"Limitations of existing mediation procedures that require agreement between the parties"
The Ministry of Education says it will use the Education Conflict Management Committee.

The Ministry of Education has effectively rejected a recommendation from the National Human Rights Commission of Korea to establish dispute mediation bodies at metropolitan and provincial offices of education so that conflicts at schools can be resolved through dialogue and mediation. The Commission stressed that more conflicts within schools are leading to lawsuits and other judicial proceedings, and that practical measures are needed to resolve problems through dialogue and restore relationships.


According to the Commission on November 2, it recommended policies in February to the Minister of Education and the superintendents of 17 metropolitan and provincial offices of education to create schools that respect human rights. The recommendations included 21 tasks in three areas aimed at safeguarding the rights of students and teachers. After reviewing the Ministry of Education's response, the Commission concluded that the ministry had not accepted eight of the recommendations, as it had presented no specific implementation plans for amending laws or introducing new systems.

Minister of Education Choi Kyojin adjusts his glasses during a parliamentary audit held by the National Assembly Education Committee on the 23rd of last month. Yonhap News

Minister of Education Choi Kyojin adjusts his glasses during a parliamentary audit held by the National Assembly Education Committee on the 23rd of last month. Yonhap News

View original image

The Commission particularly called for a separate body to resolve conflicts within schools. It said that, since disputes can escalate between the parties when they lead to legal battles, offices of education should establish procedures to resolve problems through dialogue and mediation. It also proposed considering a system that would, in principle, refer all disputes to mediation, rather than allowing the process to be used only when the parties wish to do so.


The Ministry of Education, however, said that existing Education Conflict Management Committees could be used. These committees mediate conflicts that arise at schools and help resolve them. Each metropolitan or provincial office of education may establish one as needed. The ministry cited the fact that such procedures are already in place, but the Commission said that although a legal basis exists, the committees are not required to be established at education offices nationwide, and called for specific implementation measures.


In addition to establishing dispute mediation bodies, the Commission recommended various institutional improvements to safeguard the human rights of all members of the school community. These included explicitly stipulating human rights education for school community members in education-related laws and regulations, strengthening teachers' capacity to provide human rights education, and expanding such education for new teachers, school staff, and guardians. The recommendations also included ensuring that students can participate in school management committees and establishing a legal basis for self-governing organizations such as student councils, teachers' councils, staff councils, and parent associations.


The Commission further called for laws and regulations to specify the rights students are entitled to and the procedures for seeking remedies, and for a legal basis to conduct surveys on the human rights conditions of teachers. It also proposed safeguards to protect teachers' right to health and prevent less experienced teachers from being burdened with undesirable duties. The Commission also recommended adding provisions to the Act on the Status of Teachers to prevent and address workplace harassment among teachers.


However, the Ministry of Education did not present specific implementation plans for eight tasks, including legislating human rights education; establishing alternative dispute resolution bodies within offices of education; explicitly recognizing student rights as a standard for student guidance; specifying student rights and remedies in law; surveying teachers' human rights conditions; and establishing a system to address workplace harassment.



A Commission official said, "The provisions in current laws and regulations alone are not enough to guarantee specific rights and remedies," adding, "We will work to ensure that the Ministry of Education and other relevant agencies review the intent of the recommendations and pursue institutional improvements."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing