[Market Pulse] Korean Economy Wins Unprecedented Praise, But Is Its Next March Ready?
Record-high economic indicators, but only one instrument: "semiconductors"
If the soloist falters, the entire performance could stop at any moment
A new score needs imagination, patience, experimentation, harmony, and expansion
People matter most... creative destruction is essential
Applause fills the auditorium of our economy today. A range of economic indicators are also soaring. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) raised its growth forecast for this year to 3.3% this month, marking the second consecutive increase, while exports in early September rose more than 80% from a year earlier. But there is effectively just one instrument carrying the performance: semiconductors, which account for 47% of exports. However dazzling a solo may be, a symphony is not a performance for a single instrument. Reports say the United States is considering tariffs not only on semiconductors but also on laptops and servers, while the share of the population of working age has fallen below 70%. If the soloist falters, the entire performance could come to a halt at any moment.
Even when world-class musicians gather on one stage, their sound becomes noise if they have no score to play together. Raising the conductor's voice will not change that. A good score is a prerequisite for a good orchestra. I would like to ask whether our economy has a new score today.
For the past 60 years, our country had a fine score for industrial development. The government expanded infrastructure, companies built factories, the financial sector provided funding, and people learned new skills. We took the world stage by playing more precisely and cheaply the pieces that developed countries had played first. In an era when we had to escape poverty, that was the most rousing of marches.
But the concert hall has changed. The global economy is moving beyond catch-up innovation, which means making products invented by others better, toward pioneering innovation that imagines and creates markets that did not previously exist. New instruments, including artificial intelligence (AI), biotechnology, quantum technology, and energy, are appearing one after another, and yesterday's competitors are becoming today's collaborators. The audience has changed, too. It wants not cheaper products, but unprecedented experiences and services tailored to individual needs. The moment we repeat yesterday's melody, the auditorium empties.
What should a new score look like? Israel, a country with scarce resources, has rewritten its score by turning the challenges of each era into themes for the next industry. Water shortages in the 1970s led to the desalination industry; nuclear and radiation research in the 1980s gave rise to technologies for safety, precision measurement, and nuclear medicine; the internet era of the 1990s led to a cybersecurity industry that anticipated risks; and, from the 2000s onward, the focus expanded to medical devices, biotechnology, and digital health. Israel did not invent the internet, but it was first to turn the locks the internet needed into an industry. Talent cultivated by elite military units and venture capital seeded by the government connected the different movements. Israel, with a population of 10 million, and our country are different in scale, but we can learn from its approach of making the problems that need solving the themes for the next industries. The movements changed, but the central melody of overcoming scarcity through science and technology never wavered.
Our economy's new symphony also needs four movements. The first movement is "imagination." Like a fast allegro, we must set out first toward problems and markets that do not yet exist. A catch-up economy finds the right answers quickly, but a pioneering economy starts by asking new questions. The U.S. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) imagined technological disruptions that might lie ahead rather than products that could be sold immediately. In the process, the early seeds of foundational internet technologies, compact GPS receivers, speech recognition, and messenger RNA (mRNA) research were sown.
We are changing, too. The government has allocated KRW 39.5 trillion to next year's research and development (R&D) budget, an 11.2% increase over this year's budget, and shortened the review period for large-scale R&D projects from two years to three months. The pace has picked up. The question now is what we will ask. With KRW 4.1 trillion going to AI, we must also ensure that basic research is not neglected. Rather than simply repeating a list of industries to promote, we should make a list of challenges the world has yet to solve - the climate crisis, a super-aged society, food, infectious diseases, and caregiving - the first notes of new industries.
The second movement is "patience." A symphony needs an "adagio" that slows the pace. Basic science, new drugs, space, and quantum technology take a long time to bear fruit after the seeds are sown. Yet we demand innovation a decade from now while evaluating research funding annually and calling researchers incompetent after a few failures. The government R&D budget fell for the first time in 33 years in 2024, then increased by KRW 13 trillion in just three years. When the tempo shifts so wildly, decade-long research gets cut off halfway through. Israel has mechanisms for the government and private sector to share the risks of early-stage deep tech. Korea, too, needs "patient capital" at the national level that does not demand short-term revenue. We should expand the KRW 100 billion in investment-based R&D being piloted for the first time next year, and provide large-scale research projects with multi-year funding guarantees that are not shaken by budget fluctuations.
The third movement is "experimentation." Like a scherzo, lighthearted and bold attempts should spring up everywhere. In a pioneering economy, the ability to try things on a small scale and learn quickly matters more than a perfect business plan. Singapore tests new financial services in real-world settings within regulatory sandboxes, while setting limits on their scope and duration to contain the impact of failure. It did not eliminate regulation; it created a stage for safe experimentation. By contrast, when a new idea emerges here, we first look for which law it might violate, and if it fails, we reprimand its proponents for wasting public funds. Particularly in fields where legislation cannot keep pace with technology, such as physical AI and autonomous driving, we should first allow small-scale experiments, quickly scale up what succeeds, and preserve failures as data for the next attempt. In an economy that punishes failure, no one will try to write a new piece.
The fourth movement is "harmony and expansion." In the finale, every instrument must retain its own tone while coming together around a single theme. A decisive technological lead cannot be built through one company's solo performance. The Netherlands' ASML describes itself as both an architect and an integrator of technology, and has built a semiconductor equipment ecosystem with thousands of partner companies. Taiwan's TSMC brings together customers, design firms, software companies, and intellectual property (IP) firms on an open platform, reducing the time it takes for an idea to become a semiconductor product. For us, with semiconductors accounting for nearly half of exports, this is a matter of survival. A solo becomes an ensemble only when materials, equipment, fabless companies specializing in semiconductor design, and AI software grow together. Yet policy still manages large and small companies, universities and businesses, and the capital region and other regions in separate boxes. The manufacturing industry and software, the production capacity of large companies and the imagination of startups, must meet on the same score.
According to the “September Export and Import Trends” released by the Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy on the 1st, exports last month rose 83.5% year over year to $120.94 billion, setting a new monthly record. Export and import cargo is piled high at Busan Port’s Sinseondae (bottom), Gamman, and Singamman terminals. Yonhap News Agency
View original imagePeople must be part of the final passage. Those aged 65 and older now account for 20.7% of the population, and 3.3 working people support each older person. Ten years ago, the figure was 5.6. If the costs of industrial transformation are shifted entirely onto individuals, the performance cannot go on to the end. Denmark's flexicurity model offers workers who change jobs retraining and a safety net instead of clinging to outdated jobs. It gives companies the freedom to change and people the chance to get back on their feet. If creative destruction brings only destruction and no bridge to cross, people have no choice but to fear innovation.
A new score is not a blueprint for a planned economy in which the government writes every note and hands it out. It is a living score in which the state sets the broad themes and tempo, companies, universities, financial institutions, and workers each add their own variations, and the score is revised in response to the market. A conductor is not someone who plays every instrument on the musicians' behalf, but someone who arranges the order and space so they can produce their best sound.
We are not short of instruments. We have world-class manufacturing companies, digital infrastructure, and educated talent. The problem is that these instruments are still playing from the score of the industrial age. The first passage is not difficult: publish a list of national challenges, guarantee multi-year research funding, and allow small-scale experiments first. For the past 60 years, we have played pieces composed by others better than anyone else. Now it is time for us to compose. The next miracle of the Korean economy will begin not with a bigger slogan or a faster baton, but with writing a new score.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Yoon Jongrok, Adjunct Professor at KAIST and former Vice Minister of the Ministry of Science, ICT and Future Planning
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.