Formaldehyde Found in Cigarettes, Heated Tobacco Products, and Liquid E-Cigarettes
46 Substances Analyzed: "Lower Levels Do Not Mean Less Harmful"

In the first-ever test of harmful substances in 465 tobacco products sold in South Korea, human carcinogens were found in cigarettes, heated tobacco products and liquid e-cigarettes. Formaldehyde was detected in 99 of the 105 liquid e-cigarette products tested.


First-Ever Harmful-Substance Test of 465 Tobacco Products: Carcinogens Found in 99 of 105 "E-Cigarettes" View original image

On October 29, the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety, the Ministry of Health and Welfare and other relevant government agencies released the results of tests for harmful substances in 465 tobacco products distributed in South Korea, following deliberations by the Tobacco Harm Management Policy Committee. This is the first disclosure since the Tobacco Harm Management Act took effect in November 2025.


The products tested were from 20 manufacturers and importers: 256 cigarettes, 104 heated tobacco products and 105 liquid e-cigarettes. The tests covered 44 types of substances in cigarettes and heated tobacco products, respectively, and 20 types in liquid e-cigarettes, for a total of 46 different substances after duplicates were excluded.


The results confirmed the presence in all three types of tobacco products of formaldehyde, a Group 1 human carcinogen designated by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC). Various other carcinogenic substances, including benzene, 1,3-butadiene, cadmium and benzo[a]pyrene, were also detected in cigarettes. Formaldehyde, the tobacco-specific nitrosamines NNN and NNK, and benzo[a]pyrene were found in heated tobacco products. Formaldehyde was detected in 99 of the 105 liquid e-cigarette products, and NNN, NNK and arsenic were found in some products.


First-Ever Harmful-Substance Test of 465 Tobacco Products: Carcinogens Found in 99 of 105 "E-Cigarettes" View original image

Nicotine and tar were detected in all cigarette and heated tobacco products. Cigarettes contained 0.8 to 2.6 mg of nicotine and 11.7 to 40.4 mg of tar per stick. Heated tobacco products contained 0.1 to 1.2 mg of nicotine and 10.3 to 32.0 mg of tar. Liquid e-cigarettes contained 5.7 to 20.0 mg of nicotine per gram of liquid.


The government said it would be inappropriate to directly compare test results across tobacco types to determine which products are less harmful. For cigarettes and heated tobacco products, emissions produced during use were collected and their content measured per stick. In contrast, this test analyzed the content of substances in the liquid itself for liquid e-cigarettes. This means the results do not compare emissions produced during actual use under identical conditions.


Finding lower levels of harmful substances, or levels below the analytical equipment's quantification limit, does not necessarily mean that a product poses a lower health risk. The health risks of tobacco can vary depending not only on combined exposure to multiple harmful substances, but also on the amount and duration of use and inhalation habits. Interactions among individual substances may also increase the risks.


First-Ever Harmful-Substance Test of 465 Tobacco Products: Carcinogens Found in 99 of 105 "E-Cigarettes" View original image
First-Ever Harmful-Substance Test of 465 Tobacco Products: Carcinogens Found in 99 of 105 "E-Cigarettes" View original image

The test used the intense smoking regime recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO) and included in the standards of the International Organization for Standardization (ISO). As a result, the test results may differ from the nicotine and tar figures shown on existing cigarette packs. The government plans to improve the system to ensure consistency between information disclosed in the future and existing product labeling.


The government plans to expand the range of products tested for harmful substances and advance its analytical technologies. Tobacco products containing synthetic nicotine, newly included in the definition of tobacco under an amendment to the Tobacco Business Act, will be tested for harmful substances and the results disclosed starting next year, in 2027. The government will also investigate harmful substances produced only by heated tobacco products and develop standard devices and testing methods to assess emissions from liquid e-cigarettes during actual use, in addition to analyzing the liquid itself.


The government also plans to review the properties and mechanisms of action of menthol, which was identified as a major ingredient in the additive lists submitted by the tobacco industry, and use the findings to develop management measures. The WHO has reported that menthol may enhance nicotine's effects when inhaled together with nicotine.


The Tobacco Harm Management Policy Committee urged people to quit smoking, saying that a tobacco product should not be considered less harmful simply because it contains lower levels of certain harmful substances. It also emphasized that information on harmful substances in tobacco should not be used to choose a particular product, but to understand the risks of all tobacco products and support efforts to quit smoking.


“This disclosure is a first step toward transparently informing the public about harmful substances in tobacco products, based on scientific test results,” said Oh Yukyung, head of the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety. “We will continue to pursue policies to manage harmful substances in tobacco based on scientific evidence.”


Detailed information on harmful substances by tobacco product and the effects of each substance on human health is available on the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety's website.



First-Ever Harmful-Substance Test of 465 Tobacco Products: Carcinogens Found in 99 of 105 "E-Cigarettes" View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing