[Korea Trips Sold at Bargain-Basement Prices] ② Low-Cost Group Tours Hinge on Shopping Sales

Ground Fees Fall from $150 to Zero... Agencies Now Pay to Bring in Tourists
Shopping Commissions Cover Costs... Weak Spending Can Mean Losses
Shopping Dependence Persists Despite Government Penalties
Disputes Over Travel Agency Settlements Leave Tourists' Itineraries in Limbo

Some domestic inbound travel agencies pay Chinese outbound tour operators 20,000 to 40,000 won per tourist they bring to Korea. This practice is known as a "Minus Tour Fee." Domestic agencies that cover accommodation, meals and transportation costs make up the difference with shopping commissions and revenue from paid optional tours. If tourists spend less than expected, the agencies can incur losses. Behind ultra-low-cost trips to Korea is a business practice that relies on tourists' shopping performance for revenue.


Settlement records obtained by The Asia Business Daily from a domestic inbound travel agency also confirm this arrangement. The 21 Chinese tourists who visited Korea from May 21 to 23, 2026, spent 1.86 million won on cosmetics. Two ginseng-related products were sold, while no hovenia-related products were sold. The domestic travel agency received 1.3 million won in shopping commissions, or only about 61,900 won per tourist.


The estimated ground-handling expenses for the group, including accommodation, meals and vehicles, were 140,000 to 150,000 won per person, or 2.94 million to 3.15 million won in total. Shopping commissions alone covered less than half of the expenses.


Separate settlement records show that 15 tourists took part in a paid optional tour costing 350 yuan per person. After commissions and expenses were deducted, 424,000 won was allocated to the travel agency. Combined with shopping commissions, its revenue totaled 1.724 million won, leaving a shortfall of 1.216 million to 1.426 million won against the estimated expenses. However, the final profit or loss may vary depending on whether separate settlements were made with the Chinese outbound tour operator and other factors.


Foreign tourists browse products at a cosmetics tax refund shop in South Korea. Photo provided by a reader.

Foreign tourists browse products at a cosmetics tax refund shop in South Korea. Photo provided by a reader.

View original image

Ground Fees That Once Reached $150 Fall to Zero... Now Agencies Pay to Bring in Tourists

Minus Tour Fees emerged as price competition intensified between Chinese outbound tour operators and domestic agencies that receive tourists in Korea. In the past, Chinese travel agencies paid domestic operators ground-handling fees for accommodation, transportation and meals. But as competition heated up, some cases emerged in which domestic agencies not only accepted "zero-fee" tours, where no ground fees were paid, but also paid Chinese operators to send tourists to Korea.


A travel industry source with experience in both Chinese outbound operations and domestic tour reception said, "The ground fee, which used to be $150 per tourist, fell to $100, then $50 and $30, before eventually reaching zero. These days, there are even cases where domestic travel agencies pay Chinese outbound operators 20,000 to 40,000 won per tourist."


Based on the expenses cited by the industry source, ground-handling expenses in Korea for a group of 30 would amount to 4.2 million to 4.5 million won. Adding a referral fee of 40,000 won per tourist would bring total costs to 5.4 million to 5.7 million won. Assuming the travel agency ultimately receives 50% of shopping sales as commission, shopping revenue of 10.8 million to 11.4 million won would be needed to cover the costs. That works out to 360,000 to 380,000 won per tourist. This is a simple calculation that excludes other revenue, such as income from optional tours; actual profits and losses vary according to each travel agency's contract terms.

The actual shopping commission revenue from 21 Chinese tourists who visited Korea from May 21 to 23, 2026, was 1.3 million won, just 44.2% of the estimated ground-handling expenses of 2.94 million won, calculated at 140,000 won per person. A Chinese-language commission schedule obtained alongside the figures specifies performance-based payments, including 3% of cosmetics sales and 10% of optional tour sales, as well as a condition that no additional commission would be paid if the tour leader did not cooperate with shopping or optional tours. Source: Settlement statement and tour leader commission schedule from a domestic inbound travel agency.

The actual shopping commission revenue from 21 Chinese tourists who visited Korea from May 21 to 23, 2026, was 1.3 million won, just 44.2% of the estimated ground-handling expenses of 2.94 million won, calculated at 140,000 won per person. A Chinese-language commission schedule obtained alongside the figures specifies performance-based payments, including 3% of cosmetics sales and 10% of optional tour sales, as well as a condition that no additional commission would be paid if the tour leader did not cooperate with shopping or optional tours. Source: Settlement statement and tour leader commission schedule from a domestic inbound travel agency.

View original image

Revenue Tied to Shopping Performance... Affecting Guides and Tourists

Shopping commissions are one of the main sources of revenue for travel agencies operating low-cost group tours. When tourists buy products at shopping centers included in their itineraries, commissions are paid to travel agencies and others based on sales. Such arrangements may be made under contracts between businesses to attract tourists and promote sales. However, if a travel agency does not secure enough revenue from basic travel fees, its profitability can vary significantly depending on shopping performance.


Whether tourists will shop and how much they will spend are difficult to predict in advance. Poor shopping performance can reduce a travel agency's revenue and affect guide compensation, as well as payments to vehicle and accommodation providers. Conversely, incentives to boost revenue by increasing shopping and optional tours may add to the burden on tourists.


Those in the tourism industry focus not so much on low-cost packages themselves as on operating models that fail to secure enough revenue from basic travel fees. They say a revenue structure is needed that allows agencies to provide the services promised, regardless of tourists' shopping performance.


Foreign tourists gather in front of a tax refund shop. Photo courtesy of a reader.

Foreign tourists gather in front of a tax refund shop. Photo courtesy of a reader.

View original image

Shopping Dependence Persists Despite Government Penalties... Tourists Bear the Cost

Similar business practices have also been uncovered in China. A 2018 Xinhua News Agency report on a Kunming police investigation found that local travel agencies paid Chinese outbound operators 100 to 500 yuan per tourist and received commissions amounting to 30% to 90% of sales at shopping outlets.


The Korea Culture and Tourism Institute also identified dumping and the use of shopping commissions to recoup losses as persistent problems in its 2024 report, "Measures to Create a Fair Environment for the Chinese Group Tour Market to Korea."


In May 2024, the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism imposed a one-month business suspension for the first time on a travel agency specializing in Chinese tours that had been caught forcing tourists to shop, among other violations. In July of the same year, it revised its operating guidelines to include zero-fee tours, forced shopping and failure to pay costs for tour interpreters among the grounds for penalties.


Tourists' spending habits are also changing. According to the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism, the share of Chinese tourists who went shopping fell from 95.1% in 2019 to 68.2% in 2023. Although independent travel and discretionary spending are on the rise, some low-cost group tours still rely on sales at designated shopping centers.


Jung Ji-yeon, a professor in the Department of Tourism at Hanyang University, said, "The problem is that the basic travel fee does not cover the cost of essential services, and agencies also fail to set aside funds to cushion the impact of weak shopping sales. When a land operator's revenue falls short, guide compensation may be cut or payments to vehicle and accommodation providers delayed, ultimately leaving tourists to face service disruptions." She added, "If the losses on cheap trips are covered through forced shopping and sacrifices by guides, that is closer to shifting costs onto others than offering a discount."



The incident on October 14, when more than 60 Chinese tourists were stranded for over three hours in Dongdaemun, Seoul, is also linked to this structure. A domestic travel agency halted bus services, citing the Chinese outbound operator's failure to pay ground-handling fees and weak shopping sales. The itinerary resumed only after the Chinese side transferred the outstanding ground fee of 27,500 yuan. The tourists had already paid for their trip in China. The incident illustrates how disputes between travel agencies over cost settlements can disrupt itineraries and shift the business risks of ultra-low-cost tours onto tourists.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing