The three lowest-ranked experts scored in the 50s.

Lawyers representing parties in litigation evaluated court-appointed experts, who received an average score of 72.37 out of 100. The three lowest-ranked experts averaged scores in the 50s.

Seoul Bar Association

Seoul Bar Association

View original image

On October 29, the Seoul Bar Association submitted the results of its "2026 Expert Evaluation" to the National Court Administration. A total of 976 experts were evaluated.


The Seoul Bar Association introduced the expert evaluation system in May and closed submissions in September. A total of 449 members participated, submitting 1,505 valid evaluation forms. The evaluation covered experts appointed by courts nationwide in cases handled by members between 2024 and 2026.


The five evaluation criteria were ethics and impartiality; case management and communication; expertise; adherence to deadlines and follow-up management; and fees. Each criterion had two questions, for a total of 10 questions. Each question was scored out of 10, with the scores combined for a total of 100.


The Seoul Bar Association selected the three highest-scoring experts as outstanding experts and the three lowest-scoring experts as low-ranked experts, among those evaluated by at least five lawyers. The outstanding experts were Kim Donghyun of Jeongmyeong Appraisal Corporation, Park Geumho of Kumho General Architects Office, and Oh Jun of the Construction Dispute Technology Institute.


Reports concerning the low-ranked experts included cases in which they submitted perfunctory expert reports without specific grounds, made significant calculation errors in high-value appraisals, and were suspected of conducting on-site inspections after preparing appraisal reports. Other reports said that, despite charging high fees, some experts submitted reports that merely summarized the parties' claims without offering professional judgment.


The Seoul Bar Association cited factors that undermine confidence in expert appraisals, including compromised fairness and impartiality; arbitrary judgments beyond the scope of the appraisal questions and the court's instructions; inadequate appraisals lacking expertise and objective grounds; delays in litigation resulting from poor performance and improper procedures; and inappropriate calculation or claims of appraisal fees.



A Seoul Bar Association official said, "If the results of evaluations by lawyers' organizations are incorporated into the selection and management of experts, alongside the courts' expert rating system, they could make a practical contribution to operating a fairer and more objective expert appraisal system."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing