Nine associations nationwide face 1.1461 trillion won in levies

Home sale and actual transaction price indexes show a fourfold gap in growth rates

"Home sale price index fails to reflect actual home price increases"

Associat

The total reconstruction excess-profits recapture levies estimated by associations at nine reconstruction complexes nationwide have exceeded KRW 1 trillion. Each household will have to pay at least KRW 21 million and as much as KRW 400 million. The redevelopment industry says the standard should be changed because the home sale price index used to calculate the current levies does not adequately reflect market prices. There are concerns that, unless the system is improved, the supply of housing through redevelopment projects could be stalled, starting with Banpo Centerville Asterium in Seocho-gu (formerly Banpo Hyundai).


According to the National Reconstruction and Redevelopment Union Coalition (Jeonjaeyeon) on October 28, 10 of the 82 member associations nationwide are subject to the reconstruction excess-profits recapture levy. Excluding Busan's Daeyeon District 4, where the levy has not yet been estimated, the projected total levy payable by 7,332 members of the other nine complexes is estimated at KRW 1.1461 trillion.

Nine Associations Nationwide Face 1.1 Trillion Won in Reconstruction Excess-Profit Levies Alone... Redevelopment Industry on Alert View original image

The reconstruction excess-profits recapture system collects a set proportion of gains exceeding a certain threshold when the average profit earned by association members through reconstruction exceeds KRW 80 million. It applies to reconstruction associations and other entities that applied for approval of a management and disposal plan after the system was reinstated in 2018.


By association, the estimated levy per member was highest at KRW 402 million for Banpo District 3 (Raemian Trinione) in Seocho-gu. The estimates were KRW 284.89 million for Sinbanpo 21st (Otier Banpo) and KRW 100 million for Banpo Hyundai. Outside the Seoul metropolitan area, the levy is expected to reach as much as KRW 276 million at Dunsan The Sharp Elif (Yongmun-dong Zones 1, 2 and 3) in Daejeon, and KRW 49.14 million at Beomeo I-Park (Beomeo Woobang 1st) in Daegu.


The main point of contention is whether market prices are properly reflected in the levy calculations. The redevelopment industry and Jeonjaeyeon argue that the current calculation method does not adequately reflect market prices, resulting in excessive levies. The levy is calculated based on the excess profit, determined by subtracting the home value at the time the association was established, the increase in normal housing prices and development costs from the home value on the date of approval for completion of the project. The increase in normal housing prices refers to the amount that home prices are deemed to have risen in line with market trends even if reconstruction had not taken place. The more this increase is recognized, the lower the levy association members must pay; it is calculated using the Korea Real Estate Board's home sale price index.


Associations argue that because the home sale price index is a statistical estimate of average home prices by city, county or district, it reflects only about 30% of actual market prices. Since the sample may include homes that do not sell regularly, the gap between the index and the actual transaction price index—which is calculated based only on sale prices from complexes with at least two transactions—widens considerably during periods of rising and falling home prices.

Nine Associations Nationwide Face 1.1 Trillion Won in Reconstruction Excess-Profit Levies Alone... Redevelopment Industry on Alert View original image

A comparison of the increase in Seoul's home sale price index with its actual transaction price index from January 2017 to December 2021, when home prices surged, shows a difference of nearly fourfold. Over the same period, the home sale price index rose 27.2%, while the actual transaction price index for apartment buildings increased 100.9%. Looking at individual complexes, the home sale price index for Seocho-gu rose 22.45% from October 2016, when Banpo Hyundai received approval to establish its association, to July 2021, when it received approval for completion. However, the actual transaction price index for apartment buildings rose from 88.7 to 170.9 over the same period, an increase of 92.6% and 4.1 times the rate of the home sale price index.

Nine Associations Nationwide Face 1.1 Trillion Won in Reconstruction Excess-Profit Levies Alone... Redevelopment Industry on Alert View original image

The redevelopment industry is calling for the system to be revised so that the actual transaction price index is used to calculate increases in normal housing prices, or so that actual transaction prices at five comparable nearby complexes are factored in. It has submitted proposals to the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport to improve the levy calculation method, in December and June of last year. Park Gyeongryong, head of the Bangbae Samik Apartment Association and secretary of Jeonjaeyeon, said, "For some complexes, applying the actual transaction price index produces a levy of around KRW 91 million per member, while applying the home sale price index raises it to KRW 340 million." He added, "Because the increase in home prices is calculated at less than actual market levels, the levy ends up being overstated."



The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, however, says it is difficult to apply the actual transaction price index under current law. The Act on the Reimbursement of Excess Profits from Reconstruction stipulates that the calculation of increases in normal housing prices must reflect the average home price increase rate by city, county or district. The ministry says the relevant statistics are not available for areas outside the Seoul metropolitan area. A ministry official said, "The actual transaction price index is compiled only at the provincial level in areas other than the Seoul metropolitan area and the five major metropolitan cities." The official added, "Since current law stipulates that the average home price increase rate by city, county or district must be applied, it would be difficult to use the actual transaction price index unless the National Assembly amends the law."

Nine Associations Nationwide Face 1.1 Trillion Won in Reconstruction Excess-Profit Levies Alone... Redevelopment Industry on Alert View original image


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing