Kim Yonghyun: Life Imprisonment; Noh Sangwon: 30 Years in Prison
Special Counsel: "First Trial Understated the Insurrection's Purpose and Preparation Period"

The special counsel team has sought the death penalty again on appeal for former President Yoon Suk Yeol, who was indicted on charges of leading an insurrection related to the Dec. 3 emergency martial law declaration.


At the appellate court's final hearing on the 29th, presided over by the Seoul High Court's 12-1 Criminal Division (High Court Judges Lee Seung-cheol, Jo Jin-gu and Kim Min-a), the special counsel team led by Cho Eun-seok sought the death penalty, saying, "There is no reason to hesitate to impose it." The team said, "He attempted to undermine the Constitution using power entrusted to him by the people," adding, "This was an act of treason that betrayed the trust of the people who elected him president." Former President Yoon was sentenced to life imprisonment in the first trial in February this year.


Former President Yoon Suk Yeol. Yonhap News Agency

Former President Yoon Suk Yeol. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The team sought life imprisonment for former Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun, who was indicted alongside Yoon. Kim was sentenced to 30 years in prison in the first trial. It also sought 30 years in prison for former Defense Intelligence Command chief Roh Sang-won, 20 years for former National Police Agency Commissioner General Cho Ji-ho, 15 years for former Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency Commissioner Kim Bong-sik, and 12 years for former National Assembly Security Service chief Mok Hyun-tae. It also requested 10-year prison sentences for former Third Field Army Command Military Police chief Kim Yong-gun and former National Office of Investigation officer for investigation planning and coordination Yoon Seung-young, both of whom were acquitted in the first trial.


The special counsel team argued that the first-trial court had misapplied the law concerning the establishment of the crime of insurrection. It took issue with the court's finding that the substantive and procedural requirements for emergency martial law had not been met while also holding that a separate use of force was necessary for the crime of insurrection to be established. Citing the Supreme Court en banc ruling in the insurrection cases involving former Presidents Chun Doo-hwan and Roh Tae-woo, the team said, "The Supreme Court held that when martial law is used for the purpose of disrupting the constitutional order, the martial law itself constitutes an insurrection, but the original court found that there had to be a separate act of execution as well." The team argued that the original court had misapplied the Supreme Court's legal principles and set the threshold for establishing insurrection too narrowly.


The court's findings on when preparations for emergency martial law began were also raised as an issue. The first-trial court found that former President Yoon had revealed his resolve to impose martial law by Dec. 1, 2024, at the latest. However, the special counsel team argued that, considering remarks about emergency powers and military commanders' plotting that had continued since March of that year, preparations for martial law had lasted at least eight months. It said the preparation period exceeded one year if the so-called "Roh Sang-won notebook" was included.


Regarding the purpose of preparing for martial law, the team argued that former President Yoon intended not only to suspend the National Assembly's functions but also to eliminate political opposition and monopolize power over the long term. The team emphasized, "The plan was to suspend the National Assembly, halt politics, transfer judicial authority to the military, arrest and investigate opposition figures, and seize legislative and judicial powers through a new legislative body," adding, "For a president who already holds executive power to seize all three branches of government amounts to a monopoly on power and marks the beginning of dictatorship."


Former Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun. Yonhap News.

Former Defense Minister Kim Yong-hyun. Yonhap News.

View original image

The special counsel team also challenged the first-trial court's sentencing decision, which imposed life imprisonment on former President Yoon. The court treated as mitigating circumstances that the martial law plan was not meticulous, that martial law ended quickly, and that the military and police refrained from using physical force. The team countered, "The plan was not inadequate," adding, "It was only because of resistance from the people and the passive performance of duties by frontline military and police personnel that events unfolded differently from the plan." It continued, "It was other people, not defendant Yoon Suk Yeol, who prevented bloodshed," arguing that the early end of martial law should not be considered in Yoon's favor.


The team also took issue with the court's treatment of Yoon's long public service career and lack of a criminal record as mitigating factors. In particular, it said he had used the legal knowledge he acquired while serving as a prosecutor to commit the crime, noting, "He did not break the law because he did not know it; he abused it like a legal expert."


The special counsel team called for severe punishment, citing the case of former President Chun Doo-hwan, who was sentenced to death for insurrection, had his sentence commuted to life imprisonment on appeal, and was later granted a special pardon. The team argued that the leniency shown at the time had led to former President Yoon's insurrection. It said, "The practice of not carrying out executions cannot be a reason not to impose the death penalty," and requested, "Please deliver the strongest sentence prescribed by law to ensure there is no second Yoon Suk Yeol."


Former President Yoon and others were indicted on charges of declaring emergency martial law on Dec. 3, 2024, and mobilizing the military and police to stage an insurrection with the aim of disrupting the constitutional order. The first-trial court found Yoon guilty of leading the insurrection and sentenced him to life imprisonment.



The court will conduct closing proceedings over three sessions, beginning today. After the defense team's closing arguments for former Minister Kim on Nov. 3, the court plans to hear the defense's closing arguments for former President Yoon and the defendants' final statements on Nov. 5, and then set a sentencing date.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing