Poland: Prime Minister and President Clash Over Control of Constitutional Tribunal
Police Seal Off Tribunal Headquarters After Surprise Suspension of Its Chief
Uproar as President Turns Back His Plane and Enters Amid Scuffle

In Poland, a country with a semi-presidential system, a fierce clash over control of the judiciary between the pro-European Union (EU) cabinet of Prime Minister Donald Tusk and the nationalist right-wing camp of President Karol Nawrocki has plunged the country into profound political turmoil. The sudden suspension of the sitting president of the Constitutional Tribunal, the abrupt sealing off of its current headquarters, and even the return of the president's plane from a trip to Africa and a forcible entry involving physical scuffles have left the constitutional order seemingly paralyzed beyond repair. As tensions between the two sides escalate ahead of next year's general election, the standoff is expected to have significant repercussions not only for the paralysis of the Polish government but also for EU rule-of-law disputes and European security cooperation.


Police officers stand guard on the grounds of Poland's Constitutional Tribunal in Warsaw. Xinhua-Yonhap News<br>

Police officers stand guard on the grounds of Poland's Constitutional Tribunal in Warsaw. Xinhua-Yonhap News

View original image

President Rushes Home After Tribunal Chief Suspended

According to Bloomberg and other news outlets on November 1, Polish Constitutional Tribunal Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska announced on October 30 (local time) that she had suspended Tribunal President Bogdan Swieczkowski and Vice President Bartlomiej Sochanski for one month and would take charge of the tribunal's operations.


Swieczkowski, who served as a deputy justice minister under the previous Law and Justice (PiS) government, has faced criticism for blocking judges appointed by the current government from participating in the tribunal's work. Korwin-Piotrowska was also elected by parliament, but has been unable to serve as a judge because the president refused to administer her oath of office and the existing leadership excluded her from the tribunal's work.


As the situation escalated rapidly, President Nawrocki turned his plane around and returned to Warsaw while en route to a visit to Senegal. He announced that he was cutting short his trip in a social media post saying, in effect, "At a moment like this, the president should be in Poland."


Polish demonstrators protest the suspension of the head of Poland's Constitutional Tribunal. EPA-Yonhap News

Polish demonstrators protest the suspension of the head of Poland's Constitutional Tribunal. EPA-Yonhap News

View original image

A standoff and physical scuffles broke out as people tried to enter the tribunal's headquarters, where police had been deployed. Protests against the suspension continued for a second day outside the tribunal, and three people were detained after some demonstrators clashed with police.


"We Cannot Back Down," Says Prime Minister; President Calls It a "Constitutional Coup"

In a televised address on October 31, Prime Minister Tusk said, "We cannot back down, because we have waited too long," stressing the need to restore the tribunal's independence and the rule of law. He said politicians must not enter courts or the Constitutional Tribunal to order or threaten judges, and noted that the president was no exception.


President Nawrocki, by contrast, characterized the move as a forcible takeover of a constitutional institution and argued that it violated the constitutional order. Former Justice Minister Zbigniew Ziobro, a member of PiS, also condemned it as an attack on the constitutional order and called for resistance.


President Nawrocki convened an emergency meeting with the leaders of parliamentary parties, including PiS and the Polish People's Party (PSL), but Prime Minister Tusk and the Civic Coalition (KO) did not attend. With the two sides unable to narrow their differences, the possibility of a political compromise remains uncertain.


Dispute Over Judicial Appointments Stretches Back to 2015

The root cause of the current crisis is a dispute over appointments to the Constitutional Tribunal that has continued since 2015. At the time, a parliament led by Civic Platform (PO) elected five judges ahead of the general election. After winning the election, PiS overturned those appointments and appointed new candidates. PiS then expanded its influence over key judicial institutions, including the Constitutional Tribunal, during its eight years in power through 2023.


Police officers stand guard on the grounds of Poland's Constitutional Tribunal in Warsaw. EPA-Yonhap News.

Police officers stand guard on the grounds of Poland's Constitutional Tribunal in Warsaw. EPA-Yonhap News.

View original image

After winning the 2023 general election, the Tusk government began reforms, pledging to restore the independence of the judiciary, which it said had been undermined by the previous administration. However, most of the 15 Constitutional Tribunal judges had been appointed during PiS's time in power, and President Nawrocki refused or delayed administering the oath of office to judges newly elected by parliament. The existing tribunal leadership also barred them from participating in its work, prolonging the conflict.


The Tusk government argues that excluding judges elected by parliament from the tribunal's work undermines the rule of law. The president and the existing leadership, by contrast, maintain that those who have not completed the formal oath-taking process cannot exercise the powers of a judge. The debate over the legal legitimacy of the current suspensions is an extension of this broader dispute.


Reforms Blocked by Presidential Vetoes... Fears of Government Paralysis

Poland has a political system with semi-presidential features: the prime minister leads the executive branch, while the directly elected president also has considerable powers, including the right to veto legislation. Repeated clashes have occurred during policymaking as the prime minister and president belong to opposing political camps.


Since taking office, President Nawrocki has vetoed 37 bills advanced by the Tusk cabinet, including measures to ease penalties related to abortion, reform the judiciary, and introduce EU legislation regulating Big Tech. The Tusk government needs legislative achievements ahead of next year's general election, but the president's vetoes and the controversy over the composition of the Constitutional Tribunal are obstructing reform.


Strain on EU Rule of Law and European Security

The European Commission has urged Poland to swiftly complete the process of appointing new judges, saying that the country's Constitutional Tribunal must function in accordance with the Polish Constitution and the case law of the European Court of Justice (ECJ). The EU also raised concerns about the undermining of judicial independence in Poland during PiS's time in power.


The conflict is also weighing on European politics. With far-right parties gaining influence in countries including Spain and France, Poland's political confrontation could highlight divisions within the EU between centrist and nationalist forces.



Poland's political instability also carries significant security implications. The country is a key transit hub for Western military and humanitarian aid to Ukraine and a major defensive stronghold on NATO's eastern flank. There are concerns that if the conflict between the president and prime minister affects security decision-making, it could also hamper the West's deterrence against Russia and cooperation among allies.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing