[Anatomy of Supreme Court Justice Renominations] ① Appointment Authority or Infringement of Recommendation Authority? Constitutional Scholars Also Sharply Divided
Only one line: "appointed upon the recommendation"... no scope for rejection specified
Consensus on the power to reject... interpretations differ over reasons, countersignatures, and candidate selection
"Supreme Court justices are appointed by the President with the consent of the National Assembly, upon the recommendation of the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court."
Article 104(2) of the Constitution sets out the procedure for appointing Supreme Court justices in a single line. It contains no explicit provision on whether the President may reject a recommendation by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, or how far the President may intervene if doing so. This is why the standoff over a renewed recommendation of a Supreme Court justice between the President and the Chief Justice has escalated into a high-level debate over constitutional interpretation. Constitutional scholars are sharply divided over whether the President has the authority to reject an appointment, as well as the procedural legitimacy and scope of its exercise.
In August, President Lee Jaemyung asked for a new recommendation after Chief Justice Cho Heedae recommended Son Bongki, a presiding judge at the Daegu District Court, as a candidate for a new Supreme Court justice. The President did not submit the appointment consent motion to the National Assembly. On September 22, Chief Justice Cho rejected the request, saying, "No specific reasons or constitutional grounds for requesting a new recommendation have been stated." An unprecedented standoff between constitutional institutions has continued since.
Clash Between a "Text-Centered" View and "Substantive Authority"
According to legal circles on October 28, constitutional scholars who emphasize a strict interpretation of the provision generally hold that "it is difficult to recognize powers not explicitly stated in the Constitution." At a parliamentary audit on October 6, Chief Justice Cho said, "Once the Chief Justice makes a recommendation under the Constitution, the process is over," adding, "Neither the National Assembly nor the President may intervene in the recommendation, which is the Chief Justice's inherent authority."
A presiding judge at a district court in the Seoul area agreed with this interpretation, saying, "The fundamental principle is that legal interpretation begins with a literal interpretation, which understands the wording of a provision exactly as written." In a 2009 ruling, the Supreme Court held that "if the language of a law sets out a concept in relatively clear terms, there is, in principle, no need to use other methods of interpretation, or their use is limited."
By contrast, constitutional scholars who recognize the President's authority to request a new recommendation argue that "even if it is not explicitly stated, the power to reject is implicit in the power of appointment." Jung Taeho, an emeritus professor at Kyung Hee University Law School, said, "The Constitution tends to set out only key matters in brief," adding, "The President's authority to request a new recommendation of a Supreme Court justice should also be understood as being implicitly included in the constitutional provision on the President's appointment power." Professor Jung cited the difference between the appointment structures for Supreme Court justices and Constitutional Court justices as the basis for his argument. The President's appointment of the three Constitutional Court justices elected by the National Assembly, out of a total of nine, is merely a formal procedure, whereas the President's appointment of Supreme Court justices is a substantive power, he explained. The argument is that interpreting the President as unable to reject a recommendation would effectively leave the Chief Justice and the National Assembly with exclusive control over the composition of the Supreme Court, contrary to the principle of separation of powers.
Han Sanghee, an emeritus professor at Konkuk University Law School and co-head of People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy, also said, "The Chief Justice's power to recommend amounts to nothing more than sharing part of the President's power to nominate candidates as part of the appointment process." He added, "If the President refuses to make an appointment, the Chief Justice has a constitutional duty to recommend another candidate."
However, constitutional scholars broadly agree that the President may exceptionally reject a recommendation if there is a valid reason, such as a clear disqualification of the candidate. Cha Jinah, a professor at Korea University Law School who is critical of the request for a new recommendation in this case, said, "The binding provision in the 1962 Constitution that 'the President shall appoint the nominee' was removed during the 1972 constitutional amendment process. By contrast, this leaves room for the President to refuse to appoint a recommended candidate."
Dispute Over "Stating Reasons for Rejection" and "Countersignatures by State Council Members"
The key flashpoint is the "procedural legitimacy" of exercising the power to reject. Constitutional scholars are also at odds over the "absence of specific reasons" and the "missing countersignatures by relevant State Council members" that Chief Justice Cho cited when dismissing the request for a new recommendation. Constitutional scholars who believe the reasons for rejection must be stated regard this as "a prerequisite for the practical process of making a new recommendation." Professor Cha said, "Wouldn't the Chief Justice need to know exactly what disqualifies the original candidate so that he can vet and recommend someone who will not present a similar problem next time?" Song Kichun, a professor at Jeonbuk National University Law School, also noted, "Just as it would be unconstitutional for the President not to appoint a Constitutional Court justice elected by the National Assembly without a valid reason, a request for a new recommendation of a Supreme Court justice without a legitimate reason is also highly likely to be unconstitutional."
There are counterarguments. Professor Jung asked, "Where in the Constitution does it say that the President must state the reasons when requesting a new recommendation?" He explained that if the Presidential Office were to disclose the reasons for rejection in an official document, it could seriously damage the candidate's reputation. He added that the President's position had been sufficiently conveyed to the Supreme Court during prior consultations.
The same applies to the procedural requirement of a "countersignature." Article 82 of the Constitution states, "Acts of the President under the law of the state shall be in writing, and such documents shall be countersigned by the Prime Minister and the relevant State Council members." Chief Justice Cho previously pointed out that the document requesting a new recommendation had only the Prime Minister's countersignature, while those of relevant State Council members, including the Minister of Justice, were missing, rendering the procedure flawed.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Professor Han countered, "A request for a new recommendation is not an 'act under the law of the state' that immediately changes legal relations, but rather a 'factual act' that conveys the President's wishes, so a formal countersignature is not required." He added that even if it were considered an act under the law of the state, convention has been for only the Prime Minister to countersign presidential acts concerning the composition of constitutional institutions.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.