[Reporter’s Notebook] Let's Turn the Financial Sandbox Back into a 'Fintech Lab' View original image

"Companies that have failed the review several times sometimes threaten to sue, claiming the review panel is ignoring them." "There are also many cases where competitors applying for similar services clash, and the losing side files a complaint asking, 'Why was the other company approved?'"


These are behind-the-scenes accounts of the Financial Services Commission's Innovation Financial Services program (regulatory sandbox), shared by fintech industry insiders I recently met. At first glance, threatening to sue over a rejection and criticizing the outcomes for competitors may seem excessive. But it is worth considering why they feel compelled to go this far. For fintech firms with limited capital, being rejected by the sandbox can be a matter of survival.


Fintech firms are reacting so sensitively because they have lost faith in the Innovation Financial Services program, which was created to give companies the opportunity to test new financial services. Over the past three years, fintech firms accounted for only around 10% of designations, while large financial institutions accounted for more than 80%. Large institutions even applied for relief from network-separation regulations, which could be eased simply by revising public notices or supervisory rules. Such applications accounted for more than half of all designations: 560 out of 1,112. The program, which should have served as a "laboratory" for fintech, has instead been flooded with requests from financial institutions.


The Financial Services Commission is aware of the problem and announced measures to address it in June. It said that network-separation exemptions would be handled through a different system and that it would assess fintech firms' growth potential even if their financial soundness was insufficient. But the industry says these measures alone are not enough.


Fintech firms stress that, given the structural limitations that put them at a disadvantage against established financial institutions in terms of capital, they should be reviewed on a separate track from "established financial institutions" and that a "conditional designation" system is needed. They are asking to be designated first, on the condition that they address any shortcomings afterward, even if they do not meet staffing or facility requirements, provided their innovation is outstanding. They also say that post-sandbox support measures should be designed to reflect the needs of fintech firms.



The results of the second-quarter selection were announced on October 21. Two of the four new designations went to existing credit card companies. Even after the measures were announced, it seems difficult to dispel fintech firms' distrust. Reviews of applicants for the third-quarter sandbox are now beginning. Better solutions that fintech firms can actually feel the impact of need to be considered.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing