Lawsuit to overturn measure... Court finds abuse including corporal punishment and verbal abuse
Court: "Protecting children is an interest society cannot compromise on"

A father who was referred for case management by a child protection agency over allegations that he had abused his children sued to have the measure overturned, claiming defamation and other harms, but lost.


According to legal sources on October 26, the 12th Administrative Division of the Seoul Administrative Court, presided over by Judge Kang Jaewon, ruled against the plaintiff in a lawsuit filed by Mr. A against the head of Gwanak-gu seeking to overturn the measure referring him for case management. The court said, "Specially protecting children from abuse by adults and promoting their healthy development is one of the important legal interests that society cannot compromise on," adding that "the public interest in protecting children is no less important than the disadvantages Mr. A may face."


Seoul Administrative Court. The Asia Business Daily DB

Seoul Administrative Court. The Asia Business Daily DB

View original image

In October 2025, the Gwanak Police Station received a report of child abuse involving Mr. A and notified the Gwanak-gu Office. After an investigation, the district office concluded that Mr. A had physically and emotionally abused his children and, in January 2026, referred him to a child protection agency for case management. Mr. A then filed suit, arguing that his legitimate discipline of his children had been misrepresented as abuse.


At trial, Mr. A argued, "The acts of physically disciplining my children and making them leave school were decisions made as part of parental guidance and by agreement within the family." He also maintained that even if some abusive acts were found to have occurred, the disadvantages resulting from the measure, including damage to his reputation, were excessive and violated the principle of proportionality.


The court, however, rejected Mr. A's arguments. It first found that he had verbally abused and physically disciplined his children and forced them to drop out of middle school. In particular, it determined that repeatedly striking a child's thighs with a backscratcher was "an abusive act that went far beyond what could be justified as parental discipline." The court also found that making another child witness the assault constituted emotional abuse that could cause anxiety and psychological distress.


The court also rejected the claim that the children's decision to leave middle school had been made by agreement within the family. Based on statements from the children and their other parent, the court found that Mr. A had forced or encouraged them to leave school against their wishes. It also found that his use of severe insults toward a child constituted emotional abuse that caused humiliation and fear.



The court also rejected Mr. A's defamation claim. It found that a referral for case management is a measure requiring a perpetrator of child abuse to receive counseling and education, and that the fact of the measure is not disclosed to the public nor does it result in any separate disadvantage. The court said, "The risk of harm being concealed or minimized is greater in cases of child abuse by a parent," adding that "the public interest in this measure cannot be said to be outweighed by the disadvantages the plaintiff may face."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing