"Student Support Is 'Handing Out Cash'?"... Education Superintendents Nationwide Push Back Against 'Grant Cuts'
Just 0.22% of the budget, yet branded "wasteful spending"... "Not indiscriminate cash handouts"
Followed government guidance, then faced penalties... "Policy inconsistency and inequity"
Education superintendents' council urges four reforms, including "caps proportional to spending"
Provincial and metropolitan education superintendents have expressed strong concern over the Ministry of Education's plan to tighten reductions in local education finance grants related to cash-based welfare spending, calling for a comprehensive review of the system.
They said it was inappropriate to stigmatize student education support programs, which account for just 0.22% of the total budget, as “profligate spending” or “handing out cash.” Above all, they called for changes to the unreasonable current system, under which grant cuts can exceed actual spending.
The Korea Council of Education Superintendents said on October 29, regarding the Ministry of Education's plan to tighten grant reductions related to cash-based welfare spending, that “the purpose and effects of student education support programs must be fully considered, and the proportionality and fairness of the reduction criteria must be ensured.”
Key Provisions of the Proposed Amendment to the Enforcement Rule of the Local Education Finance Grant Act. Provided by the Korean Council of Superintendents of Education.
View original imageThe council criticized some media outlets for describing the programs as “handing out cash” and generalizing them as examples of wasteful management of local education finances.
According to materials the Ministry of Education submitted to the National Assembly, self-funded social security benefit expenditures in 2025 totaled approximately 209 billion won. This amounted to just 0.22% of the approximately 95 trillion won in total final accounts for special accounts for education expenses, excluding Jeju.
The council said, “These expenditures include school enrollment preparation grants, sports uniform costs, and support for learning and career activities,” adding, “Even when provided in cash or vouchers, these programs support students' educational activities and should not be treated as indiscriminate cash payments.”
It said the entire education budget should not be deemed wasteful on the basis of support programs that account for only a tiny fraction of total final accounts. In particular, it focused on the structural contradiction in the Ministry of Education's proposed amendments to the Enforcement Rules of the Local Education Finance Grant Act.
The proposed amendments stipulate that grants to the eight education offices with the highest shares of self-funded social security benefit expenditures be cut by amounts ranging from 10 billion won to 1.25 billion won, depending on their rankings. As a result, total grant cuts would rise from the current maximum of 8 billion won to 45 billion won, an increase of approximately 5.6 times.
The council criticized the approach, saying, “Because the cuts are determined solely by rankings, without an objective standard for excessive spending, the system is structured so that the top eight education offices cannot avoid cuts, even if every education office reduces its spending.”
In a simulation of the proposed amendments based on 2025 final accounts, Sejong's education office had approximately 1.43 billion won in benefit expenditures, while its grant reduction was calculated at 3.75 billion won, resulting in the anomalous situation of grant cuts exceeding actual spending.
The government was also criticized for inconsistency in its policies and a lack of fairness. On February 26, the government recommended, through the Interagency Task Force on Special Management of Prices for People's Livelihoods, that enrollment support grants, including those for school uniforms, be provided in cash or vouchers rather than in kind.
The council criticized the government for recommending cash payments for school uniform support and then including those payments among the items subject to grant reductions, saying this was inconsistent with its policies. It also said that strengthening cuts only for education offices, despite abolishing reduction items related to cash-based welfare expenses in general grants to local governments, was inconsistent with policy fairness.
The council also identified as a problem the fact that cuts for the same enrollment support program could vary depending on whether a local government directly administers it or how an education office handles it in its accounts. It therefore called for a cautious approach to and revision of the amendments to the grant law and related subordinate legislation under review by the National Assembly, and proposed four improvements.
Specifically, the council called for ▲reconsidering the ranking-based reduction method and setting a cap on cuts in proportion to actual spending; ▲clarifying the criteria for including or excluding expenditures in the reduction calculation; ▲verifying each education office's final account data and disclosing the calculation details; and ▲applying the strengthened reduction criteria beginning with grants for fiscal year 2029.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The council said, “We must increase accountability and efficiency in education financing while ensuring stable funding for the education students need,” adding, “We will continue working with all 16 provincial and metropolitan education offices to improve the system reasonably and secure stable local education finances.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.