[Anatomy of Supreme Court Renomination] ② Backroom Dealmaking Collapses... 'Battle over Precedent' Erupts with 22 Supreme Court Seats at Stake
1962 "Duty to Appoint" Removed in 1972... Backroom Negotiations Filled the Void
As Talks Break Down, Battle Over Precedent... Lee Expected to Appoint 22 Supreme Court Justices During His Term
Before officially nominating a candidate for Supreme Court justice, the president and the chief justice have engaged in “prior consultations” behind the scenes to align their preferences. This shadow practice is found nowhere in the Constitution or in law. The current Constitution grants the chief justice the authority to nominate and the president the authority to appoint, but leaves unresolved how to proceed when the two constitutional bodies disagree. For decades, informal backroom negotiations filled this gray area. But now that this tacit compromise has broken down, the president and the head of the judiciary are openly clashing over appointments in an unprecedented situation. Constitutional scholars are sharply divided over whether prior consultations represent “mutual respect in accordance with the spirit of the Constitution” or “an authoritarian relic that must be swept away.”
◆A constitutional convention or a bad practice to be swept away?= The legal community is focused on whether prior consultations, which have operated as an unwritten rule, can be recognized as normatively binding. Han Sanghee, an emeritus professor at Konkuk University Law School, said that while precedents of consultations between past chief justices and presidents had acquired the character of a “constitutional convention,” they were not legally binding. In other words, bypassing the convention would not make a party liable to legal sanctions such as a finding of unconstitutionality or impeachment. “Because these consultations took place behind closed doors and lacked democratic legitimacy, they cannot be considered customary constitutional law with constitutional effect,” Han said, criticizing them as “a mechanism for sharing power among themselves.”
Some also argue that prior consultations were never backed by the legal conviction and social acceptance needed for a particular practice to acquire normative force. “Prior consultations are nothing but a bad practice with no value worth preserving and should be abolished immediately,” said Cha Jina, a professor at Korea University Law School. “It is difficult to view a president’s request for a new nomination on the grounds that the consultations were not followed as a legitimate exercise of authority.”
Constitutional scholars who describe prior consultations as a “bad practice” trace their origins to the 1972 Yushin Constitution. The 1972 Yushin Constitution dismantled a safeguard for judicial independence by abolishing both the Judicial Nomination Council and the president’s obligation to appoint. “Prior consultations were a tool for filling the Supreme Court with the chief justice and all the justices the president favored through politically aligned appointments,” Cha said. “As a result, they became a channel through which the chief justice could anticipate the president’s preferences and select candidates unlikely to be rejected.”
There is also a diametrically opposite interpretation. Some argue that the real toxic provision left by the Yushin regime was not prior consultations, but the “exclusive nomination authority” concentrated in the hands of the chief justice. The 1987 constitutional amendment added a requirement for National Assembly consent to appointments, but left intact a system in which a single chief justice selects fellow justices. “A de facto hierarchy between the chief justice and other Supreme Court justices is inevitable,” said Jung Taeho, an emeritus professor at Kyung Hee University Law School. “By way of analogy, it is like allowing only people approved by the speaker of the National Assembly to run for a seat in the assembly.”
With no mechanism under the Constitution to resolve conflicts between the authority to nominate and the authority to appoint, prior consultations have served as an informal compromise between the two branches of power. “After democratization, the so-called ‘alternating concessions’ took place: if the chief justice nominated someone the Blue House wanted one time, the next time the president would respect the chief justice’s choice,” said a lawyer who formerly served as a judicial research officer at the Supreme Court. “When the two sides were deadlocked, an unwritten formula operated behind the scenes: instead of either side’s preferred candidate, A or B, they would compromise on a third candidate, C.”
◆A power struggle ahead of appointments of 22 Supreme Court justices= The problem is that this situation could set a precedent. “Now that the conflict is out in the open, the chief justice has few options other than to insist on legal principles,” said a lawyer who formerly served as a judicial research officer. A senior judge at a district court in Seoul also said, “The moment the chief justice accepts this request for a new nomination, the chief justice’s nomination authority will be hollowed out in every future appointment of Supreme Court justices.”
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The large-scale turnover of Supreme Court justices scheduled for the coming years is the flashpoint. Under the law increasing the number of Supreme Court justices, which passed the National Assembly in February, the number of justices will rise by four each year starting in 2028, reaching 26 in 2030. Add the 12 new positions to the successor to Chief Justice Cho Heedae, who reaches the retirement age next year, and the successors to nine justices whose terms expire by March 2030, and President Lee Jaemyung will appoint as many as 22 of the 26 justices during his term. Moreover, the successor to Chief Justice Cho will exercise the nomination authority for all 12 newly added positions. This is why the current power struggle is being called a “battle over precedent” that will determine the course of more than 20 future Supreme Court appointments.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.