Supreme Court overturns appellate ruling that split offenses committed before and after imprisonment and imposed separate sentences

The Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

The Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Supreme Court ruled that a nephew who extorted money and valuables from his uncle, a person with a severe disability, by threatening him 82 times should be punished for the entire course of conduct as a single offense, even though he spent a year in prison during that period, if he resumed the crimes using the same method immediately after his release.


According to legal sources on November 3, the Supreme Court's Second Division, presided over by Justice Park Youngjae, recently overturned an appellate ruling that had divided A's extortion offenses into two counts and sentenced him to one year and two years and six months in prison, respectively, and had also sentenced him to six months for violating the Act on Welfare of Persons with Disabilities. The court remanded the case to the Daejeon District Court.


A is accused of threatening his maternal uncle, who has cerebral palsy and a severe disability, and taking more than 39 million won from him on 82 occasions between November 2021 and June 2025. The money included disability benefits and basic livelihood assistance deposited into a bank account managed by the uncle. Investigators found that A threatened him, saying, "If you don't give me money, I'll smash everything in the house and kill you all."


The key issue was the period during which A was in prison while the crimes were ongoing. In January 2023, A was sentenced to prison for fraud and other offenses unrelated to this case, and was released on parole in January 2024. Lower courts disagreed over whether the extortion offenses committed before and after that year-long period should be grouped as a "comprehensive single offense," in which multiple acts constitute one crime, or treated as separate offenses.


The trial court treated all 82 extortion incidents as a comprehensive single offense and, in conjunction with the violation of the Act on Welfare of Persons with Disabilities, sentenced A to one year and eight months in prison. The appellate court ruled differently. It found that serving a year in prison had interrupted the unity and continuity of A's criminal intent. Accordingly, it divided the 30 incidents before his imprisonment and the 52 after his release into two offenses, sentencing him separately to one year and two years and six months in prison. With an additional six-month sentence for violating the Act on Welfare of Persons with Disabilities, A's total prison sentence increased to four years.


The Supreme Court rejected that ruling. The panel explained that courts must assess the method, circumstances, and motive of each offense, the time elapsed between offenses, and whether a subsequent offense was committed while the circumstances still allowed the offender to exploit the same opportunity or relationship. They must then determine whether there are grounds to find that the criminal intent was interrupted or newly formed.


Applying this standard, the panel found that A's criminal intent continued even while he was in prison. It noted that A told investigators that he had called his uncle from prison and asked him to send money, suggesting that he engaged in similar conduct while incarcerated. The panel also pointed out that A extorted money again in the same way just three days after being released on parole.



The panel said that, considering the victim was A's uncle and was particularly vulnerable to the crime because of his disability, the fact that A had been imprisoned alone was not enough to conclude that his intent to commit extortion had been interrupted or newly formed.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing