Delayed Return of Capital Contributions to Former Members... Loan Repayments Also Disrupted

73 Affiliated Companies Owe 373 Billion Won... Just 3.1 Billion Won in Cash

Franchise Stores Closing One After Another... Rebuilding Committee Expected to Be Formed

#. Member A, a cooperative member in her 50s who had used Natural Dream for 16 years, left iCOOP Consumer Cooperative in March 2026 but is still waiting for the return of her 1.2 million won in capital contributions. Natural Dream is the flagship eco-friendly food brand of iCOOP Consumer Cooperative, the country's largest consumer cooperative. Members pay 50,000 won when they join and 10,000 won each month thereafter, with additional capital contributions accruing whenever they use the cooperative's online or offline stores. These accumulated contributions can be returned when a member withdraws. Under the rules, A should have received her money six months after leaving, but since September 2026, all she has heard is that "the return of capital contributions is being delayed."

A banner announcing the store’s closure hangs outside the Nature Dream Gongdeok-Ahyeon branch in Mapo-gu, Seoul, the previous afternoon. The three nearby branches listed as alternatives are all a 30-minute drive away. Reporter Oh Jieun

A banner announcing the store’s closure hangs outside the Nature Dream Gongdeok-Ahyeon branch in Mapo-gu, Seoul, the previous afternoon. The three nearby branches listed as alternatives are all a 30-minute drive away. Reporter Oh Jieun

View original image

Growing liquidity problems at iCOOP Consumer Cooperative have recently heightened concerns among members who have been unable to get their money back on time. The disruption is expected to deepen because Natural Dream, which promotes organic food and ethical consumption, has a large customer base and many long-standing members.


Delays in Returning Capital Contributions and Repaying Loans... More Than 140 Billion Won in Members' Funds Tied Up

According to industry sources and cooperative members on November 5, recent liquidity problems at iCOOP Consumer Cooperative have heightened anxiety among members who have been unable to get their money back on time. The return of capital contributions to former members and repayment of loans by affiliated companies have been delayed one after another. Capital contributions are funds paid by members when joining or using the cooperative, while loans are funds that members separately lent to affiliated companies conducting business such as product supply, distribution and financial management. At the time, iCOOP Consumer Cooperative encouraged members to participate by offering returns higher than those on commercial bank deposits, including 6% annual interest on a two-year term. Although the funds are different in nature, both are money that members are owed, and they are facing losses as a result.


iCOOP Consumer Cooperative generally returns capital contributions six months after a member submits a withdrawal request. However, some members say they have been unable to recover several million won in contributions even seven or eight months after leaving. iCOOP Consumer Cooperative said, "After news emerged in August 2026 that affiliated companies were delaying loan repayments, requests from members to get their money back surged." The cooperative had shown signs of financial strain since the second half of 2025, including delays in settling payments for producers' goods. It said that demands grew not only for repayment of loans at maturity but also for the early recovery of funds, ultimately leading to delays in returning capital contributions.


According to materials iCOOP Consumer Cooperative released at a members' public hearing in September 2026, the total borrowings of its 73 affiliated companies amounted to 373 billion won. Of that amount, 146.9 billion won was borrowed from members and 226.1 billion won from banks. A total of 2,375 members participated in 9,130 loans, according to the figures. The same materials showed that the cooperative held only 3.1 billion won in cash. The number of Natural Dream franchise stores fell from 249 in 2022 to 242 in 2023 and 229 in 2024, before plunging to 145 as of the most recent count.

Unable to Recover Capital Contributions or Loans... iCOOP Members 'At Their Wits' End' View original image

Plans to Form a Rebuilding Committee... Calls for a Government-Wide Investigation Grow

As the problem worsened, voices within iCOOP Consumer Cooperative called for a review of the financial situation of all affiliated companies and a response. However, the SafeNet Special Crisis Response Committee, formed in August 2026 to address the crisis with five representatives of members, producers and employees, was also limited in its ability to assess the overall financial situation. When it concluded its work on September 21, 2026, the committee said it had been difficult to determine overall fund flows and repayment capacity because it lacked the authority to compel individual companies to submit accounting and financial records. A rebuilding committee, with participation from a broad range of stakeholders including members, lenders, producers and employees, is now being organized. The goal is to address the limitations of the previous special committee, review the financial situation of affiliated companies and develop a plan to restore their operations. The organizers are coordinating the participating groups and the committee's operating procedures, with a launch targeted for November 2026.


Calls for a comprehensive government investigation, made through a National Assembly petition, have also emerged amid concerns that the problem cannot be resolved through internal measures alone. Registered on October 13, 2026, and backed by 6,500 signatures, the petition calls for an investigation into whether iCOOP Consumer Cooperative complied with its borrowing limits, whether it obtained the required explanations and consent when encouraging members to roll over loans or make special capital contributions, and why payments to producers were delayed. It also argues that the government should clarify its authority to oversee how consumer cooperatives manage funds and establish a system requiring them to disclose how they raise and use money.



Lee Jeongbong, head of the Social Economy and Labor Center, said, "Large consumer cooperatives have structural characteristics that make it difficult to keep their management from running the organization recklessly. Discussions on restoring operations, with members, producers and employees taking part, must come first, and institutional improvements are needed to ensure effective government oversight."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing