"I knew this would happen." A tax law expert I met recently sighed before saying anything else. This came just after news broke that the ruling party and the government had discussed postponing the taxation of crypto assets scheduled for next year. Given the inadequate tax infrastructure and lack of detailed rules, another postponement appears increasingly likely: forcing implementation without them would inevitably cause confusion. If that happens, it will be the fourth postponement.


That would be an unprecedented number of postponements among countries in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). This is why tax law experts are concerned. The expert I spoke with has argued for several years that there should not be a fourth postponement and that discussions on crypto asset taxation should become more concrete. "I expected this talk of another postponement a long time ago," the expert said with a wry smile. "Will taxation really be implemented properly after four postponements?"


The rationale for postponing the tax remains the same: the tax system is not ready. There are limits to obtaining information on overseas transactions, and a domestic taxation framework has not been established. With even the detailed rules still undecided, there is no way the industry can begin developing systems. Crypto asset taxation, originally scheduled to take effect in 2022, was successively postponed to 2023, 2025 and 2027. If the same problems have persisted for years, the question should not be whether more time is needed, but what has been done in the meantime.


Of course, the government should not make implementing taxation an end in itself and pass confusion and burdens on to taxpayers when preparations are incomplete. Unclear tax rules for different types of transactions and difficulties for taxpayers in accurately calculating their income could fuel confusion and distrust. But repeatedly postponing taxation on the grounds of inadequate preparation is a separate issue. The government should explain specifically what progress has been made during the postponement period, what remains lacking at this point and by when those gaps can be addressed.


Concerns about tax fairness between users of overseas exchanges and domestic users cannot justify indefinitely delaying domestic taxation, either. If there are limits to obtaining information, systems for exchanging information should be expanded and means of verifying transactions should be developed in stages. The debate over tax fairness between stocks and crypto assets following the abolition of the financial investment income tax is also significant. However, that is a question of how to design the tax burden and tax system for each type of asset. It should not be addressed by continually postponing the principle of taxation itself.


If the precedent of delaying implementation whenever opposition to taxation arises becomes entrenched, policy predictability will decline and fairness toward taxpayers who pay their taxes diligently will also be undermined. We should also be wary of the perception taking hold that policy is being swayed by opposition from a particular group of investors. In this regard, it is deeply concerning that deteriorating public sentiment among people in their 20s and 30s, who have a high proportion of their investments in crypto assets, is being cited as a factor behind the latest postponement.



If another postponement is unavoidable, this time must be different. The government should set specific tasks, disclose deadlines for completing them and identify who is responsible. Mechanisms are also needed to monitor progress and hold those responsible accountable for the results. The first question the government and the National Assembly must answer is how to complete the system. Responsibility must not be postponed every time taxation is delayed.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing