"Current Mandatory Tender Offer Serves Only Controlling Shareholders' Interests... It Should Be Renamed"
Korea Corporate Governance Forum Commentary
Strongly Criticizes Proposal Allowing Preemptive Purchases
Representatives of asset management companies pose for a commemorative photo at a press conference on an urgent joint statement calling for renewed discussion of the mandatory tender offer system, held at the Kensington Hotel Yeouido in Yeongdeungpo-gu, Seoul, on September 30. Yonhap News.
View original imageThe mandatory tender offer bill proposed by the National Assembly’s Political Affairs Committee has drawn repeated criticism for being designed to serve only the private interests of controlling shareholders. Despite opposition from the financial investment industry, the bill allows “preemptive purchases” of only controlling shareholders’ stakes in mergers and acquisitions (M&A), putting the protection of ordinary shareholders on the back burner.
Allowing Preemptive Purchases Could Give Preferential Treatment to Controlling Shareholders
On November 3, the Korea Corporate Governance Forum made this point in a commentary. It cited as a representative example EQT Partners, a private equity fund manager affiliated with Sweden’s Wallenberg family, and its acquisition of South Korean software company Douzone Bizon. On November 7 last year, EQT signed an agreement to acquire a 23% stake held by controlling shareholders, including Chairman Kim Yong-woo, and a 14% stake held by Shinhan Securities for a total of KRW 1.3158 trillion. On the day the deal was announced, Douzone Bizon’s share price plunged 11% after the company agreed to sell only part of the shares carrying control.
“In advanced economies such as the United States, such deals are not called corporate M&A; they are classified as ‘transactions for the private benefit of controlling shareholders’ and are strictly distinguished from the sale of an entire company,” the forum said. “That is because controlling shareholders or managers monopolize the benefits for themselves without sharing them with other stakeholders, including ordinary shareholders.”
Douzone Bizon later conducted a tender offer for ordinary shareholders at the same price paid for the controlling shareholders’ stake and voluntarily delisted. However, the transaction had already involved a “preemptive purchase” of the controlling shareholders’ stake. “In the United States, neither Wall Street nor academia recognizes the acquisition of only part of a company’s shares as M&A in the first place,” the forum said, criticizing the bill: “Since the Political Affairs Committee’s mandatory tender offer bill allows preemptive purchases, it would be more accurate to rename the system the ‘private-benefit transaction system.’”
The current proposal from the Political Affairs Committee would require a tender offer for “50% plus one share” of a company’s shares in an M&A deal. In particular, it allows preemptive purchases of only the controlling shareholder’s stake. The forum said that under this approach, the system’s purpose of guaranteeing all ordinary shareholders the same opportunity to sell as controlling shareholders would not be fulfilled. The larger the major shareholder’s stake, the fewer opportunities ordinary shareholders would have to sell if only that stake were purchased first.
Countries Worldwide Have Adopted 100% Mandatory Tender Offers... M&A Would Not Be Stifled
The forum warned that this would be a “self-contradictory system” out of step with global standards. According to the forum, the United Kingdom, Germany, France, the Netherlands, Spain, Switzerland, Italy, Hong Kong, and Singapore all operate mandatory tender offer systems covering 100% of shares, based on the acquisition threshold. The United States has no mandatory tender offer system, but in practice, 100% tender offers are conducted through a combination of a strong disclosure system, the highest-price rule (which requires that all shareholders be able to sell at the same highest price in a tender offer), and the entire fairness review standard.
South Korean companies have also acquired 100% stakes overseas in line with global standards. A leading example is Samsung Electronics’ acquisition of automotive electronics and audio company Harman for a total of $8 billion in 2016. At the time, Samsung Electronics offered all of Harman’s shareholders the opportunity to sell at the same price, including a 28% premium, before acquiring 100% of the shares. Samsung Biologics followed the same approach when it acquired Swiss peptide contract development and manufacturing organization (CDMO) company PolyPeptide Group in July. Ordinary shareholders sold their shares to Samsung Biologics at the same price as the controlling shareholder, which held a 56% stake.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The forum also rejected concerns that increasing the mandatory tender offer threshold to 100% would stifle M&A. “In Japan, the M&A market has actually become very active over the past two to three years since the introduction of mandatory tender offers,” it said. “Given that the acquisition financing market has already grown and is active in South Korea, there is no basis for the concern. International investors with extensive experience around the world also strongly disagree with the claim that the market would be stifled by the burden of financing M&A acquisitions.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.