Separation of Investigation and Prosecution Leaves Companies Concerned:
"Uneasy About Applying to Investigative Agencies That Cannot Grant Immunity from Indictment or Recommend Reduced Sentences"
Prosecuting Authority Assigns Provisional Rankings from the Application Stage
Ensuring Certainty of Immunity
Original Materials Immediately Forwarded to Investigative Agencies

Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Prosecution Office has completely revised its relevant guidelines to ensure that companies that voluntarily report cartel activity (apply for leniency) have their legal status firmly protected from the earliest stage, it has been learned. The move is seen as an effort to ease companies' concerns that applying for leniency to an investigative agency without authority to grant immunity from indictment or recommend a reduced sentence could jeopardize their immunity status, and to close gaps in the response to cartels.


According to legal circles on October 25, the Prosecution Office completely revised its “Guidelines on Procedures for Applications for Sentence Reductions in Cartel Cases (Prosecution Office Directive)” on October 16, ten days ago. With its direct investigative functions abolished, the Prosecution Office has redefined its role: rather than directly investigating leniency cases, it will focus on receiving applications, assigning provisional rankings, forwarding cases to relevant investigative agencies, and making final decisions on reductions and rankings after cases are referred to it, including whether to grant immunity from indictment or recommend a reduced sentence.


The key aim of the revised directive is to resolve the “legal uncertainty” that companies applying for leniency may face under the separation of investigation and prosecution. Legal and business circles have long been concerned that even if a company confesses to an investigative agency, the decision could change at the Prosecution Office, which has the authority to indict, or that the applicant's status as a voluntary reporter might not be fully protected.


Recognizing that the sentence-reduction system is fundamentally based on prosecutors' discretion to prosecute, and allows them to decide whether to grant immunity from indictment or recommend a reduced sentence, the Prosecution Office has focused on having the prosecuting authority responsible for the final decision conduct a legal review and assign a “provisional ranking” from the application stage. The aim is to firmly protect applicants' legal status from the outset and maintain conditions that allow companies to confess with confidence.


Measures have also been introduced to ensure investigations proceed swiftly. Under the revised directive, when a leniency application is received by the Prosecution Office, the designated unit at the Central Regional Prosecution Office (formerly the Fair Trade Investigation Division) will review it immediately and assign a provisional ranking. All original submitted materials will be forwarded to the investigative agency without delay. The measure is intended to let the Prosecution Office first establish the reporter's legal status while promptly handing over the materials, enabling the investigative agency to independently begin compulsory investigative measures and avoid missing the window to act.

[Exclusive] Prosecution Office Overhauls Cartel "Leniency" Directive... Guarantees Reporting Firms' "Legal Status" from Outset View original image

A new application form has also been created to reduce procedural uncertainty and administrative waste that reporting companies may face because responsibilities are split between agencies. From the time an application is received, the form confirms in advance whether the applicant agrees to “share all submitted materials with relevant agencies” and to “cooperate throughout all criminal justice proceedings, including any subsequent investigation and prosecution,” helping ensure that the reporter's status and cooperation with authorities continue smoothly after the case is transferred to an investigative agency.


Safeguards have also been substantially strengthened. The directive stipulates that the Prosecution Office must notify applicants in writing immediately when a provisional ranking is assigned and when the final reduction ranking is determined. In addition, before making a final decision on a reduction, prosecutors must obtain the investigative agency's views and conduct at least one direct interview with parties to the case, including the applicant, as well as experts and personnel from relevant agencies. This is intended to ensure that the parties have ample opportunity to express their views and that prosecutors take those views into account in reaching a reasonable decision.


Procedures for communication between agencies have also been established to ensure that cooperation during the investigation carries through fully to a decision granting immunity at the prosecution stage. Investigative agencies may ask prosecutors for advice on the requirements for a sentence reduction at any point during an investigation. After a case is referred, prosecutors must obtain the investigative agency's views before deciding whether to grant a final reduction. These safeguards are intended to prevent a reporter's status from being jeopardized by a change of decision at the prosecution stage despite the reporter's cooperation with investigators, and to ensure that the reporter's actual contribution to the evidence is fully reflected in the final decision.


Under the system, the Prosecution Office is expected to administer leniency, while the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency (SCIA) conducts independent investigations after an investigation is launched, allowing the framework to become established. “It is most important to formally establish safeguards to protect reporting companies' legal status,” said a lawyer specializing in fair trade law. “The division of responsibilities should become firmly established: applicant companies should secure legal certainty about immunity from the initial stage, while investigative agencies such as the SCIA should use that foundation to promptly launch independent investigations.”



The full text of the revised directive is available through the National Law Information Center.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing