KTU surveys 1,017 teachers and 3,414 middle and high school students
73% of teachers: "Government unlikely to meet suicide prevention goal"
Suicide prevention measures need to focus on isolated students and victims of school violence

Academic pressure and competition for college admission can cause an "emotional crisis," but an analysis has found that "isolation" is the key factor that can escalate emotional distress into a "suicide crisis." Students who often felt "alone" at school were more than six times as likely as those who did not to experience severe emotional distress that interfered with their daily lives. Even among students with many concerns about grades or studying, those who were not isolated at school were relatively less likely to experience emotional distress.


On November 4, the Korean Teachers and Education Workers Union (KTU) released the results of its "Teacher-Student Opinion Survey on Student Mental Health and Self-Harm and Suicide Prevention." The survey was conducted last month among 1,017 teachers nationwide and 3,414 middle and high school students.


Students who said they had often or almost every day been too distressed to manage their daily lives over the past month were classified as students experiencing severe emotional distress. They accounted for 14.4% of respondents, and the survey compared them with other students.


"The More Alone They Feel, the Greater the Risk"... Students in Mental Health Crisis More Vulnerable to "Isolation and School Violence" Than Academic Pressure View original image

The survey found that 30.4% of students experiencing severe emotional distress often felt alone at school, 5.6 times the proportion among the other students (5.4%).


They were 3.2 times as likely to be concerned about family discord, 3.0 times as likely to have experienced bullying or social exclusion, and 2.6 times as likely to say they had no one to turn to when they had difficulties with friendships.


Results of the "Teacher and Student Opinion Survey on Student Mental Health and Self-Harm and Suicide Prevention." Korean Teachers and Education Workers Union (KTU)

Results of the "Teacher and Student Opinion Survey on Student Mental Health and Self-Harm and Suicide Prevention." Korean Teachers and Education Workers Union (KTU)

View original image

Among students with many concerns about grades or studying, 57.9% of those who often felt alone at school said they were distressed enough to have difficulty with daily life. By contrast, the proportion was just 20.6% among students who did not feel alone at school.


Even among students who did not have many concerns about grades, 38.7% of those isolated at school reported severe emotional distress.


"The findings show that while academic stress can worsen emotional distress, isolation and a breakdown in relationships are the factors that most strongly determine whether a student is in crisis," the KTU said. "We need to move beyond the idea that 'students die by suicide because of academic stress' and develop measures focused on students in crisis who are isolated."


"The More Alone They Feel, the Greater the Risk"... Students in Mental Health Crisis More Vulnerable to "Isolation and School Violence" Than Academic Pressure View original image

The difficulties faced by students who had experienced school violence also stood out. A total of 6.7% of students had experienced bullying or social exclusion in the past year. Of these, 33.2% said they were distressed enough to have difficulty with daily life, 2.5 times the proportion among students who had not experienced such victimization (13.1%).


Four in 10 victimized students (39.9%) did not tell their school about what had happened, and 45.3% of those who did report it said that "the situation did not improve."


"The More Alone They Feel, the Greater the Risk"... Students in Mental Health Crisis More Vulnerable to "Isolation and School Violence" Than Academic Pressure View original image

Teachers also viewed "school violence victimization" and "isolation" as the greatest risks.


Among teachers, 64.0% identified students who had experienced bullying or school violence as being at "very high" risk of suicide.


This was followed by 53.3% who selected students isolated due to difficulties with peer relationships. A total of 36.1% identified students experiencing severe stress over grades or college admissions.


"The More Alone They Feel, the Greater the Risk"... Students in Mental Health Crisis More Vulnerable to "Isolation and School Violence" Than Academic Pressure View original image

In addition, 90.9% of teachers said the quality of students' peer relationships had worsened compared with the past. The factors they cited were increased online and remote activities (43.4%), not knowing how to build friendships (39.9%), and the loss of classroom order and a sense of community (37.5%). Admission-related stress was cited by 25.2%.


Teachers gave a negative assessment of the government's suicide prevention measures.


A total of 73.2% said the government's goal of "halving the youth suicide rate by 2035" would be difficult to achieve with current measures, while just 4.4% said it was achievable.


"The More Alone They Feel, the Greater the Risk"... Students in Mental Health Crisis More Vulnerable to "Isolation and School Violence" Than Academic Pressure View original image

The most commonly cited ways teachers first learned that a student was in crisis were the student speaking up (52.6%), counseling at a Wee Class (47.7%), and identification by a homeroom or subject teacher (46.6%). A total of 15.5% said they identified a student through the Emotional and Behavioral Characteristics Test or the Mind EASY Test.


Meanwhile, 82.4% of teachers said that having to "handle the situation alone" was a challenge when intervening with students in crisis.


Based on the survey findings, the KTU proposed 13 tasks, saying youth suicide prevention policy should shift from identifying and treating students in crisis to restoring relationships and promoting a coordinated response within schools.


It first stressed that students who are isolated or have experienced school violence should be a primary focus of suicide prevention policy, and that schools should support the restoration of peer relationships. It also called for the abolition of self-reporting tests, including the Emotional and Behavioral Characteristics Test, and for schools to identify students in crisis by using teacher observations, changes in attendance, and records of school violence victimization. The union also called for revisions to the Student-Tailored Integrated Support Act and regulations governing crisis management committees to clarify the roles and responsibilities of school community members, as well as for stronger coordination between Wee Centers and medical institutions.


The union also proposed measures to intervene when students are neglected because their guardians refuse treatment, psychological recovery support for teachers who have experienced a student suicide, revisions to suicide prevention education and crisis management manuals, and greater state responsibility for students who have dropped out of school.



"We can no longer protect children by identifying depressed students and sending them outside the school. The key to preventing student suicide is to create a structure in which an isolated child can rebuild relationships in the classroom and the entire school community shares responsibility so that no student is left alone in a crisis," the KTU said. It urged the government to "stop passing failed policies down to schools and immediately put forward practical policies and administrative and financial support to create schools that can protect children."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing