Focus on Ministry of Finance and Economy votes ahead of third committee meeting on October 26

Speculation that the ministry is seeking to keep the Financial Services Commission in check

Sh Suhyup Bank considers legal action over FIU fine, fu

With the selection of the next president of Sh Suhyup Bank having fallen through twice, a dispute has emerged between the Financial Services Commission and the Ministry of Finance and Economy over how the ministry’s representatives are voting. Adding to the controversy, Sh Suhyup Bank is belatedly considering filing a lawsuit to challenge a fine imposed by the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU), which is headed by Lee Hyeongju, a candidate for the bank’s next president. This has raised suspicions that the lawsuit is intended to help current President Shin Hakgi secure another term. With less than a month remaining in Shin’s term, controversy over the selection of the next president is escalating.


Shin Hakgi, current president of Sh Suhyup Bank, and Lee Hyeongju, head of the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU)

Shin Hakgi, current president of Sh Suhyup Bank, and Lee Hyeongju, head of the Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU)

View original image

According to financial industry sources on October 25, Sh Suhyup Bank plans to hold a third meeting of its President Recommendation Committee on October 26 to resume discussions on selecting candidates for the next president.


The race for the next presidency is a two-way contest between President Shin, an internal candidate, and Lee, a serving Financial Services Commission official. The committee consists of three members recommended by government agencies—the Ministry of Finance and Economy, the Financial Services Commission, and the Ministry of Oceans and Fisheries—and two members recommended by the National Federation of Fisheries Cooperatives. At least four members must agree to recommend a final candidate. At the two committee meetings held on September 22 and October 6, Shin received three votes and Lee received two each time, so neither was recommended.


Financial industry attention is focused on how the Ministry of Finance and Economy’s representatives will vote. Initially, the prevailing expectation was that the three government-recommended members would support Lee, while the two members recommended by the National Federation of Fisheries Cooperatives would back Shin. However, Kim Byung-gyu, an outside director recommended by the Ministry of Finance and Economy and a former head of the tax policy office at the former Ministry of Strategy and Finance, supported Shin, creating an unexpected three-to-two split. Lee had been expected to face an employment review by the Government Ethics Committee for Public Officials if he passed the committee, but he has now been blocked at the candidate recommendation stage. Inside the Financial Services Commission, officials appear taken aback, viewing the vote from the Ministry of Finance and Economy as an unexpected defection.


Some interpret the vote as reflecting the Ministry of Finance and Economy’s discontent with the Financial Services Commission. The ministry, a deputy prime minister-level organization, has seen its organization and functions scaled back following the separation of the budget office, and is considered to have lost some of its former standing in key economic appointments. Of the first ministers appointed to major economic ministries when the current administration took office, only the minister of finance and economy has been replaced. More recently, Kwon Dae-young, a former vice chairman of the Financial Services Commission, was appointed the ministry’s first vice minister. Moon Shin-hak, a former vice minister of trade, industry and energy, was also selected as senior presidential secretary for economic growth, a post traditionally held by someone from the Ministry of Finance and Economy. By contrast, the Financial Services Commission has raised its profile by leading key government initiatives, including productive and inclusive finance, curbing unfair trading in capital markets, and managing household debt. Moreover, with it having become harder under the current administration for officials to move into leadership roles at affiliated agencies or private-sector associations, some have suggested that the ministry may have been displeased with a serving Financial Services Commission official’s bid to become a bank president.


“Lee was seen as someone who could strengthen Sh Suhyup Bank’s competitiveness and help it become a financial holding company, thanks to his expertise in financial policy. But, as a serving official, he also faced controversy over whether his candidacy amounted to a political appointment or government interference,” one financial industry source said. “Even the government-recommended members were divided, and they couldn’t reach a consensus, making the controversy over government interference seem beside the point.” Another source said, “It is difficult to say whether the outside director recommended by the Ministry of Finance and Economy made an independent decision or was acting on the ministry’s wishes, but some interpret the vote as reflecting the ministry’s desire to keep the Financial Services Commission in check.”


However, some say it would be a stretch to view the ministry’s vote solely as the result of conflict between the two ministries. They suggest the members may have prioritized management performance and continuity, taking into account Shin’s efforts to expand the bank’s nonbanking business by pursuing acquisitions of asset management companies and securities firms. The controversy over government interference and possible conflicts of interest arising from Lee’s bid to lead the bank while serving as a financial regulator may also have affected their judgment.


Meanwhile, Sh Suhyup Bank has added fuel to the controversy over the selection by signaling that it may take legal action against the FIU’s fine.


Sh Suhyup Bank paid a fine of 1 billion won imposed by the FIU in March for violating customer identification requirements related to anti-money laundering. However, about seven months later, it is suddenly considering filing a lawsuit to challenge the penalty. Financial industry sources have focused on the fact that Sh Suhyup Bank raised the prospect of legal action after Lee entered the race for the next presidency, prompting speculation that the move may be intended to create conditions favorable to Shin’s reappointment. Challenging a fine is a legitimate right of a financial institution, but questions are being raised about the reasons for considering a lawsuit, since a legal dispute between the FIU and Sh Suhyup Bank could create a negative impression of Lee’s suitability as a candidate.


A Sh Suhyup Bank official said, “We understand that another bank that received a similar sanction is also pursuing a lawsuit,” adding, “We may decide whether to take legal action after seeing the outcome of that case.”


As the selection of the next president has shifted from evaluating the candidates’ management capabilities and medium- to long-term strategies to speculation about conflicts between ministries and allegations of attempts to discredit rival candidates, frustration with the selection process is growing. If the third committee meeting on October 26 fails to reach an agreement ahead of Shin’s term ending on November 17, the need to reopen applications is expected to come into sharper focus.



A financial industry source said, “There have been cases in the past when the committee repeatedly failed to recommend a candidate, and the bank ultimately appointed a president through a new round of applications. If the voting pattern does not change this time, the bank should seriously consider reopening applications to minimize any leadership vacuum.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing