"Taken to the hospital because of the distress"
A video of continuous barking is stronger evidence than a medical certificate

The neighbor's dog barked at 2 a.m. Sometimes it kept going for more than a minute. The neighbor sent a recording to the dog's owner but received only the reply, "Yes, it's barking now. I'm sorry." The barking continued. This is the story of a family that won a court ruling ordering the dog's owner to pay 4.5 million won in damages over the barking. By contrast, another person lost a case despite submitting a medical certificate documenting the effects of the noise. What made the difference in the outcomes?


Pixabay

Pixabay

View original image

Claiming "It was noisy" is not enough

The Incheon District Court's Civil Division 16, presided over by Chief Judge Park Seongmin, ruled in favor of the family seeking 4.5 million won in damages on August 25, 2026 (case No. 2024Gahap61239). The dog's owner argued that it was reacting to things happening outside, such as a delivery worker passing by or a neighbor's dog barking. But a video recorded by the family who filed the lawsuit captured the dog barking continuously late at night even though no one was outside the front door. The court said the owner should have taken adequate measures if the dog was barking for several minutes at a time. It also noted that although the dog had been neutered and other measures had been taken, the noise only became less frequent after the owner received the court documents.


The Jeonju District Court's Civil Division 12, presided over by Chief Judge Kang Hyeokseong, ruled against a resident who sought about 10.56 million won in damages over noise from an upstairs neighbor's dog and other sources on August 26, 2026 (case No. 2025Gahap1376). The court acknowledged that noise had occurred but said the video captured it only occasionally. There was also no evidence that a public official who visited in response to a complaint had actually confirmed the noise. The resident who filed the lawsuit submitted a medical certificate stating that they were suffering because of the noise, but the court found that it was not enough to prove that the noise had actually occurred.


The courts' standard: the "limit of reasonable tolerance"

The courts' standard is how much dog barking a neighbor can reasonably be expected to tolerate. The Incheon District Court said the government's standards for inter-floor noise were only a reference point, and considered both when and how often the dog barked and how its owner responded.


In 2023, the Gwangju District Court also awarded 1 million won in damages to an upstairs resident who had been troubled by noise from a downstairs neighbor's dog (case No. 2022Gaso17996). The court said the upstairs resident, who was in poor health, had filed several complaints, but the dog's owner had failed to take appropriate measures.


The court's position is that even if dog barking falls below the standards for inter-floor noise, an owner may still be liable for damages resulting from an unlawful act if the barking is repeated every day. The court noted, "Anyone who has lived in an apartment knows that you can hear the sound of a toilet flushing upstairs or downstairs," and cited the proverb, "Even a pleasant sound becomes tiresome after one or two times."



In 2019, the Seoul Northern District Court also awarded 1 million won each to two residents troubled by noise from three neighbor's dogs (case No. 2016Gahap1148). One of the residents sought medical care for headaches, and the resident's son became so distressed that the family eventually moved. The resident measured the noise from the barking dogs with a portable digital sound level meter, recording levels of 82.5 to 97.4 dB, far above the nighttime standard of 40 to 60 dB.


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing