"Personnel and administrative powers, and presiding over the en banc panel"
Criticism that reform measures have been rolled back since the judicial scandal
Noh Gyeongpil: "The system does not allow unilateral appointments"

When Democratic Party of Korea lawmaker Kim Yongmin pointed out on the 26th that excessive personnel, administrative and judicial powers are concentrated in a single Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Chief of the National Court Administration Noh Gyeongpil countered, "It is an excessive disparagement of the judiciary to think that the substance of court rulings changes depending on who the Chief Justice is."

Noh Kyungpil, head of the National Court Administration, and Kim Hocheol, chairman of the Board of Audit and Inspection, talk during a comprehensive audit of the Ministry of Justice and other agencies at the National Assembly on Oct. 26, 2026. Photo by Yun Dongju

Noh Kyungpil, head of the National Court Administration, and Kim Hocheol, chairman of the Board of Audit and Inspection, talk during a comprehensive audit of the Ministry of Justice and other agencies at the National Assembly on Oct. 26, 2026. Photo by Yun Dongju

View original image

At a comprehensive parliamentary audit of the National Assembly's Legislation and Judiciary Committee that day, Kim said, "Judicial power is subject to popular sovereignty," and pointed out that the Chief Justice has the authority to appoint judges and assign court presidents, exercises judicial administrative authority through the National Court Administration, and also presides over the Supreme Court en banc.


"All power in the judiciary is concentrated in one person, the Chief Justice," he said. "The Chief Justice holds both personnel and administrative powers and also participates in judicial decision-making, but there are insufficient checks and balances." He also noted that Supreme Court cases are, in principle, heard by the en banc panel, which the Chief Justice presides over.


Kim also again raised the fact that Noh had previously called Supreme Court justice candidates directly. Referring to rulings by the panel on which Yoon Seongsik, then a presiding judge at the Seoul High Court and one of the candidates at the time, served, Kim said, "After the calls, the appeal in the Han Duck-soo case was dismissed, and former minister Park Seong-jae's sentence was significantly reduced. Would the public understand this as not being interference in trials?" Noh had previously explained that he called the candidates to ask their opinions about restarting the candidate recommendation process, and that he did not urge them to withdraw.


In response, Noh countered, "Judicial appointments must go through the Judicial Personnel Committee, which is composed mostly of outside members, and are then finalized through a meeting of Supreme Court justices. The system does not allow the Chief Justice to make judicial appointments unilaterally."



He added, "More fundamentally, thinking that the substance of court rulings or judicial appointments changes depending on who the Chief Justice is may be an excessive disparagement of our judiciary, which has already reached a world-class level. I find that regrettable."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing