Federation: "Threat to the Survival of Small and Midsize Operators"
FSC Promises to Provide Impact Analysis Report

The Korea Rental Car Business Association Federation said on the 28th that it had urged the Financial Services Commission (FSC), during a meeting, to withdraw its proposed revision to expand the cap on rental business handled by capital companies. The FSC apologized for insufficient prior consultation with the industry during the drafting process but maintained its plan to proceed with the revision.


According to the federation, the FSC projected that, if the revision takes effect, the cap on rental business handled by capital companies could increase by up to twofold, depending on each company's asset composition, with the industry average rising by about 50%. The FSC cited increased market competition and greater consumer benefits as the aims of the revision, but said during the meeting that it would be difficult to quantify consumer benefits in advance.

The parking lot at Hyeopjae Beach in Jeju City is packed with rental cars. Yonhap News

The parking lot at Hyeopjae Beach in Jeju City is packed with rental cars. Yonhap News

View original image

The federation pointed out that, although consumer benefits had been presented as grounds for easing regulations, there was insufficient concrete analysis to support that claim. It said the residual value and risk level of existing rental assets, as well as the potential impact on the market, should be thoroughly assessed before significantly expanding the cap on rental business handled by capital companies.


Industry concerns over the expansion of capital companies' rental businesses are closely tied to asset quality. According to the federation, the number of rental cars registered by capital companies rose more than 20-fold in 15 years, from about 27,000 in 2010 to about 557,000 last year. An analysis of the 30 companies with the most registered rental cars as of the end of July this year found that capital companies held a 45.32% market share, exceeding the 43.08% held by large, dedicated rental car companies. The remaining approximately 11% was held by around 1,000 small and midsize rental car companies.


The federation has argued that if expanding the cap on rental business spurs price competition, the risk of losses resulting from falling used-car prices could also grow. Long-term rental fees are affected by the residual value, or the estimated price at which a vehicle can be sold at the end of a contract. Setting a high residual value can lower monthly rental fees, but if the actual sale price of a used car falls below the estimate, the operator could incur a loss equal to the difference. The federation is therefore calling for an examination of changes in residual value ratios at each capital company, actual vehicle sale prices, and gains or losses on sales before regulations are eased.


The meeting also revealed differences over whether payment deferrals could be considered a mutually beneficial measure linked to regulatory easing. The federation said it had neither accepted payment deferrals, which the FSC had proposed as a mutually beneficial measure during the advance notice of the proposed rule change, as a concession in exchange for regulatory easing, nor agreed to them. Representatives of member companies who attended the meeting also said they had not been told, when applying for payment deferrals, that the measure was linked to regulatory easing.


The FSC, however, maintained that payment deferrals were a mutually beneficial measure linked to regulatory easing. It explained that financial support for small and midsize rental car companies and arrangements to connect them with replacement vehicles for accident-related cases were recommendations, not requirements subject to enforcement or supervision. The federation stressed that measures that cannot be enforced should not be used to justify regulatory amendments.


The federation also said that small and midsize rental car companies face a competitive disadvantage because they borrow funds at higher interest rates than capital companies. It warned that, since capital companies are a major source of financing for rental car businesses, expanding the cap on rental business could further increase the competitive burden on smaller operators. The FSC reportedly responded that it understood and sympathized with the difficult financing conditions small and midsize businesses face in terms of borrowing rates.


The FSC said it would ask the Korea Credit Finance Association to provide the federation with an impact analysis report it had prepared. It also said it would invite the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport to relevant meetings and that the FSC would attend the ministry's meetings whenever possible. The FSC is also considering commissioning an impartial study involving industry and consumer experts, funded by the national budget, and said it would share the findings. It further indicated that the advance notice period for the proposed rule change could be extended if more time were needed for the impact analysis.


The federation called for the proposed revision to be withdrawn, the grounds for expanding the cap and the results of the impact analysis to be made public, consultations with relevant ministries including the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, and a legal review. It plans to submit a separate formal opinion during the advance notice period and reiterate its call to withdraw the proposal.



"Small and midsize rental car companies are struggling to stay afloat by borrowing money at higher interest rates than capital companies," said federation president Choi Yooncheol. "If the cap on rental business handled by capital companies is increased by up to twofold without grounds or adequate consultation under these circumstances, smaller companies will lose their place in the market." He added, "The survival of small and midsize rental car companies is at stake, so this proposed revision must be withdrawn."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing