Points to omissions in the history of the independence movement and concerns over distortions in the account of May 18
Senior Secretary Hwang Pungnyeon: "A book that is wrong should be discarded."

Calls have emerged for specific procedures and a timetable to discard the existing edition of A Millennium of Jeolla History, amid controversy over omissions and distortions of historical facts.


Shin Minho, chair of the Council Operations Committee of the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City Council (Suncheon District 6, Democratic Party of Korea), pointed to problems in the historical narrative of A Millennium of Jeolla History during an administrative audit on Nov. 3 of the office of the integrated special city mayor and its advisory bodies, calling for the submission of a plan to discard the book.

Shin Minho, member of the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City Council.

Shin Minho, member of the Jeonnam-Gwangju Integrated Special City Council.

View original image

Addressing Hwang Pungnyeon, senior secretary for social and cultural affairs, Chair Shin said, "The council has been raising this issue for three years, but no substantive measures have been taken." He added, "Based on the results of expert reviews, a considerable amount of information is missing on the activities of independence activists from Jeonnam and Gwangju documented in the Ministry of Patriots and Veterans Affairs' records of meritorious service, as well as on the independence movement in the Americas."


He also raised concerns about distortions in the account of the May 18 Democratization Movement and the omission of pro-Japanese activities by literary figures such as Seo Jeong-ju. He argued that merely supplementing some content would not be enough to restore confidence in the history book.


He also countered the existing position that discarding the book would be difficult because of copyright issues and the possibility of lawsuits, saying that legal risks could not justify failing to correct historical errors.


He called for the submission of legal advisory materials concerning copyright and potential lawsuits, as well as records of the compilation, review, and printing approval processes.


In response, Hwang, senior secretary for social and cultural affairs, said, "A book that is wrong should be discarded." When Chair Shin called for specific procedures, a timetable, and details on how the book would be handled, Hwang said he would submit the relevant materials.


Meanwhile, Chair Shin raised the issue of omissions in the history of the independence movement during the 2024 administrative audit and, last year, called for the fourth volume of the modern history section to be discarded and rewritten.



On April 21 this year, the Jeonnam Provincial Council plenary session adopted a resolution sponsored by Chair Shin calling for the immediate discarding of A Millennium of Jeolla History and a halt to its distribution.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing