Nuclear Power Deliberation Committee's citizen participation group begins work
"Demand forecasts are exaggerated" - "Proactive expansion"
Experts also divided in their views
Selecting a site for a new nuclear power plant takes up to 13 years
Industry fears obstacles to investment in AIDCs and other projects

The government is considering lowering its electricity demand forecast for the 12th Basic Plan for Electricity Supply and Demand, raising concerns in industry. Critics warn that power shortages could hinder investment in advanced industries such as AI data centers (AIDCs) and semiconductors.


According to the Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment on November 4, the Nuclear Power Deliberation Committee for the 12th Basic Plan for Electricity Supply and Demand is conducting a telephone survey to select 300 members of a citizen participation group. After about a month of study, the members will take part in deliberative discussions over three days and two nights, from December 11 to 13.

Kim Seonghwan, Minister of Climate, Energy and Environment, delivers opening remarks at the launch ceremony for the Nuclear Power Public Deliberation Committee for the Basic Plan for Electricity Supply and Demand, held at the Han River Flood Control Office in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on the 2nd of last month. Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment

Kim Seonghwan, Minister of Climate, Energy and Environment, delivers opening remarks at the launch ceremony for the Nuclear Power Public Deliberation Committee for the Basic Plan for Electricity Supply and Demand, held at the Han River Flood Control Office in Seocho-gu, Seoul, on the 2nd of last month. Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment

View original image

The Basic Plan for Electricity Supply and Demand is a medium- to long-term plan that forecasts electricity demand from industry, commerce and households and sets the direction for expanding power generation facilities and the electricity grid. Building power plants and installing transmission lines can take several years to more than a decade, so preparations for sites and facilities must be made in advance to reduce the risk of power shortages and large-scale blackouts. Public deliberation on nuclear power is a process for gathering opinions to reduce social conflict over construction and increase public acceptance.


◆Differences over electricity demand from advanced industries, concerns about overinvestment and calls to expand nuclear power=The key issue is how much electricity demand from advanced industries should be factored in. As investment plans for AIDCs and semiconductors have followed one after another, including three major mega-projects, calls have grown to prepare for a sharp increase in demand. Others argue that including projects that have not been finalized could lead to an overestimate of demand and excessive investment in power generation facilities.


Sungwon Ki, an honorary professor in the Department of Advanced AI Engineering at Kangwon National University, said, "I question whether data centers and semiconductor factories will still need enormous amounts of electricity 15 years from now." He added, "I believe expanding renewable energy and energy storage systems (ESS) is more necessary than expanding nuclear power based on inflated demand forecasts."


Kwanghoon Seok, a specialist committee member at the Energy Transition Forum, also said that electricity demand from AIDCs had been overestimated following the announcement of the mega-projects. "When drawing up an actual national electricity supply and demand plan, genuine demand must be distinguished from demand that has not yet been confirmed," Seok said. "I believe it is wrong to include all demand in the government's electricity demand forecast without distinguishing between demand reflecting the government's investment intentions and confirmed demand."


Others, however, argue that nuclear power should also be expanded proactively because renewable energy alone cannot meet rising demand.


Jaehak Jeong, a professor in the Department of Nuclear Engineering at Kyung Hee University, said, "Renewable energy generation should certainly be expanded, but nuclear power must also be expanded because renewable energy alone cannot meet all of the growing electricity demand." He added, "There is no clear alternative to nuclear power for meeting the surge in electricity demand caused by AIDCs, so proactively increasing its share is essential."

[Why&Next] Disagreement Over Nuclear Expansion in 12th Power Plan... Industry: "What About a Power Supply Gap in 10 Years?" View original image

◆Concerns that uncertainty over electricity supply could disrupt investment; coordination between ministries also a challenge=Industry is concerned about the impact that uncertainty over electricity supply could have on investment. Without plans to ensure a stable power supply for AIDCs and semiconductor factories, investment attraction and project implementation could be disrupted, industry says.


Because expanding power generation facilities takes a long time, the later decisions are made, the greater the risk of a gap in supply, industry argues. Industry estimates that selecting a new site for a nuclear power plant alone takes 9-13 years, and that the country could face power shortages in 10 years if it does not secure sufficient supply capacity.


Coordination between industrial and energy policies is also a challenge. As responsibility for drawing up the Basic Plan for Electricity Supply and Demand has shifted from the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy to the Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment, the need to closely link industrial investment with electricity supply plans has grown. Critics say that if the ministry responsible for climate policy and the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy, which are responsible for electricity and water supply, fail to coordinate project scale and timing or have differing assessments of future demand, facility expansion and investment schedules could be delayed.


Hongjong Cho, a professor of economics at Dankook University, said, "Take the mega-projects, for example. The Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy handles industrial policy, while the Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment handles energy and water policies. How are they supposed to cooperate?" He added, "Industry says it needs electricity immediately, while the Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment is struggling to supply it on time. How this is coordinated could determine whether the policy succeeds or fails."


Experts recommend drawing up a supply and demand plan that assesses the feasibility of industrial investment plans while ensuring that expansion of power generation facilities and the electricity grid is not delayed. Their aim is to improve the accuracy of demand forecasts and respond flexibly to changes in industrial conditions.



Seunghoon Yoo, a professor in the Department of Future Energy Convergence at Seoul National University of Science and Technology, said, "We should focus on building a viable supply and demand system that can provide high-quality electricity reliably, at the right time and in the right place, in line with the surging demand from advanced industries." He stressed, "The 12th Basic Plan for Electricity Supply and Demand should serve as an implementation roadmap that balances three key goals - energy security, industrial competitiveness and carbon neutrality - moving beyond ideological disputes centered on particular energy sources."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing