Giant A4-Sized Hangtags Appear
Returns Surge Every Year During Singles' Day Season

Clothing sold on Chinese online shopping platforms has recently sparked controversy because it comes with a giant hangtag the size of an A4 sheet of paper.


Jinan Daily reported on November 3 that "opinions are divided over whether A4-sized hangtags are sellers' self-help measure to prepare for a surge in returns or an excessive response."

A giant, A4-sized hangtag attached to clothing has sparked controversy. Source: Baidu, China.

A giant, A4-sized hangtag attached to clothing has sparked controversy. Source: Baidu, China.

View original image

"Too many customers return items for no reason"

AI-generated image.

AI-generated image.

View original image

Recently, products with A4-sized hangtags attached to the clothing and prominently bearing the words "No returns or exchanges after removal" were posted on Chinese social media, sparking heated debate.


According to the report, some hangtags are attached to the front of the clothing and are so large that the fabric can be pulled or distorted unless the garment is supported by hand when trying it on. Some people complained that the tags make it difficult even to try the clothes on. Others, however, said they "prevent unscrupulous shoppers from wearing an item once and returning it, reducing the risk of buying a product someone else has used."


Returns surge during Singles' Day season, giving sellers a headache


Sellers say they have resorted to this because of the substantial losses caused by unsellable inventory. One seller said, "This is a measure to prevent consumers from returning items that show signs of wear. Clothes that have been worn cannot be resold and have to be discarded, and the cost per garment is so high that it makes it difficult to run the business." Another seller said, "Too many people wear clothes and return them within seven days without giving a reason. Since customers do not want to receive secondhand goods, we have no choice but to manage returns more strictly."


The outlet said, "Cases of people wearing an item once to go out or for a photo shoot and then returning it are common. Sellers have to cover all the costs, including return shipping, cleaning, repairs and disposal, which will eventually lead to higher clothing prices."


Returns increase exponentially during Singles' Day season, China's major annual shopping event held on November 11. In 2025, sellers sparked controversy by selling clothes secured with padlocks. At the time, sellers complained, "The clothes come back stained and smelling of perfume, making them difficult to resell," and "If we refuse a return, buyers leave reviews saying our after-sales service is terrible."


"Giant hangtags are a temporary fix and will ultimately drive up clothing prices"

A giant hangtag the size of an A4 sheet attached to clothing has sparked controversy. China’s Baidu.

A giant hangtag the size of an A4 sheet attached to clothing has sparked controversy. China’s Baidu.

View original image

Experts view this phenomenon as the result of a breakdown in trust in the e-commerce market. Zhang Han, a senior researcher at Pangoal Institution, explained that sellers' inventory losses continue to mount due to a combination of inaccurate product descriptions from some sellers, inconsistent sizing standards, and some consumers' abuse of return policies. Zhang said this has led sellers to adopt such measures to reduce their losses.


Zhang cautioned, however, that "physical measures such as A4-sized hangtags are only a temporary fix. Additional spending to prevent returns will ultimately lead to higher clothing prices and could eventually threaten the entire industry."



Questions have also been raised about the legal effectiveness of the measure. Attorney Shen Xu of Guangdong Guohui Law Firm explained that the legally mandated seven-day return period without giving a reason is a consumer right, so sellers cannot automatically refuse a refund based solely on a notice saying "No refunds after the tag is removed." However, Shen said, "A return can be refused if the product is worn or stained and is no longer in good condition. Since the burden of proof rests with the seller, platforms should establish fair dispute resolution and self-regulatory mechanisms to protect the rights of both parties."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.