Supreme Court Upholds Lower Court's Finding of "Mutual Attack"

The Supreme Court has ruled that even if a man killed his son after a physical altercation following the son's assault and threats, the act cannot be considered non-punishable excessive self-defense under the Criminal Act if the two were attacking each other at the time of the crime.

The Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

The Supreme Court in Seocho-gu, Seoul. Yonhap News Agency

View original image

According to legal circles on October 29, the Supreme Court's Third Division, with Justice Eom Sangpil presiding, recently upheld an appellate court ruling sentencing A, a medical school professor indicted on charges including murder, to four years in prison. It also upheld the lower court's decision to reject a request for a probation order.


A was indicted and detained on charges of stabbing his son, B, in the neck with a weapon and killing him at his home in Ilsandong-gu, Goyang, Gyeonggi Province, at around 12:05 a.m. on September 23, 2025.


A and B were reportedly estranged for a long time. After B's mother died in March 2025, B expressed anger toward A over inheritance issues, claiming, among other things, that his mother had died because of A. At around 10:22 p.m. the day before the incident, B went to A's home and punched him several times, demanding to know why A had not replied to his KakaoTalk messages. B then picked up a weapon from the kitchen and threatened to "kill him," assaulting and threatening A for about an hour.


After B briefly calmed down and then tried to assault A again, A knocked him down and climbed on top of him, and the two struggled. During the altercation, A struck B on the head twice with a blunt object and pressed hard on his neck, fracturing his thyroid cartilage and other bones. A then stabbed B in the left side of the neck with a weapon, killing him.


The central issue was whether A's actions constituted non-punishable excessive self-defense under Article 21, Paragraph 3 of the Criminal Act. Paragraph 2 of Article 21 allows a sentence to be reduced or waived, depending on the circumstances, when an act of self-defense exceeds what is necessary. Paragraph 3 provides that a person shall not be punished if, while acting at night or under other unsettling circumstances, the person acted out of fear, shock, excitement or confusion. However, court precedents hold that neither legitimate self-defense nor excessive self-defense applies when an act of harm is both defensive and aggressive in nature, as in a fight in which both parties intend to attack each other.


On February 6 this year, the first-trial court sentenced A to four years in prison and rejected the request for a probation order. It found that A had intended to kill B, citing the fact that he stabbed B in the neck, a vital area, and pushed the weapon in to a depth of 5 to 6 centimeters, as well as the fact that A was on top of B for most of the altercation. The court found there was insufficient evidence to establish a substantial likelihood that A would commit another murder in the future, and therefore rejected the request for a probation order.


On July 24, the appellate court also dismissed appeals by both sides. At the appeal trial, A acknowledged that he had intended to kill B but argued that his actions constituted non-punishable excessive self-defense. The appellate court, however, cited the fact that B's one-sided assault had subsided and was no longer ongoing at the time of the crime, as well as the fact that A actively attacked B from a generally dominant position during the altercation, striking him on the head with a blunt object and pressing on his neck hard enough to fracture his thyroid cartilage. It concluded that A's actions were acts of harm that were both defensive and aggressive in nature and therefore did not constitute excessive self-defense.



The Supreme Court also found no error in the lower court's ruling. The panel said, "There was no error in the lower court's ruling that violated the rules of logic and experience and exceeded the limits of the principle of free evaluation of evidence, or that misinterpreted the legal principles concerning non-punishable excessive self-defense and thereby affected the judgment."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing