[Ask The Era] A New Path for South Korea-Japan Relations: Now It's Our Politicians' Turn to Light the Way
South Korea-Japan diplomacy held back by historical disputes
Domestic politics sway diplomacy, undermining trust
Japan must face history and cooperate with South Korea
South Korea, too, must move beyond victimhood and embrace confiden
Not long ago, I spoke before Japanese intellectuals in Kobe. I began with President Park Chung-hee's normalization of diplomatic relations in 1965 and the 1998 Japan-South Korea Joint Declaration by Kim Dae-jung and Keizo Obuchi. I was a high school senior in 1965 and took part in protests against the normalization, but in 1998, although I was an opposition lawmaker, I did not oppose the Joint Declaration. Decades have passed since the two leaders risked their political careers to make those decisions. Where should relations between South Korea and Japan go from here?
At the event, I proposed three things each country should change. A serious question-and-answer session continued for more than an hour after my speech. But there were things I could not bring myself to say in full on foreign soil: the shameful, unvarnished face of our politics. Today, I want to speak to South Korean readers and add the rest of my confession. What I have sought to uphold, in the past and present alike, is the dignity and national interest of the Republic of Korea, as well as its future. What has changed is our national strength, and the way we deal with Japan must change accordingly.
We cannot change our geographical location. Whether we like it or not, South Korea and Japan are neighbors who must live alongside one another. The economies and security of the two countries are already deeply intertwined at the level of survival and prosperity. Even so, whenever things do not go our way, we get caught up in historical issues and emotions and repeat cycles of confrontation and deadlock. Relations between South Korea and Japan must now move beyond a passive stance of simply waiting for Japan to change. When diplomacy becomes a tool for emotional incitement, the national interest disappears, and our future is left at the mercy of others. We must firmly break this irresponsible vicious cycle.
Three Things Japan Should Change
First, Japan must move beyond the habit of viewing South Korea only through the lens of the United States. When I visited Japan at the invitation of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs more than 20 years ago, I got the impression that South Korea was like a weather forecast tucked into the corner of a Japanese television screen. While Japan focused its attention across the Pacific on the United States, it left its closest neighbor in a strategic blind spot. That perspective still seems to persist. If Japan recognizes the importance of Asia and wants stability and prosperity, it must turn its gaze toward Asia. And it must look to its immediate neighborhood for a true partner. That takes wisdom and courage.
Second, Japan must treat South Korea not as a country whose past needs to be managed, but as a partner with which to shape the future. Cooperation must be rooted in institutions that remain steady even when administrations change, going beyond friendly gestures between leaders. Amid North Korea's nuclear threat, China's rise, and tensions in the Taiwan Strait, South Korea is the neighbor with which Japan should work most closely. Does Japan think it can overcome all these immense challenges through the U.S.-Japan security alliance alone?
Third, Japan must not let historical issues hold it back. If Japan honestly reflects on the past first, to the point where South Korea can say, "That is enough," it will be a path that benefits Japan above all. Only by humbly looking back on its past wrongs, if it is to protect peace in Northeast Asia and the values of liberal democracy, will Japan earn the genuine trust and respect of countries across Asia. If it evades the issue or insists it did nothing wrong, it is unfit to lead.
Three Things South Korea Should Change
Having made demands of Japan, we must also ask ourselves some painful questions.
First, how long will we make historical issues the starting point and precondition for all diplomacy? This is not to say that we should forget the suffering of victims or the humiliation of colonial rule. But the argument that we cannot change because Japan has not changed is no different from handing our future over to Japan. Historical issues are a matter of principle and dignity. We must stop putting them at the forefront of every diplomatic issue and tying our own hands. We should stand far prouder, if only out of respect for those who shed their blood for our country. There is no need to waste our national strength trying to extract an "insincere apology."
Second, we must break the vicious cycle of making diplomacy hostage to domestic politics. We say that Japan cannot be trusted, but from Japan's perspective, South Korea is also an unpredictable partner. The Moon Jae-in administration's record alone shows how the comfort women agreement, painstakingly reached, and the Reconciliation and Healing Foundation were dismantled, and how the dispute escalated to the point of notifying Japan of the termination of the General Security of Military Information Agreement (GSOMIA) in response to Japanese export restrictions. During this process, emotional incitement such as the "Jukchangga" song swept through politics. President Lee Jae-myung, too, sharply criticized treated water from Fukushima, calling it "nuclear wastewater," when he was an opposition party leader.
It is encouraging that since taking office, he has shifted course toward "pragmatic diplomacy," and that the two countries have made progress, including through the leaders' visits to each other's hometowns and efforts to cooperate in identifying the remains of victims of the Chosei coal mine. But Japan remembers the remarks made in the past and is watching closely to see whether these actions are sincere or will be reversed again as the political landscape changes. Rebuilding the national interest and trust undermined by politicians' inflammatory rhetoric takes several times as much effort.
Third, South Korea must deal with Japan through competence and confidence, not a sense of victimhood. South Korea is no longer the poor country it was in 1965. It has developed global competitiveness in semiconductors, shipbuilding, the defense industry, and cultural industries, and its per capita gross domestic product (GDP) is on a par with or ahead of Japan's. We should learn what there is to learn, compete where we should compete, and cooperate confidently where we should cooperate.
Young people are already showing this confidence through their actions. Last year, more than 9 million South Koreans visited Japan, and Japan is also the most popular destination for South Korean travelers. They are not traveling back and forth because they are unaware of history. They are simply refusing to let past conflicts dictate today's encounters and the future. While politicians try to rally their supporters through emotions rooted in the past, young people are already crossing borders and opening up the future.
Let's Establish a "South Korea-Japan Joint Ancient History Research Fund"
South Korea faces security threats from North Korea, China, and Russia, while the United States is leaning toward transactional diplomacy centered on its national interests. If, in these circumstances, South Korea argues with Japan, cannot say a word to China, and only watches North Korea warily, what will become of the country? How much could the United States trust such a country? Japan faces the same situation. If South Korea is destabilized, Japan too will have to bear enormous security costs alone. The two countries share a strategic destiny.
So where should we begin? I propose establishing a "South Korea-Japan Joint Ancient History Research Fund." Since ancient times, the Korean Peninsula and the Japanese archipelago have shared goods and culture across the sea. There are sensitive issues, too. That is all the more reason to pursue academic research free from political interference. The research foundations in both countries will also grow stronger. A country's geographical location may be its fate, but we cannot leave its future to fate as well. Saying that we should change first does not mean yielding to Japan; it is a confident declaration by a sovereign state that we will decide our own future.
When crossing rough seas on a dark night, the most reliable guide is the nearest lighthouse. It is up to us to light that beacon first. Now our politicians must ask themselves: "How long will we remain preoccupied with criticizing Japan while closing our eyes to designing a future that goes beyond it?"
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Kim Hyung-o, former Speaker of the National Assembly
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.