The Irreplicable Value of Time and Trust... The Return of Analog in the Digital Age
Nostalgia Grows as Faith in the Future Wavers... The Anxieties of an Era Behind the Retro Craze

[Jang Eun-su's World Through Books] Why Neighborhood Restaurants Are Thriving in the Age of AI View original image

A few days ago, I visited the neighborhood where I grew up with some old acquaintances for the first time in a while, and was astonished. It is part of Seoul's old downtown, dotted with restaurants that have been doing business in the same spots for decades. These are long-established eateries that make ordinary food delicious with the skill honed over years. Their interiors are plain, their walls covered in graffiti, and few have parking spaces beyond tightly packed seating areas. They were no longer quiet places known only to those in the know. The jjimdak restaurant I used to visit holding my late father's hand, the sundae-guk restaurant where I stayed up all night with friends, and the hangover soup restaurant where a few 1,000-won bills could buy a hearty meal were all bustling with people of every age and gender.


Old shops are gaining popularity, discontinued products are being re-released, and disbanded idol groups are getting back together with increasing frequency. More people are buying turntables to enjoy the vinyl records (LPs) they left forgotten at home, and scouring flea markets for albums from long ago. While the online world is busy chasing accelerated innovation, people in the offline world are taking their time to revisit memories. Ironically, analog is thriving in the age of artificial intelligence (AI).


In a way, this is only natural. Digital leaves no memories behind. It grabs our attention with momentary stimulation, then quickly scatters and disappears. While AI remembers everything in the world, the inner lives of people cheering innovation grow ever emptier. In The Crisis of Narration, Byung-Chul Han warns: "Information allows no lingering. (...) A snapshot disappears after a brief moment. Reality is fragmented into snapshots. As a result, we are cut off from places where we can securely anchor ourselves in time. (...) Nothing remains."


Knowledge is generated through the inner capacity to connect information with life, while narratives arise from the imagination that links the past and the future. The digital world, where only momentary stimulation exists, can create neither knowledge nor narratives. There is no meaning or value there. The emptiness summoned by insubstantial stimulation swells and drives us until we are exhausted. No matter how diligently we scroll through short-form videos, the only thing we are left with is the feeling that time has "vanished in an instant"; nothing remains in our actual lives.


In this kind of world, the rules of value change. Things that are easily created, quickly shared, and gone in an instant gradually lose their worth as objects of attention. We half-watch, casually swipe past, and let them drift by in a daze. Conversely, the value of things built up over time continues to rise. In The Inevitable, Kevin Kelly writes: "Trust cannot be mass-produced. Trust cannot be bought wholesale. Trust cannot be downloaded and stored in a database. Someone's trust must be earned over time. (...) Trust is an intangible thing that gains value in a world saturated with copies."


The more attention digital innovation attracts, the more value the analog world's enduring present acquires. Classical literature tops bestseller lists, and book fairs are packed with visitors. In a world where people can listen to music for free anytime and access knowledge at no cost, they flock to concert halls and lecture venues. That is likely why neighborhood institutions and long-established brands are coming back to life. The many strengths they have accumulated while enduring the test of time radiate an aura of authenticity.


Customers browse dishes at a shop in Seoul Folk Flea Market in Dongdaemun-gu, Seoul. As vintage items and analog-inspired aesthetics gain renewed attention on social media, more young people are visiting the market.

Customers browse dishes at a shop in Seoul Folk Flea Market in Dongdaemun-gu, Seoul. As vintage items and analog-inspired aesthetics gain renewed attention on social media, more young people are visiting the market.

View original image

According to Svetlana Boym, however, this cultural phenomenon commonly called "retro" may not simply be nostalgia for the past. In The Culture of Nostalgia, she delves deeply into the historical and social dimensions of the paradoxical cultural phenomenon in which people feel "a deep longing for connection with the past even as technological development accelerates." Boym writes that "the twentieth century began with utopia and ended with nostalgia." In other words, retro was bound to emerge from the failure of twentieth-century civilization.


The fundamental sensibility of modernity is a passion for progress and development: an enthusiasm and obsession with the new. History moves forward, and society improves day by day. People in the traditional world regarded learning something new by studying the old (温故知新) as the highest ideal. A good life meant bringing the past back to life in the present. Modernity rejects the past and embraces the future. The new replaces the old, and today's events push yesterday's into the background. We see the past as a place cut off from the present, where things that have disappeared lie in repose.


Having abandoned the past, modern people are like uprooted grass blown by the wind, and are therefore always gripped by a sense of having lost their home. The more prosperous society becomes, the poorer the heart grows; the faster we race toward the future, the stronger our nostalgia for the past becomes. Nostalgia culture is therefore an unmistakably modern phenomenon.


Longing for the past and enthusiasm for tradition grow especially strong when expectations for the future collapse. When the future is uncertain, the present unsatisfying, and the promise of progress unconvincing, the past takes on an innovative meaning. We come to believe that the abandoned past preserves intact desirable values that are absent from the present and difficult to expect from the future, and begin to remake the present with those values as our foundation. In short, retro nostalgia is a psychological symptom revealing the collapse of optimistic faith in the future, and a social moment in which the longing that "we can no longer live like this" erupts.


Boym defines nostalgia as "a longing for a home that no longer exists or has never existed." This reveals two characteristics of nostalgia culture. Nostalgia is fundamentally an attachment to a vanished past, rooted in "feelings of loss and separation." Restorative nostalgia regards the past as a desirable truth, a tradition to be protected, and a legitimate history, and seeks to return the present to that past. Longing for the era of military dictatorship or chanting slogans such as "Make America Great Again" (MAGA) are typical examples. This is reactionary.


At the same time, nostalgia is also "a romance with one's own fantasy." When we yearn for the past, we secretly invent it, filling it with our present anxieties and hopes for the future. Such a past may never have actually existed, but it is one that we feel must have existed. Nostalgia culture therefore contains the power to critically reflect on the present and look toward the future, while seeming to look back at the past. Boym calls this "reflective nostalgia." By imagining a counter-temporal utopia, it prompts the present to "explore side streets and back alleys in the shadows instead of the straight road of progress." It hinders the flow of time from racing toward the future and encourages us to look in entirely different directions.





Jang Eun-su, Publishing and Culture Critic


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing