Public service announcement by an Irish rape crisis center

Urges people to ask for "consent" before hugging their grandchildren

Removed after minister's intervention... dispute over "dangerous precedent"

An Irish public service announcement urging people to ask for consent before hugging their grandchildren was taken down after a backlash accusing it of belittling grandparents.


Granddaughter's uncomfortable expression featured in ad... "Are grandparents a cause for concern?"


An Irish public service announcement urging people to ask for consent before hugging their grandchildren. It was removed after sparking controversy. Dublin Rape Crisis Centre, Ireland.

An Irish public service announcement urging people to ask for consent before hugging their grandchildren. It was removed after sparking controversy. Dublin Rape Crisis Centre, Ireland.

View original image

According to Irish media outlets including The Journal on October 28 (local time), the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre (DRCC) removed a video ad about grandparents hugging their grandchildren from social media on October 22. The video was part of "We-Consent," a consent education campaign launched by DRCC in 2023 and funded by Ireland's Department of Justice. Three other videos from the same campaign were also reportedly removed.


First posted on social media in mid-September, the ad begins with grandparents visiting their grandchildren at home. A grandson runs to the entrance and hugs them, while his granddaughter, standing behind him, looks uncomfortable as they approach. The screen displays the message: "Not everyone wants to be hugged. Even if it's a hug from someone who loves them. Is it awkward? Maybe. Does it matter? Absolutely." A website with information about consent is then shown.


After the video recently spread online, it drew widespread criticism for portraying expressions of affection between family members as problematic behavior. Critics also said it depicted grandparents' hugs as something to be wary of, while others argued that supporting such a campaign with government funds was wasteful.


Justice Minister James O'Callaghan distanced himself from the ad, saying, "The video does not represent the government's views." He criticized it, saying, "The video is inappropriate and demeans grandparents. It is very important to understand the concept of consent in sexual relationships, but this video does not serve that purpose." O'Callaghan said the video was removed after Department of Justice officials contacted DRCC. An opposition lawmaker said, "A video funded with public money was made based on a very ill-considered idea," adding, "It is deeply regrettable that public money was spent on an ad that could insult and hurt older people."


The center explained that the video depicted various situations based on workshop participants' experiences. DRCC said, "The video was made to encourage respect for other people's boundaries from a very young age." It added, "We will review whether the ad can achieve the impact we intended and, until then, take it down from our social media channels."


Civic group warns of "self-censorship after intervention" as minister welcomes removal


After the video was taken down, a fresh debate broke out over whether the minister's intervention was appropriate. The Irish Council for Civil Liberties (ICCL) said the removal of the video just five weeks after it was posted could lead to "self-censorship and a chilling effect among civil society organizations if ministers intervene in the work of government-funded nonprofits." Gary Gannon, justice spokesperson for the opposition Social Democrats, also criticized the move, saying, "It sets a dangerous precedent for the minister and the Department of Justice to direct the removal of content they disapprove of."



Irish Taoiseach Micheál Martin, however, defended the minister. Martin said, "Criticism had been pouring in long before the minister spoke," adding, "It was within Minister O'Callaghan's legitimate authority to make clear that the government had not approved it." He added that "the ad was inappropriate," but said, "I don't think that was intentional."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing