'Impacted Student' Used in Sexual Violence Investigations
University Calls It a "Neutral Term to Prevent Bias"
Campus Backlash Continues, Including Resignation and Student Protests

Stanford University in the United States is facing controversy after deciding to refer to students who report sexual violence as “impacted students” rather than “survivors” during investigations.


University Changes Terminology to “Prevent Bias”; Critics Say It “Silences Victims”


A scene from “Take Back the Night,” an anti-sexual violence event at Stanford University. A sign reads, “Stanford Stands with Survivors.” Official website.

A scene from “Take Back the Night,” an anti-sexual violence event at Stanford University. A sign reads, “Stanford Stands with Survivors.” Official website.

View original image

According to the New York Post on November 2 (local time), the Stanford Daily, the university’s student newspaper, reported on October 28 that the university had changed the terminology used for students who report incidents during investigations. The university also removed “Sexual Harassment/Assault Response and Education (SHARE)” from the name of the office handling sexual violence and discrimination cases, renaming it the “Title IX and Title VI Office.” Title IX is a U.S. federal law that prohibits sex discrimination in educational institutions.


Patrick Dunkley, Stanford’s deputy provost, said of the changes, “We will continue to use the term ‘survivor’ in educational programs, but during investigations, we will use neutral terms such as ‘impacted student’ so that bias does not affect a case.” He said that referring to someone as a “survivor” before the facts have been established could give the impression that the reporting student’s claims are being accepted as true.


However, the decision has drawn fierce criticism on campus. Pelagia Martin, who worked as a student employee at SHARE, resigned in protest. Martin, who has said she experienced sexual violence, criticized the decision, saying, “It is a direct attack on my credibility and an outright dismissal of victims’ voices,” and, “The Title IX Office has completely lost the trust of survivors on campus and my own.”


Martin also claimed that the university office had tried to distance itself from awareness-raising events, including Take Back the Night, an event opposing sexual violence. The event, previously organized by the university office, was held by students themselves at White Plaza on campus this year. Participants called for stronger sexual violence prevention education, improvements to the process for reporting incidents, and greater transparency in how cases are handled. The university, however, said, “We had planned to expand the office’s involvement in programs for Awareness Month.”


Michelle Dover, professor emerita at Stanford Law School, said that the term “‘impacted student’ may be appropriately neutral in the context of an investigation seeking to establish the facts.” However, she pointed out that “rejecting the term ‘survivor’ even in broader contexts outside investigations has the effect of denying what students and members of the university community have actually experienced.” She added that it was “needlessly hurtful and serves no legitimate purpose.”


Growing Unease Over Campus Sexual Violence and Nearby Sexual Assault


A view of Stanford University in the U.S. Pexels

A view of Stanford University in the U.S. Pexels

View original image

Earlier, the Stanford Daily published an anonymous op-ed by a student who said that a student found responsible for sexual assault on campus had been suspended for two years. The student wrote, “The process swallowed half the time I spent at Stanford.” The student also claimed that campus police did not contact a witness until four months after the initial report. The student also described raising concerns with the university and meeting with Deputy Provost Dunkley. Earlier this year, a man armed with a weapon sexually assaulted a woman who was jogging near campus, heightening anxiety among women on campus.



In South Korea, controversy also arose in 2020 when the ruling Democratic Party of Korea and other members of the ruling bloc referred to the complainant in allegations of sexual harassment involving then-Seoul Mayor Park Won-soon as a “person alleging victimization” rather than a “victim.” After critics said the term could lead to secondary victimization, the Democratic Party officially changed its terminology to “victim” in July of that year, following a decision by its Supreme Council.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing