Fewer Hearings, Longer Processing Times
Courts: "Due to Prioritizing Cases Involving Detained Defendants"

Mr. A, who was sentenced to prison in the first trial in June 2025, avoided being taken into custody in court but appealed, arguing that the sentence was too severe. He submitted a statement of grounds for appeal to the second-instance court in August that year, but the first hearing was not held until September 2026, a year later.


The circumstances of defendant B are similar. After receiving a first-instance sentence in November 2025, B appealed and submitted a statement of grounds for appeal the following month. However, the appeals court scheduled the first hearing for November 2026, a year later.


Cases appealed by prosecutors are no exception. Defendant C, who is on trial at a court outside the capital region, was sent to a second trial after the prosecutor appealed in February 2026. The first hearing, however, has been scheduled for December, 10 months later.


Among lawyers, the situation with appeals involving defendants who are not in custody has become so dire that they say, "There is no word from the appeals court." Unlike cases involving detained defendants, for which the detention period is capped at six months, there is no separate statutory deadline for handling cases involving defendants who are not in custody.


The Judicial Yearbook shows that criminal single-judge cases take more than three months longer to resolve on appeal than at the first-instance level. Over the past three years, the time from filing to sentencing in criminal single-judge cases involving defendants who were not in custody was about six months at the first-instance level, compared with about nine months on appeal.


The longer processing time is not because more hearings are being held. According to the Judicial Yearbook, first-instance trials in 2025 held an average of 2.57 hearings (3.29 for panel cases and 2.48 for single-judge cases), while appeals held an average of just 1.75 hearings (2.01 for panel cases and 1.70 for single-judge cases). In other words, fewer hearings are being held, yet cases are taking longer to resolve.


Yang Yunseop, president of the Korean Bar Association's Court-Appointed Lawyers Association, who passed the seventh bar examination, said, "In cases involving defendants who are not in custody, it is not uncommon for the first hearing on appeal to be scheduled late, regardless of whether the first-instance sentence was a fine, a suspended sentence, or imprisonment." He added, "Defendants have to spend more than a year in an anxious state, with their cases not yet finalized."


The courts say this happens because they prioritize cases involving detained defendants. An official from the National Court Administration said, "The appellate divisions of district courts, which handle single-judge appeals, have about five times as many cases as high courts, which handle panel cases.


"Cases involving defendants who are not in custody are pushed back because cases involving detained defendants are handled first." The National Court Administration added, "Cases involving detained defendants are actually resolved more quickly by district court appellate divisions (101.6 days) than by high courts (121.6 days."



Han Mina, Legal Times reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing