Arbitrarily changed diagnostic kit products and violated the Subcontracting Act by issuing written documents late

Celltrion, Inc., which benefited from a boom in diagnostic kits during the COVID-19 pandemic, was found to have engaged in unfair practices against its suppliers, including arbitrarily canceling large-scale contracts and issuing written documents late. The Korea Fair Trade Commission (KFTC) imposed sanctions for these violations of the Fair Transactions in Subcontracting Act, curbing abusive practices that could be widespread in the biotechnology industry.

With COVID Boom Over, Celltrion "Abruptly Canceled" 37 Million-Kit Order; Fined 630 Million Won View original image

On Oct. 29, the KFTC announced that it had decided to order Celltrion to take corrective measures and impose a total fine of 630 million won for violating the Subcontracting Act in the course of contracting out the manufacture of diagnostic kits. Of the total, 40 million won was imposed for violating the obligation to issue written documents, and 590 million won for violating the prohibition on unfairly canceling entrusted work.


From September 2021 to January 2022, when demand surged amid the pandemic, Celltrion entrusted a subcontractor with manufacturing COVID-19 rapid test kits on seven occasions. In the second and seventh orders, the company changed the products several times, switching between professional-use and home-use rapid test kits, but failed to issue any written contract amendments required by law. The KFTC also found that Celltrion placed the third order around November 2021, and began receiving deliveries on Dec. 1, but did not issue a written document specifying the product name, quantity and unit price until Dec. 16, 15 days later, disregarding even basic procedures for subcontracting transactions.


On Dec. 26, 2022, as the transition to an endemic phase of COVID-19 gathered pace, Celltrion terminated its diagnostic kit supply contract and unilaterally canceled the manufacturing orders for a total of 37.17 million kits that had not yet been delivered: 1.86 million from the second order and 35.31 million from the seventh. The subcontractor was left to bear the devastating impact of tens of millions of kits in inventory and disruption to production-line operations, despite having committed no clear wrongdoing and having had no opportunity to prepare in advance. This violated Article 8, Paragraph 1 of the Subcontracting Act, which strictly prohibits a principal contractor from arbitrarily canceling or changing a manufacturing or other outsourcing order when there is no reason attributable to the subcontractor.



The KFTC said, “By imposing strict sanctions on a principal contractor that unfairly canceled entrusted work and issued written documents late, we expect to help protect the rights and interests of subcontractors, who are in a relatively weaker position.” It added, “We will continue to correct unfair trading practices and focus our administrative resources on strengthening subcontractors’ rights and interests and establishing a fair order in subcontracting transactions.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing