable of making their own judgments, but as people swayed by rumors. If you win, was it a wise choice, but if you lose, were you deceived? The residents of Sinan County were not foolish. They chose a new future after watching it all unfold: the Supreme Court ruling, the pardon process, and the light and shadow of 15 years.
Scrutiny Is Not False Information; It Is the Essence of an Election
An election is an opportunity to scrutinize one another’s pledges and records. Take his pledge to provide “KRW 500,000 a month to every county resident,” for example. Paying KRW 500,000 each month to roughly 40,000 residents would cost more than KRW 200 billion in a single year.
He said the funding would come from revenue from offshore wind and solar power, but media reports pointed out that this would require eight or nine nuclear power plants’ worth of capacity to be operating normally, backed by a massive power transmission and distribution network. According to Korea Electric Power Corporation (KEPCO), new power generation facilities cannot even be connected at 103 substations in Gwangju and South Jeolla Province by the end of 2031. Questioning a promise based on revenue from generators that are not yet operating and electricity that has no route to the grid is scrutiny in the public interest. Criticism and scrutiny of policies and campaign pledges are areas that democracy must protect as broadly as possible.
Calling something “false” in a complaint does not make it false. It is up to investigative authorities and the courts to determine what is true and what is not. But one thing must be made clear: scrutinizing the qualifications and pledges of candidates for public office is central to an election, and the courts have repeatedly stated that questions raised to scrutinize candidates should be broadly protected. If every uncomfortable word of scrutiny is met with a criminal complaint, who will dare to ask about a candidate’s record and pledges in the next election?
Above all, a few remarks did not determine the county residents’ choice. The Supreme Court’s final ruling, the pardon granted less than five months later, and pledges whose feasibility was questioned were all publicly available facts that anyone could verify. The exchanges during the campaign did not come from just one side. The residents watched it all and then made their judgment at the ballot box. Taking issue with certain remarks in an attempt to undermine that entire judgment is not accepting the result.
When determining whether statements were false, it is first necessary to accurately establish the facts confirmed by the courts.
During his time as vice mayor of Hanam City, he was given a final sentence of a KRW 5 million fine on charges including the preparation of false official documents. In 2011, while serving as Sinan County governor, he was fined KRW 800,000 in an appellate court for violating the Public Official Election Act by providing budgetary support to the Marine Corps Veterans Association ahead of a local election. Then, on March 27, 2025, the Supreme Court finalized a sentence of eight months in prison, suspended for two years, for charges including abuse of authority and obstruction of the exercise of rights. The charges concerned his improper instructions, between June 2019 and February 2020, to hire applicants who had received outside recommendations as fixed-term public officials and contract workers. He consequently lost his position as county governor. These are not allegations; they are facts established in a final court ruling.
Less than five months after the final ruling, he regained the opportunity to run for office through a special Liberation Day pardon and restoration of his civil rights. That is why local civic groups and political parties issued a series of statements criticizing the move. A pardon is a system established by law, and its effect must be respected. But even if a pardon removes the legal effect of a sentence, it does not erase the facts established by the court. Only the residents of Sinan County can restore trust.
Having risen again through the pardon, he was a seemingly unassailable giant, backed by the nomination of a major political party and an organization built over 15 years. It was not the state or the media that stopped him, but the votes cast by county residents across large and small islands. That is the weight of democracy. No power and no pardon can take the place of the sovereign people’s judgment.
The Shadows of His Tenure Begin to Emerge
Since the election, allegations surrounding projects from his time in office have also begun to emerge, one by one. Investigators will determine whether laws were violated, but residents have the right to know what issues have been raised.
According to the results of a review of major projects from the seventh and eighth popularly elected administrations, announced by Sinan County in July, about KRW 42.9 billion was spent on a donated-tree project launched in 2020. The county said that about 77% of the amount went to just three individuals. The county was also criticized for covering all ancillary costs, including the excavation and transportation of the donated trees.
The exchange of public property, initiated through a notice in 2023 during his tenure, was finalized with a sole applicant on June 4, the day after the election. The county said it found indications that trees had been planted on the land slated for exchange before permission to use the land had been obtained.
The most troubling case of all is the safe housing project for salt farm workers. “Salt farm slavery” is a deeply painful wound that Sinan must never forget. On remote island salt farms, human dignity was trampled amid confinement, assault, and wage exploitation. The safe housing project was the first step toward healing that wound and restoring the human rights of salt farm workers. Yet according to the county, although the project remains at the detailed design service stage, about 70% of its total budget has already been paid. Allegations of preferential treatment have also been raised over the decision to have a private entity carry out the construction of a public facility.
Investigations into possible legal violations are ongoing. But if the investigation finds that the money was improperly spent, this would go beyond a simple budgetary issue: it would mean abandoning a project meant to help the most vulnerable. Investigative authorities must leave not a single won of these allegations unexamined.
Allegations over agricultural machinery subsidies have also recently surfaced. According to media reports, about KRW 7.2 billion in support for agricultural machinery purchases was allocated to 10 farming organizations through a rice-farming scale-up support project in 2019 and 2020. Allegations of duplicate benefits have also been raised, with some representatives of agricultural cooperatives reportedly receiving support in their personal names in addition to assistance granted in the name of their corporations. The county says it will review the procedures and take action in accordance with the law if any improprieties are found. Whether the law was violated must be determined. But if public funds intended for many farming households were concentrated among a few, leaving other farmers waiting in line without an opportunity, the residents would bear the full cost.
The Burden of the Past Is Holding Back the New Administration
Even so, the dispute over the election result shows no sign of ending. Meanwhile, the new county administration has inherited the problems left by the past. As referrals for investigation and audits continue, a considerable share of the administration’s capacity is being spent sorting out what came before. Resources that should be devoted to transportation and medical care for island residents, income for farmers and fishers, and policies to keep young people from leaving are instead being used to clean up the legacy of a past era. If criminal complaints are added to the mix, the residents who voted for change will be left to bear the full cost.
Now Is the Time to Give Sinan Back to Its Residents
The shepherd boy David stood before the giant Goliath with neither armor nor sword, carrying five stones he had picked up by a stream. No one believed the boy could win. But one stone brought the giant down. Last June, the residents of Sinan County were David. What they held in their hands was a small stone: a single ballot. Faced with a power that had seemed impossible to overcome for so long, the residents used that small stone to reclaim the place of ownership they had entrusted to others.
What he should give back is not a criminal complaint, but reflection. He should sincerely bow his head before the young people whose opportunities were taken away and the residents who were disappointed, humbly await the results of the investigation, and step aside to let the new county administration move forward. That is the final courtesy owed to the residents who entrusted him with the county governorship four times.
When Goliath fell, the battle was over. The election was over, too. Now Sinan must be returned to its owners: its residents.
Kang Seongjong, Former South Jeolla Provincial Council Member
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.