Numerous unreasonable practices by construction companies in joint implementation
Excessive fees and contracts that make accountability difficult
Seoul to distribute standard guidelines next month and push for legal amendments

Seoul Mayor Oh Sehoon visits the Seogye and Cheongpa-dong areas of Yongsan-gu, Seoul, on the 11th, where resident-selected private redevelopment projects, including Fast-Track Integrated Planning and Moa Town, are underway, and looks around the sites. Aug. 11, 2026. Photo by Yoon Dongju

Seoul Mayor Oh Sehoon visits the Seogye and Cheongpa-dong areas of Yongsan-gu, Seoul, on the 11th, where resident-selected private redevelopment projects, including Fast-Track Integrated Planning and Moa Town, are underway, and looks around the sites. Aug. 11, 2026. Photo by Yoon Dongju

View original image

The Seoul Metropolitan Government will overhaul the unreasonable joint-implementation arrangements arising in small-scale housing maintenance projects. It plans to protect the rights and interests of association members by addressing construction companies’ lack of expertise and excessive fee structures in projects they jointly implement with associations.


On November 2, the Seoul Metropolitan Government said that its analysis of 45 joint-implementation contracts for small-scale housing maintenance projects and its inspection of two associations had identified a lack of transparency in the selection process, excessive advance fee payments, and contractual structures that made it difficult to hold parties accountable.


Joint implementation in small-scale housing maintenance projects is a system introduced to enable construction companies to support associations lacking financial resources and expertise from the outset. However, problems have persisted, with some construction companies performing work similar to that of maintenance service providers while collecting excessive fees without taking responsibility for construction or financing.


The Seoul Metropolitan Government’s investigation found that construction companies acting as joint implementers performed work similar to that of maintenance service providers, including tasks related to obtaining consent to establish an association, feasibility reviews, preparation of implementation plans, and applications for approval of project implementation plans. However, most contracts did not specify financing, which is the system’s original purpose.


In particular, maintenance service providers are selected through a public tender, competition among multiple companies, and a vote at a general meeting. By contrast, a construction company acting as a joint implementer can be selected with the consent of only a majority of association members, raising concerns that this could bypass competition and vetting, the investigation found.


Many construction companies acting as joint implementers also charged excessive fees. All 45 contracts analyzed by the Seoul Metropolitan Government set fees at 2.0% to 2.8% of total sales revenue, but none specified how total sales revenue would be calculated or provided an estimated total amount. This is more than four times the service fees for assigning the same work to a maintenance service provider.


Despite being joint implementers expected to share project risks, 35 of the 45 contracts required associations to pay 60% to 70% of the fees by the time they received approval for their project implementation plans, before any sales proceeds were generated, and up to as much as 80% by the start of construction. Most contracts also failed to include provisions in the standard agreement for maintenance projects concerning performance guarantees, joint project-cost accounts, prohibitions on the improper provision of money or benefits and interference for private gain, and loans of funds.


There is currently no process for vetting joint implementers’ capacity to carry out projects in advance. As a result, a small number of companies have taken on multiple project sites simultaneously. This could lead to inadequate project management for individual associations, but contractual duties and responsibilities were unclear, making it difficult to hold parties accountable when problems arose.


Following repeated complaints that construction companies intervened from the association-establishment stage and controlled projects as a whole, the Seoul Metropolitan Government conducted inspections of two associations from July 27 to August 7, 2026. The inspections identified a total of 49 cases of improper conduct, resulting in nine referrals for investigation, 21 corrective orders, and 19 administrative guidance measures.


The Seoul Metropolitan Government plans to improve the system across the board, from vetting joint implementers at the selection stage to clarifying contractual responsibilities and ensuring transparency in project operations. It will also respond firmly to illegal or improper conduct.


In August and October 2026, the Seoul Metropolitan Government submitted proposals to the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport on two occasions to amend the Small-Scale Housing Maintenance Act. The proposals call for establishing a legal basis for setting standards for the selection of joint implementers and their agreements, and for stipulating in the law that construction companies participating as joint implementers must also bear the responsibilities of a construction contractor.


The Seoul Metropolitan Government will draw up and distribute standard joint-implementation guidelines in December 2026, and have autonomous districts and associations apply them first. The standard agreement will include the selection methods and procedures for construction companies acting as joint implementers (including registered developers); selection criteria covering bid proposals; information about construction companies; a standard consent form that discloses the estimated total fees in advance; the scope of work and responsibilities of the selected construction company; and the criteria for calculating fees.


On-site management and oversight will also be significantly strengthened. The city, autonomous districts, and outside experts will jointly conduct targeted inspections of the joint-implementer selection process, contract terms, and overall financial management. If illegal or improper conduct is uncovered, the city will take firm action, including issuing corrective orders and referring cases for investigation. Inspection results will be sent to the relevant associations and disclosed to their members.



Myeong Nojun, director of the Seoul Metropolitan Government’s Housing Office, said, "Associations choose joint implementation to supplement their expertise, and members should not have to shoulder a heavy fee burden." He added, "Even before the law is amended, we will continue to promote the use of the Seoul Metropolitan Government’s standard agreement and conduct additional inspections of individual construction companies to ensure that association members are not harmed."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing