"What's the point of packed airports if tourists spend just 60,000 won before leaving?"... The Dark Side of 'K-Travel' as Korea Nears 20 Million Tourists
[Korea Tours Sold at Bargain-Basement Prices] - ③ Spending Falls Even as Arrivals Double
20 Million Tourists in Sight, but Travel Agencies Face "Cutthroat Competition" as Tourism Boom Benefits Vary
17.11 Million Visitors to Korea and KRW
The era of 20 million foreign tourists is just around the corner. The number of visitors to Korea and tourism spending are rising steeply, but the outlook for the domestic tourism industry is not entirely bright. Travel agencies seeking to attract tourists are caught in cutthroat competition, while at some regional airports, the number of foreign arrivals has more than doubled even as per-capita spending in the surrounding region has fallen. This reveals a structural limitation: the increase in tourists is not translating into higher earnings for Korea’s tourism industry. Critics say it is time to look beyond how many tourists are being attracted and examine how much of their spending stays in domestic industries and local economies.
Taiwanese tourists who arrived via Cheongju International Airport leave the welcome event venue. In the first half of this year, the number of foreign arrivals at Cheongju Airport rose 109.1% from the same period last year, but per-capita credit card spending by foreign visitors in Chungcheongbuk-do fell 38.2%.
View original imageAccording to the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism and the Korea Tourism Organization, among other sources, 17.11 million foreign tourists visited Korea from January to September this year, up 21.5% from the same period a year earlier. That was also 32.3% more than in the same period of 2019, before the COVID-19 pandemic. Chinese tourists numbered 5.47 million, up 29.2%, accounting for 41% of the overall increase in visitors to Korea, or about 3.03 million.
Tourism spending also rose sharply. During the same period, foreign visitors’ credit card spending on tourism totaled KRW 15.9416 trillion, up 47.7% year over year—more than twice the growth rate in visitor numbers. Tourism revenue last year also increased 14.4% year over year to $21.89 billion.
Spending per visitor is also trending upward. An analysis by Yanolja Research of Bank of Korea and Korea Tourism Organization data found that tourism revenue in the first half of this year reached $13.61 billion, up 36.4% from the same period a year earlier. Tourism revenue per visitor rose 12.4% to $1,270.4, exceeding the first-half 2019 level by 3.7%.
Although the tourism market has grown in scale, the benefits of that growth vary across industries and regions.
The number of visitors entering through Cheongju Airport rose sharply, but foreign visitors spent just 60,238 won per person in the Chungbuk region. This illustrates how an increase in arrivals does not necessarily translate into greater local spending, highlighting the downside of "bargain-basement tourism."
View original imageMedical Tourism Grows 6.6-Fold as Duty-Free Sales Plunge 60%... Tourism Boom Has Uneven Impact
Foreign visitors’ spending on medical services reached KRW 1.1931 trillion in the first half of this year, up 59.1% from the same period a year earlier. That was 6.6 times the first-half 2019 figure. With more foreign visitors seeking services at dermatology and plastic surgery clinics, medical tourism is emerging as a new growth engine.
Duty-free shops, by contrast, are not benefiting from the increase in tourists. In the first half, 6.644 million foreign visitors used duty-free shops, down 30.9% from 9.618 million in the same period of 2019. Sales also plunged 59.8%, from $8.37 billion to $3.37 billion. This is believed to reflect a shift in a business model that had relied heavily on sales to Chinese group-buying agents.
The traditional travel industry also remains sluggish. According to the Korea Culture and Tourism Institute, the production index for the tourism and travel services industry fell 8.8% in May from a year earlier. In the same month, credit card spending on tourism accommodation rose 17.5%, while spending at travel agencies fell 4.2% and spending on airlines declined 24.6%. The figures combine spending by Korean and foreign visitors, so they cannot be directly compared with the performance of travel agencies handling Chinese tour groups. Even so, the differences between sectors are clear.
A similar mismatch between rising visitor numbers and increased spending can be seen in regional areas. From January to September this year, foreign arrivals through airports outside the Seoul metropolitan area reached 3.24 million, up 37.4% from the same period a year earlier. Arrivals through regional ports also rose 14.5% to 1.58 million.
However, the increase in arrivals did not directly translate into greater spending in those regions. According to the second issue of “Korea Tourism Today,” published by the Korea Tourism Organization, foreign arrivals at Cheongju Airport surged 109.1% in the first half of this year, but their per-capita credit card spending in the Chungbuk region fell 38.2% to 60,238 won.
By contrast, per-capita credit card spending in Daegu by visitors arriving at Daegu Airport rose 9.9% to 255,355 won. That was 4.2 times the amount spent in Chungbuk by visitors arriving at Cheongju Airport.
Differences in length of stay, purpose of visit, and travel routes among passengers arriving at different airports are believed to have contributed to regional differences in spending. Even if tourists arrive through a regional airport, the economic benefits for that area are bound to be limited if they travel elsewhere right away.
Shim Chang-seop, a professor in the Department of Tourism Management at Gachon University, explained, “An increase in arrivals at regional airports does not necessarily mean that the local tourism economy is growing. The airport where visitors arrive may differ from the places where they actually stay and spend, and even spending that takes place locally may flow to outside businesses.” He added, “We need to create links that encourage tourists to stay in the region, experience its distinctive way of life and culture, and ensure that their spending supports the income and jobs of local businesses.”
Spending by foreign tourists varied sharply by sector. Medical tourism and lodging increased, while duty-free shops and travel agencies struggled, showing that the rise in tourist numbers did not translate into improved profitability across the industry.
View original imageTourism Revenue Rises, but Travel Agencies Face Cutthroat Competition... Referral Fees and Commissions Shrink Their Share
How much of the money spent by foreign tourists goes back to domestic travel agencies is also an issue worth examining. Tourism revenue and credit card spending indicate the size of the tourism market, but they do not reflect the actual earnings of individual businesses.
The Bank of Korea’s tourism revenue figure is based on international balance-of-payments data for travel credits, while the Korea Tourism Organization’s tourism spending figure is compiled from credit card transaction data. Because the two are calculated differently, and because neither accounts for travel agencies’ net earnings after accommodation, vehicle, and guide costs, overseas referral fees, and various commissions, those net earnings are difficult to determine from either set of statistics.
Kang Ji-su, a research fellow at the Korea Culture and Tourism Institute, said, “It is difficult to interpret an increase in tourism revenue as an immediate increase in the profits of individual tourism businesses.” Tourism revenue includes a wide range of spending, not only at travel agencies and accommodation providers but also at retail stores, restaurants, and medical and beauty service businesses.
The “negative tour fee” model in China’s ultra-low-cost group tour market is a typical example of how attracting tourists does not necessarily translate into profit. In this arrangement, a local Korean inbound travel agency pays a Chinese outbound tour operator to receive tourists, then recoups the cost through commissions from shopping centers in Korea. Even if an agency attracts many tourists, it can still incur losses depending on their shopping activity and the terms for sharing commissions.
The problem is that even the scale of these transactions and how the profits are distributed are difficult to establish from official statistics. Kang said of commission transactions between Chinese outbound tour operators and local Korean inbound travel agencies, “As far as I know, they are not currently being captured in official statistics.”
The power imbalance in negotiations between Chinese outbound tour operators and local Korean inbound travel agencies is also a factor behind the cutthroat competition.
Choi Kyung-eun, a senior research fellow at the Korea Culture and Tourism Institute, said, “The difference in bargaining power between Chinese outbound tour operators and local Korean inbound travel agencies, along with the lack of differentiation among tourism products, is a major reason low-price competition persists.”
The analysis is that as packages featuring similar destinations and itineraries flood the market, price—not the quality of the travel experience—is determining competition. This is also why Chinese companies that lead efforts to recruit tourists hold the upper hand in setting transaction terms.
The spread of independent travel and the growing influence of online travel agencies (OTAs) are also cited as factors weakening the existing revenue base of travel agencies.
Professor Shim noted, “The core issue is that even when tourist numbers and spending rise, domestic travel businesses find it difficult to capture the added value. The growing intermediary power of OTAs and the spread of independent travel have weakened the revenue base of traditional travel agencies, while specialized services such as itinerary planning and interpretation are not being adequately compensated.”
There are calls to change the criteria used to evaluate the performance of tourism policy. In addition to visitor numbers and total spending, evaluations should consider regional stays and spending, the profitability of domestic tourism businesses, and how revenue is shared with overseas operators.
Professor Shim stressed, “Tourism policy should examine not only the scale of visitor attraction but also how revenue is distributed to the people who plan tourism and provide services.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The government, too, has acknowledged the need to distinguish an increase in tourist numbers from genuine growth in the tourism industry. At a tourism press briefing on October 28, Minister of Culture, Sports and Tourism Choi Hwi-young said, “The number of people traveling is growing, but there are many issues to consider from another perspective when asking whether the tourism industry itself is continuing to grow.”
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.