"You're late. What time did you get here?"


Would it constitute workplace harassment if a supervisor said something like this in a pressuring tone, even though the subordinate was not late? The court ruled that it did constitute harassment and that the salary-reduction penalty was lawful. It said the supervisor, who had the authority to reassign employees, improperly pressured subordinates from a position of superiority.


The 12th Administrative Division of the Seoul Administrative Court, presided over by Judge Kang Jaewon, ruled against the plaintiff on September 10, 2026, in a lawsuit (2025GuHap56587) filed by civil servant A, who works for Gangbuk-gu, Seoul, seeking to overturn a salary-reduction measure imposed by the district office.


[Facts]

While working as a department head, A received a two-month salary reduction for remarks made to subordinates, including a team leader and an administrative officer, that were deemed workplace harassment. A told an employee giving a work report, "Don't try to explain it to me," and asked the team leader, "You're late. What time did you get here?" The team leader had not been late. A also told a female employee who wanted to take annual leave to care for her child, "Have your husband watch the child."


A filed an appeal with the Local Appeals Commission, which reduced the penalty to a one-month salary reduction, stating: "The grounds for discipline—that the remarks constituted workplace harassment—are recognized. Given that A has no prior disciplinary record, it is appropriate to reduce the penalty." A challenged the decision and filed a lawsuit.


[Court's Ruling (Summary)]

- When A said, "Don't try to explain it to me," A was not giving a work instruction but reprimanding the employee's manner of speaking and cutting off the report and explanation.


- A's remark asking about the employee's arrival time was also made to a staff member with no actual attendance issue, reflecting an expectation that the employee arrive early. In particular, since A had the authority to reassign the team leader who heard the remark, making such a comment to an employee with no attendance problem constituted "improper pressure," even if A did not directly require the employee to arrive early.


- The remark, "Have your husband watch the child," not only obstructed or made it difficult to take legitimate annual leave, but also amounted to giving instructions about the employee's personal life rather than work, and therefore could not be considered within the appropriate scope of work-related authority.


- Even a one-time remark can constitute workplace harassment. Each of A's remarks exceeded the scope of appropriate work instructions and undermined employee morale and the working environment of the entire department.



Park Suyeon, Legal Times Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing