Korea Corporate Governance Forum: "Minority shareholders must be guaranteed an opportunity to sell"
Shin Dongguk appears to have conducted off-market transactions with at least 10 shareholders within six months
Whether the exception for specially related persons applies is a key issue

As discussions spread over whether minority shareholders should also be guaranteed an equal opportunity to sell their shares in change-of-control transactions, attention has returned to how Shin Dongguk (pictured), chairman of Hanyang Precision, acquired a stake in Hanmi Science. The question is whether Shin violated the Capital Markets Act’s mandatory tender offer rules by purchasing large stakes off-market from multiple shareholders.


According to industry sources on November 5, the Korea Corporate Governance Forum issued a commentary on November 3 arguing that discussions on introducing a mandatory tender offer system should ensure that ordinary shareholders have sufficient opportunities to sell their shares. The argument stems from concerns that applying the “50% plus one share” tender offer approach currently under discussion in the National Assembly could allow controlling shareholders to enjoy a control premium while leaving ordinary shareholders with no opportunity to sell their shares.


The mandatory tender offer system gives ordinary shareholders the opportunity to sell their shares when a company’s control is acquired. The forum said that a transaction in which the controlling shareholder does not share the premium gained from transferring control with ordinary shareholders could be viewed not as a conventional merger and acquisition (M&A), but as a transaction pursuing “private benefits of control.”

Shin Dong-kook, Chairman of Hanyang Precision. Photo: Hanyang Precision website.

Shin Dong-kook, Chairman of Hanyang Precision. Photo: Hanyang Precision website.

View original image

The debate has drawn attention in connection with allegations that Shin violated mandatory tender offer rules when purchasing shares off-market. Shin agreed to acquire a total of more than 9.39 million shares (13.74%) of Hanmi Science in three transactions in February, July and October 2026. An analysis suggests that the number of sellers in the February and July transactions, which took place within six months of each other, could reach at least 10 even after excluding duplicate sellers.


Under the current Capital Markets Act, a shareholder whose combined stake with that of specially related persons is at least 5% must, in principle, make a tender offer if the shareholder purchases shares off-market from 10 or more shareholders within six months. The provision is intended to prevent a buyer from acquiring a large stake through off-market transactions with specific shareholders while denying other shareholders the opportunity to sell.


Shin’s side maintains that there was no violation of the law. It says that there were fewer than 10 sellers after excluding transactions covered by statutory exceptions, such as transactions with specially related persons. The key issue is whether the family of Lim Jong-yoon, chairman of Kori Group, who was previously involved in a management control dispute, and related companies can be considered specially related persons to Shin. Since a mere business relationship is not enough to qualify for an exception, some say the legal relationship with each seller needs to be examined.


If a violation is confirmed, the voting rights attached to shares acquired through the transactions could be restricted, and the Financial Services Commission could order their disposal. If this leads to problems with disposing of pledged shares or repaying loans, it could also put pressure on financial institutions that provided Shin with share-secured loans, including Hana Securities and Korea Securities Finance Corporation.



Since discussions on the mandatory tender offer system began with the aim of protecting ordinary shareholders’ rights in change-of-control transactions, some say the financial authorities should carefully verify whether the exceptions to the tender offer rules were lawfully applied to Shin’s share purchases.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing