SJPOs Have Limited Investigative Experience and Face Challenges Building Expertise
"Guidance and Advice" Are Not Legally Binding... Confusion Expected
Measures Needed, Including Personnel Exchanges and Legal Support

[The Police File] SJPOs Without Prosecutorial Direction Need Support to Make the System Work View original image

Since the revised Criminal Procedure Act took effect on October 2, prosecutors have no longer had the authority to direct investigations by special judicial police officers (SJPOs). As a result, prosecutors and SJPOs have shifted to a relationship of mutual cooperation, with prosecutors now limited to providing guidance and advice to SJPOs. The change is intended to strengthen the separation of investigation and prosecution and expand the independence of SJPOs. However, it is also necessary to examine the confusion and adverse effects arising in the field as a result of the institutional change.


The greatest concern is the SJPOs' legal expertise and investigative capabilities. Of the approximately 20,000 SJPOs nationwide, 80% have less than three years of investigative experience. Frequent job rotations and the need to handle administrative work alongside investigations also limit their ability to build investigative expertise. SJPOs have a strong understanding of their respective fields, including patents and trademarks, the environment, labor, and food, but their expertise in criminal law and criminal procedure as a whole is considered a weakness. Yet investigations often require comprehensive judgments on whether the elements of a crime have been met, whether evidence was obtained lawfully, and whether compulsory investigative measures are necessary.


Prosecutors have until now played an important role in addressing these gaps. They have done so not only during compulsory investigative measures such as search and seizure or arrest, but also after receiving cases, by conducting supplementary investigations and examining from multiple angles whether a crime was committed. For example, a trademark infringement case could involve fraud in addition to a simple intellectual property (IP) infringement, while a trade secret infringement case could also give rise to allegations of occupational breach of trust. The prosecution service (the Public Prosecution Office) has reviewed criminal law issues beyond the scope of SJPOs' duties and helped clarify the full picture of cases.


These functions are inevitably likely to weaken. An official formerly with the Ministry of Intellectual Property said, "Cases that could previously be handled within a single investigative system under a prosecutor's direction are now more likely to be split between the police and SJPOs," adding, "Victim companies and members of the public may be inconvenienced by having to deal with multiple agencies and file separate complaints." The newly introduced system of "guidance and advice" also has limitations. Unlike investigative direction, guidance and advice are not legally binding. As a result, SJPOs may not receive sufficient legal support, while prosecution authorities may find themselves in an ambiguous position in which it is difficult to intervene proactively.


The success of the institutional reform ultimately depends on building SJPOs' expertise. In addition to strengthening investigative training, authorities should explore a range of measures, including personnel exchanges between the police and SJPOs and the establishment of internal legal support systems. The Seoul Metropolitan Government's Special Judicial Police Bureau is working to establish a committee of SJPOs centered on legal experts and operate an investigative advisory group. It also plans to strengthen its review of legal issues by hiring attorneys.



For the reform's goal of strengthening SJPOs' independence to be properly realized in the field, support at the national level and close cooperation among agencies must go hand in hand. It is hoped that this reform of the criminal justice system will help establish SJPOs as true public safety law enforcement agencies.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing